ILikePie5
Really wish this DP had started sooner. I'm on about 4 hours of sleep from last night (seriously, good sleep has been elusive for about a month now), and I'm having trouble focusing on the words on screen at this point.

The long and short of it is that I can see the case both of you are making. I think there are significant oddities in Mag1c's play, but they could just be legitimate fumbles, albeit very big ones.


Could it be? Sure. Anything is possible. But the fact that he thinks he’s entitled to be townread for it is a disgrace. If he made the mistake, he’s an idiot for it. You were Mikal’s partner in Alien Mafia, so you know that Town just took it as a legitimate mistake and moved on. I’m not making the same mistake again. At the worst he’s scum. At the best, this sets a bad precedent.


In particular, while CCing Link does stand out as a big problem, it also makes sense that he'd be mentioned in multiple character justifications, so it's not out of the realm of possibility that he just saw the name a few times and thought that was his character. It's not great play, but it's not necessarily scum indicative, especially since the CC places him as a prime target for a lynch the next DP. It doesn't necessarily make Mag1c town just because it would be very sloppy play as scum, but considering how he's played as scum recently, it's not what I'd expect to see from him if he was scum.


I don’t think it’s sloppy at all. His obvious goal was to lynch Thoth. He was going to lynch him to begin with. But then Thoth dropped the bomb that he was Link. Naturally, that would’ve derailed the lynch. But he just hammers first blindly without checking his PM.


As for the reasons Mag1c has given to sus Pie, the not being there at EoD is the weakest. I went back and checked and, yes, that's what Pie said would happen ahead of the game.


Yes, I did, and I got an earful last night.


A lot of the rest of this looks like Mag1c's frustration in response to tunneling (fair, I've been there) and the shift to focusing on him after the events of the last DP. I get why those would be frustrating, but I can't say the continued pursuit of his read or the decision to push Mag1c this DP comes off as scummy. It's not unusual for Pie to pursue someone like this as scum or town.

In terms of what we can do about it, I think the mutual claim probably makes the most sense, though I'm about to shut my computer down because I'm getting a headache. If you guys don't sort this out by tomorrow, I'll give my two cents when I can think more clearly.


He hammered Link. That should objectively be scummy. He can make whatever excuse he want. But the fact is that he hammered Link.

ILikePie5
you’re contradicting yourself. You were straight up sussing me. I wasn’t a null.


I said it was “alarm bells.” I never stated I thought you were scum.


And then why can’t it be the same here? If I can be town there I can be town here. You know this. All of you see what was an obvious honest mistake. And you’re falling for it. And Pie ur a fucking dipshit for even thinking this case is any good. If I’m a moron you’re the moron supreme.


Lmfao. So you admitted to being a moron in Paper Mario. And are claiming to be a moron here, but Pie is somehow the moron. Nice lol


really, and you suddenly stopped being with the girl when it was time for you to enter thread and express your “confusion?”

Technically possible but the timing still isn’t good. Good effort, but no dice


Uh yes? She was getting ready cause we were gonna go get ice cream.

ILikePie5
yes it would’ve been fine. It’s common people will vote someone they townread on low time just to have a lynch, especially DP1.


But people aren’t going to vote a person who claimed the main character, are they? You know this as well as anyone. Multiple people have stated they would’ve unvoted.


and I don’t even need to go for any lynch on you or Lunatic as scum, nor do I even need to say I townread Thoth.


Again, as scum lynching the bigger fish is always desirable. Your hand was forced the second Thoth came on and claimed Link.


Anyone can check the thread. Before I re-entered the thread on low time, I was questioning Thoth and had moved him out of my town block. Upon re-entering the thread, instead of appealing to low time and hammering Thoth, I observed the situation, moved him back into my town pile, and then started pushing for lynches on Pie and Lunatic, only hammering Thoth in my own confusion about my PM after he claimed.


You hammered Thoth as scum because he claimed Link, who is a main character. It’s really that simple. You couldn’t use time because he had just claimed the main character. Voting for that as scum is suicide.

ILikePie5
opportunism. Pursues Thoth over me when I’m townread and others are sussing Thoth. Only pursues me after the mistake from last DP, when he hopes the perception of me would’ve changed.


I null read 3 people. Mharman, REF, and Thoth. I picked a person from those 3. Nothing more to it.


bad arguments. His bad logic, bad faith, and outright dishonest arguments/ignoring my real points has been well documented. When Pie’s logic starts to slip, it’s a scumtell. Casey did a good job of noting this in past games.


This is just wrong. If you are town, you have yourself to blame, just like Paper Mario Mafia. You claiming will help me determine whether you are truly scum or a moron.


not being there for EoD, but then randomly showing up just after Thoth was hammered


I already said in signups I was going to be with the girl until Sunday afternoon. I checked in when I could. Nice try though.

ILikePie5
Again, take note of how Pie repeatedly ignores the point.

I’m NOT saying scum has no incentive to hammer Link, I AM saying scum has no incentive to do such weird CC shit, WHEN they had an easy alternative to simply appeal to low time and hammer off that, BEFORE Thoth could even claim. INSTEAD, I pinged him so he could claim.


You were peddling a Pie and Luna lynch because you townread Thoth. And you’re saying if you had just hammered based on time, it would’ve been fine?


You had to do this. Otherwise people would’ve questioned why you were hammering a person you townread lol


ILikePie5
I would have hammered him there without the CC regardless of affiliation unless he was scum. It's very easy to justify that lynch, so easy in fact that we should just double down on it but I will humor you. I just want magics claim


I would’ve scumread you if you hadn’t lol.

ILikePie5
What makes It any less likely? Mag1c’s response to his mistake was genuine, he didn’t fake that. “Sorry sorry”, that’s not fake.


You weren’t in the game Mikal did that. Everyone also believed him that game.

ILikePie5
Literally anyone can make a mistake and think they’re someone they’re not. It’s not a lie, it’s a mistake. It’s easily possible.


When the stakes are as high as CCing someone? Mikal literally did this in a previous game. “Innocent mistake,” doesn’t cut it.

ILikePie5
Legit Pie is only starting to get pull because he’s good at being the loudest voice in the room. Not because of any good reasoning in his “case”


This is just funny. Go look at post counts for this DP. pIE iS lOUdesT perSoN In tHE rooM

ILikePie5
Not a fan of Pie styling himself Town leader here.


That’s how I play. Ask anyone.


I’m not seeing what Mag1c is seeing here but it feels very strange that Pie is scumreading him. I know it’s not much, but it makes me sus of ILikePie5.


Why is strange to scumread someone who lied about his soft claim. Someone who claims they didnt read their PM before voting someone for a CC. And especially cause that CC was main character Link.

ILikePie5
Yeah, I would have unvoted. And yes, if I believed I was Link and I saw someone claim that character, I would have double-checked my PM. Fair points.


Exactly. And he claims he made the same mistake before. If anything that’s even worse. Help me pursue a full claim from him

ILikePie5
Just because 6 people voted him doesn't mean he is scum. He was quite towny at the end of the day, apart from his lack of reaction at Mag1cman’s hard CC.


I promise you with that claim, I wouldn’t unvoted, and many others would’ve unvoted. At the very least Mharman should be forced to full claim.

ILikePie5
That is hilarious. Mag1cman/Thoth almost certainly Town. 


Thoth, probably. Magicman, no. I don’t understand how yall are falling for this. This is exactly the shit Mikal pulled before in Alien Mafia. If you thought you were a CC, you would check your PM 5 times, not just hammer instantly. Especially if the character claimed was Link



It’s not a mistake if it helps your faction!
Thanks for overturning that Lynch, Banana.



ILikePie5
It wouldn't be a first for someone to "accidentally" hammer as scum and play it off as a mistake, and it was certainly opportune, though from reading the end of the last DP, it doesn't look like a bluff to me. Is there another reason you're sussing him?


Be real with me. If you had seen Thoth claim Link, would you have unvoted? And if you thought you had a CC, wouldn’t you have checked to make sure? It’s so unbelievable.

ILikePie5
who was your action directed at?


I will reveal that at a later point. But logically from a scum standpoint, they want to roleblock someone who is likely to investigate them. And there are 3 people who I would’ve investigated if I could’ve: Mharman, Thoth, REF

ILikePie5
Uh no. You were very opportunistic on that Thoth wagon last DP, not to mention the earlier shade at me.


He was in my null pile. I would’ve unvoted him if I had been on. But I was busy doing other things with the girl. And I explained why I “shaded” you. You were in my POE as well.


VTL Pie

tell ya what. I’ll trade my full for fulls from both Pie and Lunatic


Lol so now it’s gone from Pie + Luna are scum to “lets make make both of them full claim and then I will give my claim.”

ILikePie5
magic, no need to reveal anything about yourself or anything. that slip up was understandable and unlikely to be scum motivated


Lol, if people saw Thoth claimed Link, we would’ve unvoted. Hammering the guy who claimed Link is exactly what scum want to do

ILikePie5
The only reason for choosing banana as the NK is if they suspected that was her role tbh, It makes thoth look bad


Banana claimed Female and confirmable role. They were trying to kill Zelda no doubt