ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Magoroth wrote:
Also. Given the reactions on this thread. And how butthurt people are getting at me saying the rules were broken and Mikal’s audacity at saying he will count the game. Are you surprised that I was lenient? At least some players would’ve fucking left or gotten angry if I tried to enforce the rules.


If people like Kohai want to blame their loss on that, it’s utterly bullshit. Scum played like shit that game independent of angleshooting on not.


If you want to do an anonymous game on a site this small, you have to accept the consequences like people are going to know who is who from post style. That’s just the way it is on a site this small.


And on top of that, the entire game was scumsided to begin with. You let Thoth get replaced while he was on the chopping block, and don’t give me the “He was sick bs.” That literally gave scum a major advantage on top of an already major structural advantage with the setup.

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago

The whole getting mod killed to solve the game doesn’t even mean anything. The solution to that is simple. Mod kills are treated as the lynch for the day.


As for the whole figuring out who people were, it’s hard not to factor that in your read. And Mago was leanient towards the beginning. It’s pretty obvious Kohai was Caine since the first page.


And it’s up to the mod to determine the ramifications of the questions they choose to answer. The player can asks questions as they please to try to catch people in inconsistencies

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Bullish wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

And I would’ve joined u
naw dude lmao, Brand's wagon was at 3/7, you and banana were at 4/7, All you had to do was make a deal with banana to vote Brand and you both get spared.


There wasn’t appetite to lynch Brands blind + they hadn’t posted in a while. The replacement basically ended that wagon, which is why scum got a major advantage from that.

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Thoth wrote:
If Thoth hadn’t replaced out, which allowing that was bastard, he would have been the lynch for sure
It's so unspeakably bastard that I was sick and wanted someone who would be more active in my spot


Whatever helps you sleep at night lol

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Lunatic wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:


I didn’t “derail” it. I wanted the third person to be Brands. Luna was all gung ho about getting Pie
You tunneled that shit soooo hard just to be wrong. Like you focused so much on policy there for no reason, when we had an actual wagon on actual scum. The Banana mislynch was our only mislynch and it didnt need to happen, but it almost resulted in two town being mislynched. Though in hindsight that shit show was a treasure trove of behavioral analysis gold which could have resulted in us winning, who knows.


Bruh, I was right. There was one scum in Pie, Kohai, Banana. 2 scum if you didn’t force me to claim and we went with Brands, though that’s a different story.


If Thoth hadn’t replaced out, which allowing that was bastard, he would have been the lynch for sure

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Bullish wrote:
High key I'm gonna call pie an idiot for derailing that perfectly good scum wagon on DP1, and dragging the jailer into a miskill too.


I didn’t “derail” it. I wanted the third person to be Brands. Luna was all gung ho about getting Pie. As for telling Supa to kill me, it was simply to avoid the distraction. And it worked out in the end.


I had to be gone for the last 14 hours but if I was there I would have tried to rerail the Brand wagon.


And I would’ve joined u

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Thoth wrote:
I dunno why people were so opposed to a massclaim. I thought I was farming towncred by proposing it since I figured town would do it anyway.


Bruh what. Why would we mass claim DP1

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago

Angleshooting didn’t even win town the game. It was Kohai’s own behavior and inconsistencies.

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Helz wrote:
I had fun playing with you guys this game. I was kinda sad to see things get as toxic as they did.


Me and Luna are always chill. It’s part of the game to fake outrage.



I think its rather unfair to blame the host for the chronic disregard of basic rules. This community and its leadership probably needs to figure that part out if its ever going to grow a healthy mafia community. Second game out of 2 I have played here and I am constantly bothered by the conduct in games.


The problem is that you can’t ignore consideration of who people are. Because the pool of players is so small, it becomes very obvious based on posting who everyone is.


As for Mikal asking those questions to Mago. I see them as legitimate questions, and it’s up to the mod to consider the ramifications of answering questions. Mikal himself as mod doesn’t answer any questions, but when in doubt, No Comment is the best answer.


I do think the setup was very scum sided.


Very much so


I agree that Mestari's play individually was the the most impactful in the game.


Definitely. Luna and I had lost hope.


I am rather disappointed in my personal performance this game. Really struggled to engage and it was actually a huge problem for me to push my thoughts with my self imposed restriction.


Just play normally. It’s a team game. Half your job as town is to build the rapport with other townies.


Props to Kohai for their deep wolf play. I woulda turned on you after Brand flipped but that shit threw me for a loop. EoD I was struggling to reconcile my reads and just kept cutting back to "I do not fucking know but in every world I look at Brand is scum" kinda thing. I am sorry to hear your stepping back from mafia and I appreciate the tools you are creating for the community.


It was blatantly obvious if he read the previous game that he was scum. Especially in DP3. Those posts were very very bad

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago

Also to all my detractors, I didn’t factor in that where we’re 7 vanillas instead of 6, but we did have a 33% chance with Kohai, Banana, Pie. Would’ve been 66% if Thoth hadn’t been replaced out

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago

Also, Mikal was 100% right that I was screaming from my grave that Caine was scum. It was so obvious that idk how anyone was considering anything else. Every piece of DP3 was a direct variance from his previous town game

ILikePie5

Amber Endgame

ILikePie5 · 6 months ago


Magoroth wrote:
I ask that this game not be counted for anyone's win/lose. There were too many issues with stuff (I don't think scum lost because of these issues to be fair but it certainly didn't help)


Nah that’s bullshit. Thoth being replaced when he was on the chopping block should’ve never happened. That alone would’ve given town a major advantage

ILikePie5
So much talk about guild sabotage; my reaction is really? I didn’t see it. I felt like we worked together well and took out scum. I don’t think guild friction was nearly as much of a factor as mstari thinks it was lol but then again he was saying that alot throughout the game for some odd reason.


I genuinely wasn’t lying when I said Idrc about my guild winning. I was planning to out myself until Wylted yoloed, so we just played along with it

ILikePie5
-Pie was the most impactful on the mech side. Solid actions that shifted the game substantially. Even with the hard run of town getting scum after scum the game could have very easily and quickly been lost if not for their choice of actions. (also why I agree the game was scum sided for balance)


I’ve always said that mechanics/role analysis/justifications are my strong suit. The devil’s always in the details. My behavioral analysis is weaker, which is where if Luna and I are both town, we complement each other. Worked out really well this guy. I was proud of my DP1 behavioral Banana read tho lol

ILikePie5
We also caught Banana because of Pie's jailkeep, and Pie turtling on the last NP would probably have caught Mag1c as well.

I definitely give Mestari credit for the catch, but Pie was pretty instrumental in the win.



I also called Banana DP1 lol

ILikePie5

Sorry brotha. You shouldn’t have even been the lynch if we had know the Cop could investigate the other guild as guilty.

ILikePie5
I wish the NK were an ahead of a jailkeep in order of operations this game. Since night actions fail when you die, that means the NK has a roleblock built in. Important bc if you balance you games around NKs having RBs built in, you’re gonna give town one extra power. At which point situations where the NK isn’t the ultimate shutdown should be avoided. 


Nah, RBs have always blocked NKs and should process before NKs


I guess how the NP3 kill got blocked is fine. But say, if I had killed Pie while he jail kept me, my kill should’ve gone through with how Mikal treats NKs. The scenario never happened but Mikal confirmed the kill would fail there.


Nah hard disagree.


ILikePie5
I feel bad, I was definitely gonna lynch you. I was actually townreading you through most of the game until you voted awesome. I couldn't figure how a t!Kohai wouldn't be persuaded by my strengthened inno result on Rex.


Rule #1 with Kohai, he’s just no bueno

ILikePie5
Good job town! My reads were shit this game so it's good that scum screwed themselves over, and that the rest of the town played well overall. Banana and Magic played very well imo after their teammates got ejected, they just got PoE'd hard mechanically.


Only reason we killed you is cause you were inactive :/


Didnt want to risk another situation where scum just cruised