ILikePie5's avatar

ILikePie5

Member since

ILikePie5


Wryly wrote:
Does anyone here really buy Pie just handing scum an early-game freebie on who his character is. Especially with them not being given fake claims. Like I'm really supposed to believe this is the first time in history that whimsy overpowered his practicality.


1) It wasn’t a freebie.

2) No one even guessed it

3) I gave up cause women have cooties


ILikePie5


Wryly wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

Wryly wrote:
I would like you to tell me why you softed early. Pie, you too.

FOMO lol

This is baffling coming from you lol


Shouldnt be. I’ve strategically soft claimed in games. And it wasn’t even a clear soft claim. Everyone was running with feminist until I actually claimed

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
Where did he say he extrapolated it

Not rereading but he said something along the lines of the character being described as needing to hide from the germans so he has to remain underground until the appropriate time.

He was never directly told that another faction was after him.

Helps please confirm


Did it for you. Read #45. He said scum were explicitly told about him

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
No, it’s built on the fact that Helz was told that scum knew about him being the Jew and dangerous.

No he extrapolated that from his PM and he's likely wrong


Where did he say he extrapolated it

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
You know that, not me. I’ll work on Mikal tomorrow

You know it also because your entire theory of why I was scum was built on assuming I am TP because of Helz mod confirmation and my fixation with jews


No, it’s built on the fact that Helz was told that scum knew about him being the Jew and dangerous. So you knew that, so you’re scum. You confessed to being TP. To me, it doesn’t matter whether you’re scum or town, you need to be eliminated

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
Ultra is 95% likely to be Scum or Town
A good 50% of that is TP a neutered one

So bring it back down to 50% and explain how Mikals justification and rule 4 can coexist if both are true?


You know that, not me. I’ll work on Mikal tomorrow

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
Let's say I have you 3 lottery tickets

  1. This one is guaranteed to be a million dollars
  2. This one is ,50% to be a million dollars

Now which do you pick in real life? Apply that to this game


Youre 95% likely to be TP or Scum

Ultra is 95% likely to be Scum or Town



Theres a difference

ILikePie5

The plan is clear. Lynch Wylted. If he flips TP, that means #1 is true and if NK is successful, we’ll be at 4-3 LYLO

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
Mikal scum slipped. This condition

All characters apply to the entire group of people in the race, gender, or organization it belongs to.

He posted a character explanation that only applies to Indians in call centers. Not all Indians.



That doesn’t make any sense




ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
We will believe u when you flip TP lol
You need to believe me no matter what I flip and yes the list is 100% accurate and this is assuming condition one is false.


Condition 1 can’t be false. You already confessed to being TP Lyncher



ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
This I can believe. Bro I have it narrowed though to

Mikal whiteflame and ultra.

And ultra is the easiest lynch to get here.


We will believe u when you flip TP lol

ILikePie5

Also, the fact that they NKed Thoth instead of someone who hadn’t full claimed is noteworthy. It makes it more likely that having a Tailor is the lie. And if that’s the lie, there are at least 2 Vanillas. Something to consider for the future

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
So compromise or surrender.
Compromise. Thanks for the option


I Meant no compromise or surrender lol

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
Confirmed scum team is

Mikal whiteflame and ultra.

It's very suspicious that you are TP hunting.

You do understand that if Mikal is not scum than it's obvious you are. Only one of you can be town.

I'm pretty sure I got this right though.

Mikal whiteflame and ultra.

The other option though less likely is

Pie, whiteflame and ultra.

Wanting to TP hunt doesn't reflect well on you.


In this household, we lynch Third Parties. So compromise or surrender. Only death.


ILikePie5


Wryly wrote:
If he's TP he counts as town for parity purposes. If he has no other abilities except the lynch-the-Jew one, he's toothless now. I'd say just keep him around if I knew his full role card. And scums', lol. Alas.


Nah we lynch TPs in this household. I’m not risking them siding with scum down the line. It could also be a scum gambit if #1 is the lie. Get that one resolved at the very least.

ILikePie5


RexFavilla wrote:

whiteflame wrote:

RexFavilla wrote:
Mikal's role sounds like the Germans. He's like Hans Landa from Inglorious Bastards - opening PMs and interrogating people, trying to sniff out (and snuff out) the Jews. It makes perfect sense for a lyncher to also be a neighborizer.

I can’t say I agree with this one. Don’t have a strong townread on Mikal, but him being a Neighborizer and a Lyncher seems like a lot.

Why? Neighborizer makes a lyncher's job easier. And he targeted you, who claimed softed a religion very early. It makes sense that he suspected that if someone is lying about being the jews it was you because if you are you came up with a religious 'fake claim' very early. That's more likely to come with someone with a religious 'real' claim.


I’ll just nip this in the bud. I was recruited first, not WF. Second, Luna names his Neighborizer as Masons. I already did the research

ILikePie5


Wryly wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

Wryly wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

Right now, I have more of a reason to buy WF as town than Mikal. WF is 90% town. Mikal is more like 65%

Are you basing those numbers on Mikal not being roleblocked

Yes at least partially

One of you could be lying about being roleblocked, so I'm not sure that should strengthen likelihood percentages.


Thats also a fair point

ILikePie5

WF and I have basically revealed that we have Active roles at this juncture. If anyone else was roleblocked, I would like to know.

ILikePie5


Wryly wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

Helz wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:
So I can confirm that WF is now in our Mason PM
Does your mason chat have a function that confirms you as town to etch other or is it more of a neighborhood?

It’s more of a neighborhood. Right now, I have more of a reason to buy WF as town than Mikal. WF is 90% town. Mikal is more like 65%

Are you basing those numbers on Mikal not being roleblocked


Yes at least partially

ILikePie5


whiteflame wrote:
So, during the night, Pie and I were both RB'd. I can't tell whether that's the result of a multi-RB scum role, or a Motivator being in play.

Can confirm this. The problem we have is if this was a full scale roleblock, why did Mikal not get roleblocked? Hence the Motivator

ILikePie5


wylted wrote:
said this yesterday in thread and PM, but I see a world where Ultra + Wylted are both scum. Especially with the recent posts. Lots of distancing going on imo
You have one indicator I am scum. The indicator is you don't think I have the capacity to be antisemitic when there is an excuse to be. There are multiple indicators ultra is scum. Just lynch ultra so you have the wiggle room to mislynch me later. For fucks sake. People follow you because that's the only way to shut you the fuck up. Use that power to save this game


Im not mod confirmed town. Helz is