ILikePie5's avatar

ILikePie5

Member since

ILikePie5
Just because 6 people voted him doesn't mean he is scum. He was quite towny at the end of the day, apart from his lack of reaction at Mag1cman’s hard CC.


I promise you with that claim, I wouldn’t unvoted, and many others would’ve unvoted. At the very least Mharman should be forced to full claim.

ILikePie5
That is hilarious. Mag1cman/Thoth almost certainly Town. 


Thoth, probably. Magicman, no. I don’t understand how yall are falling for this. This is exactly the shit Mikal pulled before in Alien Mafia. If you thought you were a CC, you would check your PM 5 times, not just hammer instantly. Especially if the character claimed was Link



It’s not a mistake if it helps your faction!
Thanks for overturning that Lynch, Banana.



ILikePie5
It wouldn't be a first for someone to "accidentally" hammer as scum and play it off as a mistake, and it was certainly opportune, though from reading the end of the last DP, it doesn't look like a bluff to me. Is there another reason you're sussing him?


Be real with me. If you had seen Thoth claim Link, would you have unvoted? And if you thought you had a CC, wouldn’t you have checked to make sure? It’s so unbelievable.

ILikePie5
who was your action directed at?


I will reveal that at a later point. But logically from a scum standpoint, they want to roleblock someone who is likely to investigate them. And there are 3 people who I would’ve investigated if I could’ve: Mharman, Thoth, REF

ILikePie5
Uh no. You were very opportunistic on that Thoth wagon last DP, not to mention the earlier shade at me.


He was in my null pile. I would’ve unvoted him if I had been on. But I was busy doing other things with the girl. And I explained why I “shaded” you. You were in my POE as well.


VTL Pie

tell ya what. I’ll trade my full for fulls from both Pie and Lunatic


Lol so now it’s gone from Pie + Luna are scum to “lets make make both of them full claim and then I will give my claim.”

ILikePie5
magic, no need to reveal anything about yourself or anything. that slip up was understandable and unlikely to be scum motivated


Lol, if people saw Thoth claimed Link, we would’ve unvoted. Hammering the guy who claimed Link is exactly what scum want to do

ILikePie5
The only reason for choosing banana as the NK is if they suspected that was her role tbh, It makes thoth look bad


Banana claimed Female and confirmable role. They were trying to kill Zelda no doubt

ILikePie5
Mod psyche question: Does anyone think Kohai would significantly have changed his modding style since the last game? A brief look into 1990's-2000's mafia endgame shows me that there was no vanillas, it was a very role heavy swingy game.

Granted I do see mikal helped balance this one, so do you think mikal would have maybe suggested him putting in a vanilla here? 


This is public info in the discord but Mikal said he helped make the game from very swingy to slightly swingy. Best way to do that is Vanillas. So I buy that Vanillas exist, just a question of who they are. A relative no name for Vanilla makes sense. I also think the refusal to say the justification is townie.

ILikePie5
I won’t claim my justification for why my role is Vanilla, because I think it would count as angle shooting, due to the way it’s worded. If there are other Vanilla they could 1) townread me for it and 2) scum could figure out who the Vanilla are (trivial) and shoot in the PR pool.


Justification doesn’t count as angle shooting. What’s the justification for why you’re a vanilla?


ILikePie5
idk if I fully buy that and it’s making me start to sus you.


Going back to status quo. Much better


Thoughts on Lunatic and Thoth?


Null on both. Luna picks up late game. He’s not wrong about that. Thoth is just weird. It’s hard to read into his behavior because he does weird stuff as town and scum, and I’ve been burned by it

ILikePie5
I wasn’t there and I’m not gonna dig through it. I know he was mislynched that game and that’s it. Could you expand on this?


He was basically inactive the entire game. Didn’t even show up to full claim. Got lynched because of time pressure

ILikePie5
I just realize this is why pie is voting people. Jesus Christ. Yes the soft claiming meets is retarded. Next game we lunch whoever attempted to do it first as policy


It’s the best way to hone the initial pressure imo. Otherwise we’re just stuck in RVS