ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

dumb question but have there ever been DART/DC games with more than one of a single town role? 
like, two cops? two doctors?

where I’m from, this is certainly possible. I saw a game with two town gunsmiths (not MU/MS gunsmith but the variant that can give out guns to ppl)


I consider that bastard. Closest thing is a JOAT with a Doctor and then regular Doctor.

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

50/50 odds we hit scum in Shinjng, Thoth, Wylted, Alyssa assuming there are 2 scum.

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

I think it’s easy to do if it’s basic enough. Like mine is easy. Yours is so convuluted and requires interactions from others that imo it’s hard to do. Not impossible ofc, but the effort level required is insane

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

Pre-emptive WIFOM warning, but do you think Mago is capable of emulating his town play as scum?


Imo logistically speaking, it’s very hard to duplicate it as scum. Like the reactions and interactions are hard to fake, especially since it’s a convuluted act. Like you’d have to be Hollywood level actor to fake this. And realistically, he’d have had to do a deep read of Ruyi Zhuan. Ik I forget what I did previous game. This game is like 5 games back.

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

Thoughts on #371 and #378, specifically 

Rex is the better vote for solving the game? Obviously but if Shining is scum we dont want him to coast by forever


Mago reeks town. It’s identical to his town play.

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

My character seems to have a decent justification for their role, so I am expecting others will too. 


I do as well

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

I’m online, active, and addicted to the game. Pie can answer for himself sure I’m just a neurotic poster.


+1

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

Anyways Rex needs to post more. Why is the Miller claim a policy lynch btw? Genuine question.


Because you never know if it’s a fake claim or not. Even with the existence of a Cop, it’s possible town never had a miller to begin with. It becomes an issue cause scum are never gonna kill the Miller cause they have bigger targets, and there’s no role confirmation. Behavior is possible, and we’ve used it before, but it’s not always perfect. So my policy is that Millers are de facto lynches unless there’s a better option

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

If I am reading the OP correctly, the mafia team get to choose between a full claim, 2 mod given roles, or 2 mod given characters, meaning I don't think they got to "ask" questions. If miller is fake though it was a mod provided fake claim from the full claim, or from one of the two role claims. Also I agree wylted should have said it in his first post. Only thing giving me pause is that this just happened with him as a town miller in ruyi zhuan, and he also didn't claim it in his first post if I remember correctly. Though circumstances were slightly different there with the mechanics.


I mean if Miller was given as a fake claim, that’s just brutal, which is why I agree that it should be policy lynched.

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

You voted him for a claim lol. Also I think the commuter thing was a joke based on banana not hitting the shift key, but maybe I am wrong.


I thought he was trolling lol. You never know with him, which is why you gotta double check

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

I mean it isn't completely out of character for wylted so I am taking that into consideration. But unless we pursue more claims here, and I don't think we should with 4 on the board, the alternative is mago, who I am town reading atm. 


I don’t think we should lynch Mago as well. He’s likely town. At the worst bluffing and TP. Wylted is risky, but the other way the odds of having a miller go up is if scum flip godfather or have a lawyer or something.


I agree with you on REF. He just seems off. Sorta all over the place. Going to have to go read up on his previous scum game

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

I am pressuring wylted because he claimed miller after the cop, and didn't claim it in his first post. It's not OGI if I am dubious of his excuse. But I digress. 


You know I hate millers lol. My issue is if they did use a fake claim on asking about Miller, why not just claim it first post? That’s the safer thing to do. And you and I both know that if Wylted is doing this, his partner did it for him basically

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

As funny as it is to imagine Banana screaming slurs at people on Twitter, I rather we policy Magoroth today. Also I am not in a good mood today.


Any other thoughts? Facts don’t care about your feelings

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

I am sorry I will try harder to post better, most of the time im on my phone and I dont have auto correct on for personal reasons, so it usually takes longer effort to make my posts look nice. I promise im not a dumb dumb.


Is this like culture among Gen-Z women? My gf does the same thing

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

Could be wrong but it felt like an echo from Ruyi Zhan, a poorly thought out bait to get people to lynch him. I noticed it right away lol. Because his claim made too little sense. His claim was bad in the last game as scum he played but it was a bit more well thought out than this. Plus claiming VT early as scum is kind of wild. Anyways I just don't see the scum motivation here.


Agree with this

ILikePie5

the pitt mafia

ILikePie5 · 8 months ago

I guess I should claim because you guys act like bitches sometimes when I wait too long. I am miller


Character and justification? And don’t leave anything out