ILikePie5
The only flaw I've seen in your reasoning of Banana is that you misrepresented her role


I think everyone misunderstood the reasoning for that post. It was to show that her role is a custom role according to her, but it’s also a real role that’s out there. If all the custom roles have custom names, why is this one role not custom named


and you're criticizing her for posting sporadically when several players have been posting sporadically, you among them.


I’m not criticizing her for posting sporadically. I’m criticizing her for just coming in to vote and then leaving. She’s just wagoning to wagon. Awesome/Kohai hasn’t posted anything, but he’s next on my list of POE. I fully admit that I haven’t posted as much as I’d like, but I’ve posted more than those two.


Otherwise I agree, she is in the POE. Continuing to discuss Mago as scum in DP3 however kind of baffles me.


I think his behavior was/is objectively scummy, but as we talked about before, if he lives tomorrow, that’s the avenue to lynch him. And assuming 2 scum, 3 scum or 2-1 it’s going to be MYLO/LYLO tomorrow, so you have to reevaluate anyways. It’s going to be hard for them because if I get enough favor, I confirm myself tomorrow and that’s one less head in the POE.



Really sorry life is being such a bitch for you rn btw


ILikePie5
Pie, why is Lunatic outside your PoE? Assume I am Town for a second. Is he possibly scum.


He’s on the outside of my POE depending on if he’s the Doctor or the Neighborizer. If he is the Neighborizer, then yes, he is possibly scum, but I’m less confident on that compared to Banana.





ILikePie5
I know you’re probably gonna scumread me for this, but:

I wasn’t really super sure you were scum, just kinda agreed with Lunatic that you suggesting there’s 3P could come from some kinda informed perspective (for example, you’re Mafia and you know your faction has only one fake claim).


I’ve said in countless games before about how many scum I think there are based on the balance of the game. All I’m saying is just high level, if I were to design a game with 11 players, it would be 8-2-1. Could it be 8-3? Yes ofc. All of this is purely my opinion, and ive done similar to this in a large number of games in the past as well.

ILikePie5
There were 12 players at first. No way there is only 2 mafia. Anything, I get Pie is really busy, but something seems off with him.


I admit I’m busy. I’m stressed. Life sucks. Yes there’s something off. Congrats, you’re thinking the same exact thing everyone else is thinking including me

ILikePie5
Pie may be my top scumread right now. I know he's been slammed at work but his behavior just feels more like scum trying to play while busy than town trying to play while busy


I’m trying to scum hunt. What flaw do you see in my reasoning for scumreading Banana. There’s role mechanics. Every DP, she just comes in to vote and then dips.

ILikePie5
Pretty sure pie is scum here. He is only really pressuring people he thinks he can secure easy mislynches on, somehow town reads all the vets, normal pie would be hella sus of the other vets.


What do you mean? There’s a clear POE here. Mago will be exposed tomorrow if he lives (I still think he’s scummy. Haven’t forgotten previous DP). You/WF are at the end of the POE because one of you is the Protective role and the reads on each other, though I’ve already stated I think the non-protective role is more likely to be scum. Shining is probably the towniest person here. Wylted is on outskirts of POE. Only way he’s scum is if Miller was given as fake claim


That leaves…Wryly, Awesome/Kohai, Banana. I can’t help that the weakest players are in POE and I have at worse a null read on the other players who coincidentally are more experienced.


Plus the role is an outlier, strengthener is kind of a common fake claim and the slanderer is kind of a CC by kohai only khoais is more of a theft (which he strangely didn't mention, even though he was harping on wryly/shining cc'ing each other).


I can’t help what REF gave me. And if you think this is a fake claims, then you have to assume REF gave it to me. It’s not a safe claim if it’s a shitty fake claim


Like even buying the excuse that pie is busy (I know he genuinely is) like his behavior still feels different even analyzing his active posts. 0 interaction between him and kohai.


How am I supposed to interact with someone who has been even more inactive than me in DP1 and DP2, and hasn’t said much this DP3?


I think his vote on awesome was to look town last day phase, but kohai hasn't done a lot, and I feel like there would be a lot of focus on him from pie but there isn't. I am seeing a scum team here.


He’s part of the POE as I described earlier, but his role doesn’t stick out like Banana’s does. My focus is on my top scum read.


Pie being adamant about 2 scum and a third party suggests inside information as well, I think that is a pretty wild conclusion to jump to otherwise.


If I was scum, how would I know there’s a TP? This makes no sense? I’m saying from a pure balance standpoint it makes sense to 8-2-1 but it’s obviously up to REF.


Lastly in post 172 of dp1 pie said if he had enough favor he could carry the game.


Yep, at that point in time, I thought I could. I’ve explained this you in private. Everytime I stay alive I’m scumread because everyone is paranoid that Pie has to be scum. If I’m immune to lynches, I’m basically confirmed town, and I can lead town to victory. And also I’ll have Doctors or Watchers or similar on me in the night.


I was thinking he had some really amazing role here that could help him break the game, but the only thing I can fathom to think of that he could be referring to is his lynchproof, which 1. Requires him to be way more active and have amazing reads to use


I’m basically almost there. I can literally prove myself tomorrow with a little more favor. It’s the closest thing to mod confirmation.


2. Ignores the fact that his slanderer role could actually harmfully impact the town.


My plan was to waive anyways unless I was absolutely certain the person was scum. Like I would’ve used it on Mago if I could’ve.


And like I said earlier, I think scum probably have some pretty powerful roles based on how strong the town appears to be.


Assuming everyone is telling the truth and the game is balanced, yes. But I don’t know what scum have


Meaning that asking for favor would probably be a viable strategy from scum, not only for that but because it means that favor isn't getting fed into town power roles. It just doesn't make sense to ask for favor if you know your going to be busy and not able to post like anything if you think you are going to carry town to victory with a lynchproof lol.


At that point I had just gotten back from vacation. I didn’t think I’d be worked like a slave lol.

ILikePie5
Somebody witnessed Mikal visiting me and apparently he had that ability


And you are absolutely sure you lost exactly 1 favor?


ILikePie5
No one has claimed receiving two favor stolen from wylted yet, so I am assuming it was given to scum. 



Let me see who he townread

ILikePie5
I just don’t love Bananas claim because it’s a mechanically weird role where you are role blocking the only confirmed town player in the game by vetoing decisions. Also completely outted that I have different roles as well that I can use so…yeah don’t love that. 


Exactly, what’s the utility here. You would just waive every night. Why give that role to a townie?

ILikePie5
If you are basing this off of role name, that's not a super convincing argument, because im pretty sure a mason recruiter isn't a "Neighborizer". Not sure where Rex finds the names for his role pm's but they are definitely not standard. Also shining and wryly both have two different names for the same passive that lets them identify roles who visit them (perceptive, and careful). I have never even heard of a slanderer or benefactor or adjudicator either. Magoroths vengeful is basically just a hunter. 


If you look at the difference websites for roles Neighborizer is how the role is working. Shining and Wryly have different names, but they’re on MS and the descriptions match. Even if you look at Vengeful, it matches the description. It could obviously be fake claims, but it matches up.


The ONLY roles that you can’t find anywhere are the custom roles like Slanderer and Benefactor because they’re tied to favor. REF had to have made those up. “Siren” is also a custom role but it’s on MU. Why would he use a name that’s already taken to describe a custom role.



ILikePie5
Why do you think there’s a 3rd party?


Balance. 8-3 is scumsided. 8-2-1 is more balanced. Ofc that’s how I would design the game and I’m not REF.

ILikePie5
Largely agree with this, though I don't buy Wryly as scum, so we're talking you, Awesome/Kohai and Banana at this point.


Why? The only thing going for her is the mechanical aspect of her role.


A little wary of the Strengthener given that it wouldn't be a first for scum to use it as an easy fake claim, but with a Rolestopper, Redirector and RB already flipped, I can at least see why there might be a Strengthener.


I’m just saying what the mod gave me. I cant do much about what was given to me.


The Lynchproof would at least be confirmable if you could use it and I can't imagine REF giving that to scum, though I'm guessing you don't have access to it now.


Exactly, and I’m super close. I can literally confirm myself with a little more favor. It’s the closest thing to mod confirmed town in the game


The Siren role does ping me as odd, but I don't think Banana just grabbed a role designed for a TP and imposed a role tailor-made to this game over it to retain the name. The role looks scummy to me mainly because I don't see any town utility, but it's not because it's called "Siren."


Thats my point though. All the roles are either custom roles that you can’t find anywhere or are normal roles. This one sticks out in the sense that the role is out there, but description is different. If REF created all these names for the custom roles, the way she’s describing it is a custom role too, so why would he give a name that has something attached to it?

ILikePie5
so lots of roles are doubled.
would like to hear from everyone how much favour they have and exactly what action they took on night one as well.


I received one favor, presumably from Supa

ILikePie5

I dislike Banana’s Siren claim. Here is what a Siren does per MafiaUniverse. Funny enough it’s the role of the day on MU today. This is what Siren does:


”The Siren is an independently aligned player who may submit one name each night. If the named player visits the Siren on that night, they die. Once the Siren successfully kills two players in this fashion, they win the game.”




ILikePie5
Assuming I die of poison tonight, we could be at 7v2 right now. With a mislynch and a Town death, that’s 4v2, MyLo.
And that’s assuming the poisoner can’t poison again. With a Town Vengeful, maybe a scum Poisoner that can poison multiple times isn’t that far fetched, especially considering all the crazy roles we’ve seen yet.

8v3 at start is also possible, but then the poisoner would have to be one-shot (possible); in which case right now it’s 6v3, with a mislynch we lose, so technically there is a possibility, but a slim one, that we are actually at MyLo right now. It would certainly help explain how many people seemingly confirmed each other’s roles. 

Idk, it just feels too easy for it to be Pie/Kohai/Banana.


9 players remaining. Let’s assume it’s 7-2 right now. If we Mislynch today, it goes to 6-2. Let’s say the NK goes off. It’s 5-2. Let’s say you’re town and you die, it’s 4-2. Assuming Shining is still alive and is town, it’s effectively 5-2 with the double vote and you still get a lynch.


In a 6-3 scenario it gets much harder obviously. I still believe there’s a TP somewhere. If we eliminate them today, we should be safe.

ILikePie5
Are you claiming to be lynch proof right now or is it like my modifier where it is if I acheive top rank


Modifier if I get to the rank. Read the OP in DP1.

ILikePie5
I am in a private PM with Whiteflame. One of us is an odd night mason recruiter (Rex calls it a Neighborizer), even night avoider, with a passive of prideful. One of us is an Odd doctor/Even bodyguard with a commuter passive. I am going to keep it ambiguous for the time being to keep the mafia guessing about which of us is which. 

Our characters are:

Consort Shun: Su Luyun
Concubine Yu: Keliyete Hailan


Interesting. Whoever has the protective roles is more likely to be town imo. If WF is the protective, then WF/Luna are solid from a role and behavioral perspective. If we take Wylted and Shining as town, that leaves exactly Wryly, Awesome/Kohai, and Banana. At worse a 66% chance of catching scum. At best, the game is over.

ILikePie5
Lunatic might be scum, but so far, I think hes been scumhunting. I would like a full claim from either Pie, WF or Banana


I probably need to claim anyways cause of my inactivity


Character: Noble Consort Hui (started at 6 favor)


Concubine: Vanilla

Consort: Odd Night Strengthener

Noble Consort: Even Night Slanderer (can reduce someone’s favor by 1)

Imperial Noble Consort: Lynchproof



I hinted to this in DP2, but I Strengthened WF. He has a scumtell which he didn’t do in DP1, so I townread him going into the night

ILikePie5
Literally the only anti-Town role thus far has been Wylted’s Miller claim. What is going on. Town is already ridiculously overpowered with all these roles, and seemingly at least half these people had enough favour to carry out their night action.

I find this sus. At least one of those claims is a lie.


The most obvious pairing is Wylted/Shining. A 2 team scum team with a third vote and rock solid fake claims.


Outside of that, the only thing going for Wryly is the similarity to your disability. There is basically a CC there too with Shining. I think she is definitely in POE, much more so than Shining/Wylted.


If REF gave Cop and Miller as fake claims to scum, I’m just gonna be like it is what it is and move on with my life, cause like I would genuinely have no words

ILikePie5
But if he claimed redirector/bomb/ bulletproof I’m like 90% sure he would have been lynched anyway with a role like that lol


Would still be in POE, but he just gave up for no reason. Definition of throwing

ILikePie5
I’m not sure you realise, but Thoth flipped Town. EVERYONE had all day to suggest alternatives and nobody did, except for Awesome/Kohai who is probably Town...


They have done literally nothing this game. Why are they town? Pie, who has posted more is nuller than it’s possible to null

ILikePie5
The issue of me and Shining's similar passives remains unresolved, as does the wacky Poisoner that visits one person while poisoning another. I can only assume "Shadow Poisoner" is some custom shit that visits several people but only poisons one. I wonder if it's justified because of some poison-themed deception madness in the show. 


Or it’s just pure flavor and it means nothing. Or Mago/Luna are a scum team. There’s like so many what ifs, which is why I dislike custom roles in general. It’s hard for both sides to work around them.


ILikePie5
The issue of me and Shining's similar passives remains unresolved, as does the wacky Poisoner that visits one person while poisoning another. I can only assume "Shadow Poisoner" is some custom shit that visits several people but only poisons one. I wonder if it's justified because of some poison-themed deception madness in the show. 


Or it’s just pure flavor and it means nothing. Or Mago/Luna are a scum team. There’s like so many what ifs, which is why I dislike custom roles in general. It’s hard for both sides to work around them.


ILikePie5
Pie - I haven't been on the same page with many of his reads, though I ended up coming to a different conclusion about those than Luna, especially given he's continued to be adamant about Shining and Magoroth past the point where it was any kind of simple task to get them lynched. I'm balancing that against a surprisingly accepting response to Wylted's Miller claim and a relatively low amount of activity, which could be driven by him just being busy. I don't think he's done anything particularly scummy, he's just kind of off to me. Null.


Genuinely, I wake up, work, go home, eat, and work some more, and sleep. Same thing for the past week with no break. There’s just a million things to do cause we had a layoff and I’m not trying to lose my job in this shitty market

ILikePie5
I should probably remind myself that I have no reason mechanically to townread Lunatic, but behaviorally he is reading as muy bueno. 


I agree with that. Behaviorally he’s town


ILikePie5
Can someone give me a TLDR of what happened at the end of the previous DP? I’ll read through it when I can


Actually it’s only 2-3 pages, I’ll post my thoughts here about them

ILikePie5
Also, I know I just said Wylted is Town, but him saying “no no protectives on a Miller” is sus. It’s LAMIST and also weird. Town should ALWAYS be okay with doctors/bodyguards/whatever on them, unless they are not Town and just saying it because “look how towny I am, I am Miller, go heal a Cop you idiot!"


If Wylted is scum, why in a million years would he say to not target him. Having a protective role target him as scum would be a wet dream

ILikePie5

Can someone give me a TLDR of what happened at the end of the previous DP? I’ll read through it when I can