ILikePie5's avatar

ILikePie5

Member since

ILikePie5
I'm pretty much in the same boat. Usually, certain players are lynch magnets DP1 and a lot of them aren't in this game. I feel like we're treading water a bit because of that. I especially want to see more posts from Magoroth. If I had to pick, it'd be there. He had a pretty rough last game and was a prolific poster, so if he rolled scum this time, I could see him being a bit reticent.

Unvote

VTL Magoroth

I'll check in again in the morning.


This is a good point. The game he was scum with Kohai, very inactive. As town, active and a prolific poster. Hasn’t done much this game, which is significant.


unvote


VTL Mago for full claim

ILikePie5
Trying to avoid past mistakes. I ain’t townreading you just yet either.

anyway if I’m ringing alarm bells, why leave me out of the list of people you could get a claim from?


It’s not enough to garner a scumread, just a spidey sense tingling. You’ve done more than the other 3 people as well imo

ILikePie5

Thoth is a complete 180 in terms of behavior from previous game. Hesitant to scumread it though cause he’s weird.


Banana’s reactions feel town


WF ironically feels town. As scum he’d be posting more and progressing more imo


Wylted vibes town


Mharman not scumreading me is turning on alarm bells for me


REF is null


Luna is null


Mago is null



I’m fine pursuing any of the bottom 3 for a full claim.

ILikePie5
Anyone want to tell me how many important female characters there are in Legend of Zelda?


A whole bunch just in OoT alone. Zelda, Impa, Saria, Ruto, Nabooru, Malon, Koume, Kotake, Epona, Great Fairy, Navi


I'm getting flashbacks to when I was scum in Ranger's Apprentice and suggested that we claim male/female in hopes that I could find the only two important women in those books and maybe save us a question about which characters were in the game. This is minor scum points for Pie.


Read your own post and tell me the difference lol


I'm also scumreading Pie ending his softclaim suggestion with a question mark. Pie is the hyper-confident self-appointed town commander type. He doesn't do uptalk.


It’s cause I couldn’t think of anything better. And as the commander, claim your gender

ILikePie5
I double-checked, and I was misremembering. You actually lied about your fakeclaim in that game, you said you were in footballers but your actual character (Ted Lasso) was in coaches & staff with me. Pretty wild that Magic still managed to hit you, I was assuming the soft claim was why they successfully made the hit.

I guess the moral of the story is to do a fake claim but lie?


Luna actually gave me a fake claim that I used. Scum just got insanely lucky



ILikePie5
No, I soft claimed immediately. They had a specific target they had to hit with their ability, and you and I were the only ones who softed in the category to which he belonged. This narrowed their field of targets to two, making it 50/50; they took the shot and hit you correctly. If I had character claimed it would have simply given them a 100% chance to hit you by process of elimination. Given how often Ganon kidnaps Zelda and the games in which he possessed/mpersonated her (Twilight Princess, Spirit Tracks, TotK) I feel like revealing her character in particular might be bad. I strongly believe that she is town.


Are you talking about Luna’s game where we soft claimed the category? Cause I wasn’t in the same category as you. They guess mine purely based on luck. It was like a 20% chance I think with the knowledge that was present. The theme could be Zelda + Link vs everyone else for all we know. Gender claiming doesn’t do anything besides lock people in character claims. At worst scum have full fake claims and they just claim the gender of that, but if they’re the last to claim for some reason, they’ve eliminated half the pool. Also, some characters are clearly more likely in the game than others.

ILikePie5
We could have not softed. Also, the OP mentions possible alignment-changing roles. In a game this small there has to be some kind of catch to make that balanced. Giving away info might cause issues, Kohai also was originally going to ban it discussing flavor which makes sense if that's the case. He also originally wanted more players, which is usually necessary in games with alignment shifts.


The only reason I was killed was because you refused to claim. I had heavily imply I was a PR because idiots people wanting to lynch me


It caught Supa in one game that's older than this site. How many times did it help scum snipe power roles and important characters through POE? Judging by my character, I'm pretty sure Zelda and Link exist and would probably have power roles. If one of them dies and we do this soft scum have narrowed their POE to hunt the other down by half.


They do, but they don’t know who is who. There are plenty of males and females in the game. And because of the changes Kohai made to allow character claiming, Link or Zelda could be scum for all we know.