ILikePie5

The “socially conditioned” is a real strategy whether you like it or not. I’ve caught scum all day long based on their character, role, and justifications. You think it doesn’t work. I’m telling you that it works.


Everyone here thinks behaviorally you’re not town. We can lynch you without you full claiming. But we recognize that our reads can be wrong. So we’re giving you a chance to reveal everything. If you were a Cop for example, everyone would realize they’re wrong, Unvote you, and move on.


You also need to realize that there are at least 4 townies on the wagon who scumread you whether it’s behaviorally, mechanically, whatever. It’s your job to convince your fellow townies that you are town. Everyone knows their reads may be wrong. You acting like you’re obviously town is disingenuous and dis nothing to dissuade the scumread on you.

ILikePie5

There’s a reason there are only like 10 pages usually in our 9p games. Not everyone engages. It’s impossible to get people to engage. Your idea is right in the sense that people should say as much shit as possible and ask questions, but people don’t no matter how many times you tell them. Shining is the prime example.


I read your guide. There’s good stuff in there, but the problem with it is that humans themselves don’t follow logic. Kohai is a prime example of that. All your theory works if there’s logic in the game. But there’s only a few people with the level of logic and brainpower and town to actually play the game.

ILikePie5

You also should know that only some people are enough to continue arguing with you. One of them being me. There’s a reason why in normal games

ILikePie5
What I just told the guild as well is that I will flip town but go after shining afterwards. This was a stupid elimination but I do not even have much to argue against or anyone vetting me so just get on with it. In future games you will know that a refusal to claim a part of a role does not equate to any sort of guilt.


And we will lynch you every time. You’re lucky Luna isn’t here lol. He would be all over you for this.


And really hopefully the town starts to scratch their head and say "Wait, why do we demand role claims to begin with...." You guys fucked this all the way up.


We demand role claims as a last resort to ensure we aren’t lynching a Cop or something. It’s pretty easy. If you were transparent, we can work out your motives and what you did.

ILikePie5
No. I have not ever payed against my win condition and I will not. You guys want to do a stupid its on you


You literally said you played to act like a TP lmao. But it’s anti-town to not claim. Everyone here recognizes that. If you want to throw, which this is what it is, then you can throw. If a mod confirmed townie is asking you to do something, then you do it.

ILikePie5
That is this elimination. Without knowing why I am going to be killed because I do not full claim. Without questioning if there is a town or scum motive or how that would solve the game in any way its what we are going to do. Your meta social conditioning is a joke and I just shrug and say "Do it then" and your gona act like its my fault when I flip town. But you are the conditioned monkeys not thinking things through in this situation.

Go ahead and do it. I am not going to play less optimal just because you have a rehearsed norm of demanding a full claim.


You are being killed because you are the likely leaker. You had incentive to poison Mag1cman. You made a complete 180 with lynching the unCCed Cop. And you refuse to claim, which is exactly how we verified that Alyssa and Thoth were scum.


Town’s job is to not get lynched. Your “motives” and their AI are subject to WIFOM. If you think your role isn’t going to be adequate for us to switch to another wagon, fine, but you’re not even trying

ILikePie5
And I told you multiple times I am 100% good with being eliminated and will not give you a claim. And that even having a full claim does nothing to prove my alignment.


Then follow the steps of your fellow scum and vote yourself. Save us some time

ILikePie5
Like really, In what world do you say "Dude is scum" and have no interest in their reads and shit. Lol. Could not even make this up


Why does everyone have to interact with you to do stuff? I already told you that ur going to be lynched if you don’t claim. And you’re throwing by refusing to claim. In the off chance you’re town, say who you think are the 2 scum and why


ILikePie5
You guys just have some default "Full claim or die" thing but your turning the brain cells off asking why you are even doing that. If I have 2 people that can confirm I was role blocked for most of the game and took exactly 1 action and I confirm what that action was demanding the rest is just you wanting info. Nothing actually AI in the current situation. Do what you want with that. 


You can’t confirm anything. You can’t confirm you even took the action.




ILikePie5
I feel I owe you an apology. I may be frustrated with the game but it was not cool for me to say what I did. I do view you as a strong player and I should not have said that to you. I can only say that I am sorry and vented on you. Regardless of what happens I was out of line there. I was wrong for saying that to you.


Lol it’s fine, it’s just a game. Me and Luna have duked it out many more times and it was far, but we’re still chill. What happens in the game stays in the game.


That said, full claim or be lynch. You have till 8pm CST before I tell everyone to vote you

ILikePie5
Can't find anything on Yoo Jinho and goggles. Give me the scoop.


He’s probably making shit up lol. Why would anyone give him shit vs giving it to the guild leaders

ILikePie5
Orrrr you have actively hindered it by refusing to just sort yourself and then making demands that are not even AI. 


Lol, I have already said the leaker is scum and I think you’re the leaker, which means you’re scum. That’s either you or REF. I buy REF’s role with Wryly’s role and Luna’s flip.


Also, roles are AI lmao. We proved it with Thoth and Alyssa.


Your use to doing this robotic thing where you demand a claim. Ok. Great... Exactly how does it help you sort my alignment to know that I can track people? What possible piece of information right now is useful about that?


Because if you claim something that fits the puzzle, I’m willing to move on. But you refuse to, so you’re going to be lynched. It’s anti-town at best to not full claim, especially when you’re on the chopping block.


ILikePie5
Nothing, afaik. What he said in guildchat was that all investigative results targetting him are randomized. I guess this could be what Helz is calling Miller, but I have no idea. 


He said in his monologue that REF was hiding something



ILikePie5
Then lynch me you dunce. People kept acting like your some super strong player and I just do not see it. I see a power tripping mid level player with little understanding of how the game works. You can not get over your own hubris far enough to lead the town. 


You haven’t seen my bingo sheet lol. I’ve led town to failure sure, but I’ve led them to victory far more. And being forced to full claim predates even me. People who refuse to full claim get lynched, because townies listen to other townies and try to stop themselves from getting lynched.


I bet Shining is laughing their ass off watching this interaction.


Yep, you’re actively hindering a lynch on him by not full claiming.

ILikePie5
So to start I was given an invite to join a guild. My role I considered weak. I felt that the benefit of having a confirmed town with a chat was much more of an asset to me. I prefer to win games though actually being good instead of taking a lucky action anyways. Pre-game I even flatly told Pie I intended on open wolfing. https://discord.com/channels/1390507525673189466/1390511970310033428/1488710968019259473 (Discord link to the post) They said they would insta lynch and I said "Challenge accepted." Woulda pulled this shit regardless of my alignment roll. (Eyh Pie, You did not do it brah~)


That was an obvious troll but whatever, don’t really care.


Something about me personally I have said multiple times in my guild chat- I got tired of winning a long time ago. Now I set challenges for myself to make things interesting. This was one of them. I very specifically wanted to open wolf and when I rolled town I decided it would be fun to see if I could invert the game. Glorious situation when someone is viewed as 3p in Lylo and becomes kingmaker then demands the other players argue about who is more scummy as opposed to more town. Those were my goals for this game. I feel I was on track with people suspecting me so much as 3p. I bet a handful of you do not even know why you think I am 3p instead of mafia with all the bullshit I was doing : )


So you were playing contra to your wincon so that you could challenge yourself.


A) That’s stupid

B) That’s selfish


Over and over through my guild chat I voiced effort to be viewed as 3p. As people suspected me I reinforced their suspicion. Was actually a point of humor that I had to work so hard to be suspected that we had a lot of banter about in guild chat. I did a lot of work there trying to be midrange read insulating myself from KPN and setting up for a potential glorious 3p claim that would have been fucking epic and hilarious. Either of my guild mates can verify this and its not hard to see it if you Iso me as I constantly ramble about wanting to eat your children and how I am the most evil. At some point D1 I think someone even called me out and I said something along the lines of "Holy fucking shit what does it take to be scum read in this community" as I was also trying to play a lynchbait move D1 that did not pan out. Idea being you make yourself look scummy and bait an opportunistic wolf to bite then you dig. Kinda some FPS bullshit but very effective D1 strategy imo.


No one suspected you besides Magicman and Wylted basically lol


As our guild chat started I voiced heavy concerns about us outing roles and projecting intended actions. I was very up front about the fact that our discord chat would allow anyone joining after the fact would mean they can read anything posted and we should hide such information as it gives us no benefit. I also created a plan that even the guild leaders action should be vague. They should not confirm exactly what they will do but instead take advice from the guild on what should be done.


And that’s where Luna did it wrong. His job is to sort through the bs. If you think someone is scum, you shouldn’t be recruiting them in the first place.


Rex claimed Miller right off the bat as well as their action. Not sure if they have claimed it but no good in me saying what that is.


Oh so he’s holding something back. Let’s hear it. I’m sure Wryly knows too. I would like to hear it.


This is something I never let go of. I voiced to Lunatic that at any moment they wanted they could demand my claim and I would give it to them. I also cautioned that I did not think it was a good play.


Reverse psychology, nice


N1 Lunatic asked me if I felt we should recruit or use actions. I voiced that developing more power for the town was what I favored. I flatly voiced that I felt my power was underwhelming and not worth not recruiting.

For D1 I agreed that Thoth was scummy. I was the first (and only) person to really shove Alyssa. I also hammered Thoth while pushing them really hard for information. I tried to keep them engaged as I milked them for information. Everyone wagoned Alyssa post Thoth flip and in D2 I maintained in my guild chat that I felt they would flip scum but I had concerns. Lunatic even gave me shit about how much I was shoving them D1 in our chat to look at Alyssa and now that Alyssa was the elimination train I was pumping the breaks. I wanted real reasoning I could work with. That did not happen. I got a bunch of people regurgitating the same talking points and with a mafia flip we had a useless train and no counter train.


So you want to take credit for lynching Alyssa lol. Nice


So yeah. I bitched at the town EOD2. Honestly towns macro game has been dogshit imo. Do what you want with my opinion there. Play some Bon Jovi living on a prayer as you lean on mech demanding claims and shit.

So D2 rolls around. Now I get Castin in our chat. They reported an inno check on Alyssa at some point. I missed it in the guild chat. Was not bothering to keep up with chat and am kinda low effort this game tbh. After the fact I did question that asking why they did not fight harder to defend Alyssa if they had a hard cop check on the player. This is where my distrust of them started. Somewhere in D2 Lunatic brought up that I was the only one in the chat not to claim and I again offered them to full claim or give a half claim preventing the harm of a full claim. They declined.


So then why were you talking about all the manipulation possible when you’re talking with me lmaoo


Really stupid lynch plays out. Hit a mafia- cool... We got nothing from it because towns macro was utter garbage. I wanted things I could work with later. Voiced multiple times that the game is chess not checkers and I wanted more. We got a good flip that set town up late game for failure imo. Yes it was the conclusion but we should have created so much more.


Everyone repeatedly asking you what you wanted lol.


Now D3 kicks off. Castin has a red check on pie. Ok.. Their previous green check on Alyssa was obviously bad (and this was before they were in the guild and they handled it oddly imo) but sure. Our guild leader was killed and I pushed that we should angle the situation pushing a read based shove on Pie. I was building it but struggling a bit. Rex just went yolo Leroy Jinkens claiming the hard action before I was able to post and I pushed with pressure. Cool thing that it was hiding our alignment cop that was unknown to even be a part of our team which we did discuss but obviously landed on a confirmable town. This makes 2/2 of Wyrly's results being flatly wrong. Interesting bit there. We go down this entire train of stupid as Pie refuses to verify and I push in guild chat that they should get no info until they claim. (Still have zero understanding why that was even a subject of contention in the day chat. Wtf..)


Cause you’re just dumb. There is no scum motivation to do what I did.


That plays out and at some point Rex decides to blow up the team. I have said my piece in guild chat about that. Rex has been a ghost sense they outed me. I have pinged them and offered to interact- they have nothing to say so far. Wyrly has been pressuring me to get with the sites meta and that I should claim which is a good look. They seem genuinely upset that I am not willing to give you guys a claim. 

Thats a decent overview of what I have done this game. You guys do not get access to the 1-2k posts I have made in guild chat as I sort and hunt but I did give my people a fucking ear full about how I understand the DP players suspecting me while I feel its absolute bullshit they could not sort me in guild chat. A whole truckload of stupid got dumped on a pretty simple situation. Shining has a claim that looks fake and Pie had a red check that got sorted. 

Ehhh, But yeah. Ask me for whatever and I will give you my thoughts. But here is my role claim

"You are Helz
Passive- 
You will tell everyone to go fuck themselves if they play in a stupid way and demand information thats not even AI
Active-
You have a tracking function. Its a thing.
You have another function. Wont ever be spoken of until my flip.

Do what you guys want with that. Feel free to milk me for information if your gona go down that road. I will respond as long as I am around the computer.


Nothing you said makes me feel better besides maybe the fact that REF is hiding something. Full claim or be lynched. Idrc

ILikePie5
Uh hu. Thats what I said eyh? Just actually read my next post. We may disagree on strategy but I will unpack what I have done and why.


I’ll read whatever you want me to read, but you’re not going to get out of full claiming

ILikePie5
Caught up with the thread now. I have a decent bit to say but quite honestly, Im not getting with your sites bullshit meta. Will write a wall explain what I have done and why this game though. 


Forcing people we think are scum to claim is now bullshit meta? Wow


ILikePie5
After a back-and-forth with Helz in guildchat it seems clear he's not going to claim in the DP. I'm pretty frustrated, so yeah, consider my vote on Helz. In the interests of not putting him at L-1 just yet I'm not VTLing. I'd like to discuss Shining a bit more. Still haven't decided if they're both scum, one scum and one 3P, one scumchat scum and one Lost Wolf, or what.


I’d be frustrated too. Your entire team plan blown up by Pie and Wylted lol. If he doesn’t want to claim, that’s fine. We will treat him just like how we have treated everyone else. He probably still thinks I’m bluffing, which I’m not. It’s anti-town for him to not claim.