He's scum looking to milk as much info before he gets lynched as possible and/or he and some of the other players are in Wylted's guild and are trying to pump for information on the rival guild even if it hurts town.
How does answering one small question give me any sort of scum benefit
I'm not giving any information about my guild or my role. If you want to lynch the cop, go ahead. Otherwise, we should just lynch Pie. If he wants to stop it, he can pull out this innocent-proving thing that he's holding up his ass and slap it on the table. He's scum looking to milk as much info before he gets lynched as possible and/or he and some of the other players are in Wylted's guild and are trying to pump for information on the rival guild even if it hurts town.
Just answer if you told your guild. Yes or no? Simple
My entire thing is simply that it potentially causes harm to the town for Rex to claim. Outing guild members is a bad idea and harmful. Nailing down his PR is also a bad idea and harmful unless you want to argue that Rex is scum (which you are not.)
No it doesn’t because scum could’ve been recruited. When Luna was leading it, we knew for certain that he was telling the truth about everything.
He already outted his PR lol. He said he’s the Cop. I believe him. It will all make sense when I claim. Mestari gets it. Listen to him
Im fine just parking my vote here as I get back to digging on other things and I do hope you are confirmable but I only see harm in having Rex claim a bunch of potentially harmful information.
If people who you townread are telling you that you are wrong, then maybe you should listen to them.
They put themselves out there as a revealed cop in a situation where it makes zero sense for a scum to do so. They have already painted a target on their back to push you. Demanding more of them is unreasonable for the moment imo.
I also said lynch me TODAY if you don’t like my reasoning. Why would I put that target on my back.
If Pie is something confirmable they should just confirm it. Demanding a full role claim in this situation is rather absurd. I do not see any world where that makes sense and I do not understand why people see it as a bad thing to require Pie to feed his info first.
Because I’m telling you to lynch me in the event that my explanation is not satisfactory to you lol. If I’m scum, why would I tell you this.
I do se harm in requiring a claim from Rex. We out PR's and we feed a possible scum outs they can manipulate by knowing specifics on the claim against them.
He already claimed Cop. The entire town knows he’s a Cop. Anyways, idec if he characters claims and claims his justification, though he should. I’m just asking him to confirm he told his entire guild.
Im really not sure how everyone is missing this simple issue. We risk harm to the town by demanding Rex to claim first and risk nothing by demanding Pie to claim first. If Pie is confirmable then he can simply show as much and we can move on.
Again, you and everyone else have failed to articulate, what “harm” there is. He’s a claimed cop. As soon as he confirms he told his entire guild, I will prove everything. What harm is there in REF answering that tiny question, especially if it yields a confirmed townie?
Im catching up but you 10,000% absolutely do not need 'all the details.' You should be the one giving the details before Rex gives any. The only thing I see you being fed details about Rex doing is giving you room to craft a better lie. If you can prove yourself then you do not need details to do so.
Better lie to do what? I’m telling you to lynch me TODAY if it’s not satisfactory
That doesn’t prove anything about Pie. He could just be saying that to buy time or if he’s scum so he can get another action in. He’s also not going to admit when he gets caught
Buying time for what? What action?
I’m telling you that you can lynch me TODAY, if I can’t prove innocence
Your reads are requested
Also forgot to post this, but here is Heroes of Olympus Mafia, which I modded. Earth = Shining
The fact that nobody aside from me knows why Pie is town is also why DC Mafia is nowhere near the level DDO Mafia was.
Only a few people pay attention to detail on this site. I’m one of them and WF/Magic are the others
You didn't start the Thoth wagon. You voted without any context and without any indication that it was anything more than RVS. I started the Thoth wagon. Sit down.
Now you see my point? He’s stupid. This is the guy who was told by scum that he was scum and still voted with him
Kohai hasn't exactly appeared town to me very well, and for all your talk about me being inactive Casey hasn't posted more than me either.
Why doesn’t he appear town to you? Casey is on the list of getting claims too dw
So why haven’t you been confirmed yet?
Im waiting for REF to confirm
Why should he lynch Casey or Kohai?
Did you read a single word I posted?
You’ve had several hours to clear yourself…. it shouldn’t take this long
Are you autistic?
As I said, completely sus. The role is dodgy af, can't be verified, and the justification makes no sense. Him being the third player in scumchat is very believable in light of Thoth and Alyssa's plays. He's the lynch here. Unless you cannot satisfactorily prove your innocence, in which case I'll be in a more difficult spot.
Which I shall dw
As I suspected, Rex ain't online and I have to wait til tonight or later for my juicy, juicy data.
Y'all are really cock blocking my instant gratification here. Literally blocking my instant gratification with your cocks. Mm-hmm.
There’s a lot more to talk about like what your thoughts are on Shining’s claim
Dude, getting a red check on you and still making demands like you're not the one with evidence against him.
If Kohai or Shining or someone were like "yeah I'll prove my innocence later let's just move on" no one would let them get away with that shit lol.
If they were saying they could 100% prove they were town, then yes, I would make REF answer one tiny question
So we have team "just give Pie what he wants" and team "just give Rex what he wants". I'm now firmly on the second team out of pure counter-culture spite lol. Everyone always sides with Pie and lets him get away with shit they'd never let anyone else get a pass on, like remora latching onto a great white.
Love you though Pie. ❤️ May your eyes stay black and your teeth sharp.
What am I “getting away with” lol
Lol come on this is just a power trip at this point. I don't want to wait around for Rex to come back online, and even once he does we're just gonna waste time with a pointless macho standoff. For once in your mafia career, just put your cards down first! It won't kill you lol.
It’s one sentence for the price of a confirmed townie
Just say if you told your guild mate that you were investigating me. Because they’re likely scum
By my count there's only one other person in the White Tigers, assuming Lunatic recruited again. Proving your innocence right now could narrow our suspects dramatically. My advice is to give Rex reason to doubt his guildmate, not to uncompromisingly demand info while ceding nothing in response to his evidence against you. I think from Rex's responses it's clear he did tell his guildmate, so stop looking for him to admit what we already know, and give us something.
I want it in explicit writing first
You are going to have a field day at the end of this
VOTE COUNT
Awesome5000 (2/7): Shining, Mag1c
Pie (4/7): Rex, Helz, Wryly, Kohai
Did you even read what I said?
You will be rewarded dw
Also, your argument is that you can prove your innocence later, so let's hunt other suspects now. All I'm saying is let's reverse that order. Get your innocence proven so we can eliminate you from POE and move on.
Im literally asking for one small piece of info. A simple yes or no question
Just answer yes or no if there is another person in your guild that u told this info to
Distract and escalate pressure on another target in hopes of it leading to a quick lynch and escaping to the next DP. Also I don't know what the Ant King has in his arsenal and I'm wary of that; could be you're cooking something that could get you out of this. Your strategy as scum is always to stall, deflect, and use offense as defense.
I will commit to not lynching anyone but myself. Does that make u feel better?
unvote
Yes, scum Pie claiming to be confirmable while he tries to shift his wagon to another target... unheard of.
Bruh I’m saying lynch me TODAY if what I say in inadequate
