#ProudMonkey
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
#ProudMonkey
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Vote Count
Helz (6/7) Mestari, Rex, Mag1c, Kohai, Pie, Shining
Shining (3/7) Helz, Vader, Banana
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
ya i think he is bein stubborn. and i think theres a good chance if ur results were messed with it was rex. idk he just feels so town here.
Why though? Just cause he keeps refusing to claim or because he’s still talking to us? I’ll note that Thoth did the exact same thing
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Just waiting on Wryly and WF
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Well feel free to push my guild mates to hear what I was really up to. I constantly shoved that Alyssa was scum in our guild chat and was very clear that I wanted town to take positions I could use to hunt so the train would not be worthless.
This cuts back to why I understand the general players suspecting me but my guild mates doing so is some bullshit.
How does this have anything to do with the “questioning” of Thoth
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
You are confused here again. NP2 the doctor healed Mag1cman. NP1 I was role blocked because our guild recruited and could take no action. And I also never claimed my protective function was doctor.
Same diff. I know you never claimed that. I’m assuming that it’s some variant. If it’s self use, which I likely think it it, then I don’t buy you being town at all.
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Well 3 things factored into my decision there.
1- Our guild leader had a full protective function. If we chose to we could have turtled and blocked the majority of killing functions for everyone in the guild.
But with the Doctor, everyone can still use their role and you can protect Luna. And even if scum were to target, they would target REF, not Wryly, which is what the plan was right?
2- Poison was outed. Figured there was some kinda healer at play. (Weird world potential there still that I will not unpack)
So? NP1, you knew that the Doctor would target the Poisoned. What if someone was poisoned again? The Doctor would have to divert from being on either Luna/Wylted to the poisoned.
3- This community seems to really struggle with using any analysis thats not mech centered. As I make arguments and do deep analysis I can feel peoples eyes glossing over. I do not even know if a single other person bothered to even read through Thoth's ISO which is just nuts. Figured if the only thing you guys will hear is a result I should go for one.
People read through it, which is why Alyssa was lynched, and why you’re on the chopping block for that “questioning” you did at the end of the DP. I find it staged because Thoth has never done that before. Ever. And the fact he was interacting with you, especially after you were the one blabbering about information information information, is scummy to me.
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Lol now he’s backtracking
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
So Helz chose a Tracker over let’s say Doctor NP2. If he had chosen a Doctor, he could’ve used it NP3 ie tonight.
That guarantees he could’ve protected either Luna or Wylted NP3. Only one could’ve died by NK during NP2, but the other could be protected NP3
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Yall see my point right lol
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
What’s there to be confused about. You agree that by NP3 you would’ve had a protective ability. You couldn’t have known Wylted was gonna be dead. So logically you could’ve useed it on him NP3
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
......Because that has not happened yet and Lunatic was killed NP2?
What? You knew that you would be able to use the protective roles NP3. Both Wylted and Luna can’t die NP2
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
I literally could not have.
I was role blocked being in a guild as my guild recruited. The only action I could take N2 was to ask daddy for 1 of 2 items. I had no ability to protect anyone that night.
Why couldn’t you have protected Wylted NP3?
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Link doesn’t work for me
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Ignore link part ^
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
You do realize it takes me one turn to request the item and another to use it. I have been rather clear about that. It would be absolutely impossible for me to have protected Luna given my guild recruited Wryly N1 and I was role blocked.
You could’ve protected Wylted though. Also, still waiting on that link
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Link me to the guide you created again? I want to see something
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
cant we lynch shining? i dont feel good about helz
He’s very obviously bluffing. If he didn’t have a self protective ability, he would’ve used that first to potentially protect Luna/Wylted.
Remember how Thoth proclaimed his innocence even after being lynched. He’s never done that before. Ever. The continuation screams a higher level of thinking that only a couple of people have. Alyssa shutting up after self voting?
Magicman being poisoned? It’s all a story, and he hasn’t said anything to disprove it
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Well let me ask you this, What does it change to prove my alignment for me to claim how my protective function works? Its a protective function. Obviously there is advantage to that staying hidden.
I’ll answer this for you:
1) We already have a protective role claimed
2) It’s possible for other protective roles to exist (has in fact happened multiple times)
3) It possible for you to be CCed and if that doesn’t happen we feel better about you
4) I’m the most important person alive, so your ability has a direct impact on me being alive
5) The fact you didnt ask for the protection ability to use instead of tracker is an interesting decision
And past that bullshit what even is the case against me? As I have repeatedly said Rex or Wryly can verify looking through chat that over and over I was actively working to keep myself as a mid read for town. Nothing I have said or done I will have any trouble explaining and I have town motivation for everything I have done. If the town does not want to vet me and instead kill me because the meta is "Reveal absolutely every bit of your role" this site is again like the monkeys with the button doing things without having reasoning why.
So kill me. Or kill the extremely likely scum Shining. Either way I am good with.
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
So something of my principles for playing mafia.
Each player has a duty to try to read and figure out other players.
Also each player has a duty to try to allow others to read them.
In this situation I am bending over backwards answering every question asked of me and just not revealing a tiny piece of my role which everyone can see would cause harm to town play to be known yet thats what I am being killed for as people ignore the rest and do not bother to vet me with reasoning.
I feel like you have trouble understanding . Everyone has already stated they have behavioral reasons for scum reading you. We are willing to give you a chance to prove us wrong by full claiming (we afford that chance to everyone). Your rebuttals don’t exonerate you at all. They are insufficient as everyone has stated multiple times.
Acting like you’re only being lynched because you refuse to claim is factually incorrect. Everyone has given you significant opportunities to respond to them, and we have also shown a willingness to move onto Shining. You’re holding town up. There are guaranteed townies on your wagon who scumread you and are asking you for mechanical information to make them feel better about you. You refusing that makes us feel like you’re hiding something. At this point, scum already know you have some protective role, so there is ZERO harm in revealing it.
Have at it. This is your sites meta? Do it then. Hammer. But on the flip feel stupid.
Sure, we’re all willing to admit when we’re wrong. But if you’re a townie, you’re not doing everything to make other townies feel better. Is it worse to reveal the information you have or get lynched as town. The answer is simple.
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
How about me compromise. You reveal everything and we switch to Shining
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Say your justification again?
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Aight, I don’t think it’s town confirming regardless. TP is more likely
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Welcome back. Post full reads and thoughts on Melz
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Helz asked to leave in chat and Mikal said he could leave but his wincon is still tied with the guild. It's kind of mindfucking me. If he's scum his wincon isn't tied with the guild.
Mikal said that in chat?
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Vote Count
Helz (5/7) Mestari, Rex, Mag1c, Kohai, Pie
Shining (3/7) Helz, Vader, Banana
Awesome (1/7) Shining
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
I know Wylted would be offended because he’s black
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
You’re acting like there’s no behavioral reasoning for lynching you lol. Multiple people including myself have pointed them out and we haven’t received responses besides “I was acting like TP to challenge myself.” That literally means nothing
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
You’re acting like having a protective role makes you town. We already have a Doctor
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
In yalls hands now