ILikePie5
i was gonna produce a false result on mestari and claim WF messed with me. then i had to pray from there


Turtle OP lol

ILikePie5
Why does Mag1c's power say "your action failed" if aimed at the other guild anyway? Shouldn't it just always return false results?


It says False.



ILikePie5

Also, Banana/Kohai makes sense for for a team with Thoth/Alyssa. It explains the shitty claims and everything. Explains Kohai’s immediate claim, which prob took one of the fake roles.


If Banana flips scum and Kohai flips town, I would take a hard look at Mestari.

ILikePie5

Waive your Strengthener. Scum could redirect it to themselves and guarantee success on their action/NK

ILikePie5
What happens if awesome Strengthens me and your Jailkeeper is redirected onto me? My Cop would still go through, correct?


definitely

ILikePie5
Just got off work. Tomorrow morning I'll finish my reread before I go into work. Any particular questions anyone wants to throw at me or anything they want me to look at in particular?


Who are your top 3 scum reads and why?



ILikePie5
Was his role revealed in your groupchat? How about his target?


Both were, yes. But the only person who could’ve influenced it would be WF, and I don’t believe he’s scum



ILikePie5
Who did Mag1c target? Is there a possibility he struck an Ascetic scum or a scum with a Commuter?


I’ll let him reveal that. It’s possible, but unlikely imo

ILikePie5
  1. Does a roleblock always present as "your action failed"


I would presume yes


  1. What other roles can result in a "your action failed" message


Probably Ascetic or like BP Ascetic


ILikePie5
do u not remember? at this point in time we were working under the theory that someone in their guild was scum who had known who the cop was going to target and set them up to frame them. this was ur argument, and me and several others agreed with the logic. this is the same thing i was trying to hammer into helz brain later when he wasnt understanding why someone in their guild was likely behind the messed up result. this was not some big mystery pie. rex wasnt being forthcoming with info that we believed at the time would reveal a mafia member, so the vote was to help get him to understand the urgency. you voted before me here btw litrly two posts before i made my vote.


I know why I was voting him lol. I was asking why you were, and based on your answer it looks like you were just joining the consensus because everyone else did

ILikePie5
what are you talking about? my point is that whenver someone full pursues someone who is scum it gets dismissed as "tmi". or even the opposite, when i town read helz it got dismissed as tmi. but when im open to both sides its also scummy. ur bias towards me is on clear display. what did i do to make u dislike me so much lol


I never once used the TMI argument against you as far as I remember.


i dont see how its scummy that i am being open minded about ppl being town when ppl are also scum read for doing the opposite lol


Im pointing out that it’s odd that you defended both scum, however lightly and provided them with an out. But when it came to Shining, zilch.


helz....


Yes, but it’s different. You didn’t vote Helz, I’m pretty sure. And you were solid on him being town at the end of the DP.


If you voted him and scumread him at the end while also saying for the record, I townread him, I would agree that the situation is same. I don’t think that’s the case tho

ILikePie5
rex who still could be the mole in wrylys guild, but i also thot he had very oppertunistic scum read of me last dp, but i get that may be biased or omgus


There’s no guarantee there’s even a mole after Mikal basically confirmed that investigations on members of the other guild would yield a guilty result.


Can you expand on what was opportunistic?


awesome who has been pretty inactive but has a role that i think sounds liek a common fake claim, plus he was bandwagoning to get me lynched last dp for really bad reasons and semantics


What were the bad reasons and semantics? Can you expand on these?

ILikePie5
its funny that being open minded is scummy, and death tunneling scum is tmi lol u guys are hilarious sometimes. damned if i do, damned if i dont.


I mean thanks for confessing you’re scum.


sure, we are all human, and town make mistakes all the time. its not out of the realm of possibility. i still ended up voting for him.


it usually is.



That doesn’t answer my question. Both people, who just happened to flip scum, you provided a reasoning for them to be town. Did you do that for any of the people that flipped town?

ILikePie5
i didnt give an out to anyone, i just scum read them for different reasons than the ones everyone else was bandwagoning for.


No, you provided a town case for both of them. Thoth, you said you could see him brain farting I believe. Alyssa you said Popular is usually town