ILikePie5
Can't believe you were still sussing me when I had to practically be held back from coming clean after Pie's innocence confirmation. And I was the one arguing with Helz in guildchat and being like "Helz put yourself in their shoes..." and "nah Banana is right..."

You - you're not my real guild dad!


It’s okay, the big bad mafia can’t hurt you anymore. Daddy Pie to the recuse!

ILikePie5

Also, Helz should go first. If he refuses, then we can push it to tomorrow. Both my guild members know each other’s claims so they can verify each other if I die

ILikePie5
Sure. But anyone we're not confident about goes before me. Fair?


Dunno if we’ll ever get Casey. Let me ask Mikal if he can replace her

ILikePie5
I know Helz isn't town. I just reckon they may also not be mafia, unless maybe they are lost wolf and had no knowledge of who they partners were.


I think they’re probably Mafia for a couple reasons. They character claimed for no reason in DP1. And Mag1cman was poisoned. He was suspicious of Helz. With Alyssa having the Poison, it makes sense they coordinated that in addition to whatever Redirector or role they have

ILikePie5
Since the cop and doc are already outted, let's mass claim. I've softed multiple times so I'll go last.


I know my guild’s full claims. I would prefer you go before them. I fully townread both of them.

ILikePie5
Nah, going back to work. If I give a claim I will give one of two functions. I will never give a full claim. You can have it on my flip


You’re not in a position to negotiate. You think I’m bluffing. You can ask anyone in the game, and they will two you that I’m not

ILikePie5
Well I’m adulting. Probably never going to full claim. You guys can pretty much go fuck yourselves there.


Oh believe me. We will. You’re not the first one.


Yes I lied about rejecting the guild invite. I worked to angle myself as a mid range town read for kill insulation and prior to game starting set myself the goals of open wolfing and trying to invert the game if I got to LYLO.

I have not trusted Rex from the start of my guild situation because they claimed a hard killer function. 


Negative utility roles are common. But regardless, we can lynch him after if you flip town.


I can simply say I will be around in a few hours if you guys want to sort me and I have been on the right side of flips so far. Your community uses nonsense mech as a crutch so feel free to kill me if you can’t deal with a full claim or if you want to speed hammer before I can respond. 


Sure we’ll give you time. But if you refuse to full claim, we will lynch you.


Towns honestly going full retard today with an outed fake claim imo.


What outted fake claim

ILikePie5

That was Kohai level of retard. I should’ve known he was being disingenuous. Magicman was telling me about Helz the entire time lol. Wylted was too

ILikePie5
I'm interested in Wyrly's NP1 innocent on Alyssa. If she wasn't in the guild yet, why would we think she had been redirected?


Probably some sort of lawyer

ILikePie5
You always say "I figured" after new developments, you rascal. Although in this case, while I did try to be less transparent than Helz, I think it was still guessable. I was mostly relying on people thinking I probably wouldn't be a prime recruit target.


I meant after REF revealed that he wasn’t the Cop and that Helz hadn’t revealed. You were the 3rd person on my ass, so it had to be you by POE

ILikePie5
Actually I'm being retarded. I'm going to out the cop because if Helz is scum they know anyway, and on the off-chance the cop is scum you won't know who they are if I die. It's Wryly. I'd appreciate you recruiting her if Helz flips scum so I can go down with this ship alone.


I’ll handle it don’t worry.

ILikePie5
Lol. Surpriiiiiiise.

Yes, I told the guild who I'd be targeting NP2. Figured it was a good way to test if the guild chat was pure.


I figured it was you lol.


ILikePie5
Helz. He actually accepted the invite and joined our guild. He has not claimed to us. There is also a third. This third person is actually the cop. His character is Cha Hae-In. His character is the cop because monsters smell like shit to her. Luna came up with a kill-bait gambit where I would claim the cop results to bait the night kill. My character is Hwang Dongsoo. I have a role which has negative utility to town, but which I would rather not describe as it would allow scum to manipulate night results. The plan was to out the guilty and then hope scum kills me.


See was it so hard? That gives me enough info. I will decline to name the other one now since I don’t want the cop to reveal themselves either.


Did yall discuss that yall were going to investigate me?

ILikePie5
I'm perfectly willing to reveal their name even if it destroys my guild. I just want an absolute guarantee that I'm doing this for a town player.

I just want you to do what you literally offered to do here before walking it back:


Okay so you agree to reveal after I reveal the first name?

ILikePie5

The only way to force REF to reveal their name is we willing to force a lynch on him because he loses on the spot. He knows the person in his chat is likely scum, but he can’t reveal it because he needs the guild to live to win. If the guild goes extinct or is hijacked by scum, he automatically loses

ILikePie5
You're asking me to play against that other wincon. I've stated I am willing to do that, but only if I am 110% sure you're town. There's two ways to do that. Wait for tomorrow to see Wylted's flip. Or, for your guildmates to vouch for you right now.


Im not doing that. You know that the person in your guild is likely scum. If you’re going hold town hostage you’re going to die. I’m willing to let the guilds duke it out. If you reveal, you’ll get a free recruit cause I will likely die.

ILikePie5
Before I handle a bit of adulting I will say the exact same dynamic exists in your claim. We 'could' demand you have a guild member out themselves to verify your claim today. But why should we? The flip will show if that player was the guild leader and that semi-confirms you. Yes outing one of your guild members could resolve that right the fuck now but we could also just wait for the flip and get reasonable enough confirmation without outing a player as having developed powers. 

Sometimes its good to just wait a bit and revisit the issue later imo.


The flip will confirm me regardless. But what if Shining flips town? REF definitely dies and we still have 2 scum on the loose. That’s why it makes sense to get the information TODAY.

ILikePie5
Your pretty clever. While I disagree with your direction I will acknowledge that. Take a moment and try to break down the odds of what you are voicing as a potential.


Let’s assume framer because Redirector odds are even lower. If this was due to blind chance, there’s a 1/15 chance that they framed correctly. ~7% chance they framed correctly. Odds of one scum recruited NP0 = 4/16 =0.25 or 25%. NP1 let’s assume we factor Alyssa was never going to be recruited. 2/16 =0.125 or 12.125%. Both are immediately higher than purely random chance



ILikePie5
Sure, I get your fixation. You just got shoved hard as a confirmed town and such. You feel very justified and want closure. An easy question I can ask though is why does it need to be 'right the fuck now'?


Cause what happens if scum NK REF tonight? REF likely knows a scum and refuses to out it.


Let’s assume for a moment that Shining is scum. There’s one scum left that would likely be in the guild. Scum will kill REF to prevent them from being outted. That’s why it has to be “right the fuck now.”


You agree that Shining is probably scum. Whats the harm in keeping developed PR's hidden for another day and revisiting the subject tomorrow?

I do feel there is harm in guilds going at etch other demanding reveals. There is simply a difference between something being a valid issue and something being a valid issue that has to be addressed 'right the fuck now.' I am seeing more harm than good with the timing and its based off a pretty improbable situation.


What makes you think it’s more likely that purely due to random chance, scum knew that


A) REF was the Cop

B) He was going to investigate Pie