ILikePie5
VTL Shining

I have a passive called Perceptive that activates at Imperial Noble level. It lets me see which roles target me in a given night. This sounds identical to the passive Shining is describing, although he's claiming he had immediate access to it in addition to Rolecop, which would mean he would have to have started with high favor or be the Empress.


Well well well

ILikePie5
Tough decision because I had no idea who even had enough favor to be worth tracking, plus Mago had run around in circles waving a flaming torch and accusing everyone and their grandmother, so there were a wide range of possible scum who would be on their guard, but Mikal had said several of his roles overlap with Mago's and I decided to investigate that soft CC, and I figured Mago would probably be mislynched before the end of the game so why waste an investigative on him.


Didnt you townread Mago at the end of the previous DP?

ILikePie5
also since mikal was the empress and died does that mean vader appoints a new empress today? doesnt empress get a double vote?


They’re 2 different things.

ILikePie5
im suspicious of big players like you pie wylted whiteflame mostly, I would be very surprised if there was not scum in you guys, but wylted is probably town at least


Comes with the reputation sadly


ILikePie5
Why do you think mikal was targeted for the night kill?


Cause he was the one preventing the lynch on Mago. I think it was a WIFOM kill. He’s been running it the entire game

ILikePie5
wait, if magoroth is poisoned what's the point of lynching him


There is none, unless we think he’s lying. In that case, if there are 2 scum, one of them is completely off the board. He’s already snaked his way out of DP1. The consecutive DPs make it extremely dangerous for scum as their odds of getting lynched skyrocket. And assuming he’s lying, he could just say he was “gambiting” like he already has. He’s already done it before and everyone believed him.

ILikePie5
Can you ask Rex to clarify if you are indeed poisoned? Maybe the poisoner has two actions and visited both you and margo. Just trying to make sure this isn't a CC situation because two poisoners is a bit crazy scum sided.


Scum having an NK and Poisoner is also broken imo. It makes sense if the Poisoner activates with more favor. But NP1 having both is broken. This train of thought has be sussing Shining A LOT more.

ILikePie5
I was targeted by a shadow posioner. Isn't it more likely the posioner can target someone, and whoever they visit gets poisoned? idk


What makes you say that?

ILikePie5
Well I've done a bit of a 180 on magoroth, was still pretty paranoid about him going into the night and was actually planning on doing exactly what wylted did and seeing if I could bait a reaction out of him with a fake result, because he was falling into a lot of scum tells yesterday, but there was still a big part of me with doubts. But with the poisoner targeting him and my role kind of confirming the existence of a poisoner, it stands to reason.


I still don’t buy Mago being Town. Being “Poisoned” seems like a ploy to avoid being lynched these next to days under the guise of, “I’m going to die anyway.”


Also Shining claimed that the Poisoner visited him. Unless there’s 2 Poisoners, someone is lying.


While I would agree in general that multiple investigation roles seems kind of powerful, I think we can give that argument a little bit of leeway considering its all based on favor, technically people only have a role or any power if vader grants it to them, so theres a world where none of these investigative roles are ever active at the same time. I am getting strong town vibes from pie also, might just be he is echoing a lot of my thoughts. Not feeling the best about wryly anymore based on her voting behavior last day phase, for how scummy mago was acting I think she was trying to save face by not voting him thinking him flipping town would make her look good, other people town reading mago had more reason for it IE mikal, but wryly was just non committal for the sake of it, and when I called her out on it, she kind of just dismissed it as a joke, so it suggests some inside information to me. That said the tracking result plus targeting a claimed miller does lowkey make sense so I am not full sussing her yet.


I think you’re dismissing the investigative argument too quick. A Cop, Watcher, Tracker, and Rolecop in the same game. Regardless of the favor mechanic, the odds of scum having at least one of the latter 3 makes sense for the game.

ILikePie5
Okay, I'll just out this. I have a passive that allows me to tell who visited me during the night, and something called a shadow posioner did. 


Interesting. Never heard of a Shadow Poisoner before. I presume REF didn’t say anything about you being poisoned, which could mean that the Poison Doctor visited you, you’re passively immune, or theres some other funky mechanic with it. But this is a direct CC of Mago. Two Poisoners don’t make sense at all

ILikePie5
Honestly, Mago is acting like a schizo, so while policy lynching a huge mislynch target DP1 just for the information and removal of liability. I played with a lot of erratic people before. Its NAI, and I have a gut read on Mago.


So why did you investigate him NP1?


Additionally, I do have something else to report, but will out it later.


ILikePie5
Magoroth comes off as pretty townie after all this.


Before I went to sleep last night, I asked REF about the message someone would receive if they were Vanillaized. He said something like you are vanilla now. So he definitely wasn’t vanillaized. Now for the poison — it could be a gambit to survive the 2 DPs. Cause why would Town lynch someone who is already on the deathbed basically. And then later he claims he was cured or something magical happened.


He and Shining would have to have tied themselves together with this Rolecop claim and I don't see them being quite that obvious about that. Couple that with the Poisoning/Vanillaizing (seems over the top for providing himself with cover if that's what he's doing) and I just don't see him pulling all this as scum.


I disagree. Mago had already revealed his roles yesterday as RB, Watcher, Vengeful. He could’ve just restated what Mago said. I’d wager there’s one scum in between them. I don’t think they both can be scum.

ILikePie5
I've played games where there was a Tracker and a Watcher, so it didn't seem like an impossibility to me. Also, the favor mechanic means that Rex can hand out a lot of goodies without the game becoming imbalanced -- a lot of these roles may never activate.


I don’t recall this game. Which one? Also, if Wylted is telling the truth, there has to be a Cop in the game as well. Bottomline, you, Wylted, Mago, and Shining are in a soft CC.

ILikePie5
What are poison and Beloved Princess?


A Poisoner poisons someone in the night, and they die in the future unless saved by a Poison Doctor usually.


Mikal was a hybrid Beloved Princess. Normally if they’re lynched, there are 2 NPs in a row, but if they’re NKed, there are 2 DPs in a row. Here it’s just the 2 DPs

ILikePie5
I tracked Mikal last night and saw him visit Wylted, so assuming I wasn't redirected, there is a possibility Mikal just used his High Adjudicator on Wylted to transfer favor, though I don't know why he would do that, and I don't think Wylted would be informed of who the favor was transferred to -- and Magoroth says he didn't receive any notification of a favor increase in any case.


Wait hold on, a Tracker, Watcher, and Rolecop? There’s no way all 3 of yall are town. Thats wayyyy too many investigative roles.


Also, why didn’t you CC Mago? A Tracker and Watcher doesn’t make much sense.



ILikePie5
Well, I got news for you all. I rolecop'd Mago last night. His consort role is odd night role, his noble consort is even night watcher, and his imperial consort is vengeful.


Rolecop? Interesting

ILikePie5
Why would the scum poison you when you are probably getting lynched anyway? 

Why would they vanillaized you?


Was thinking about this too. Luna confirmed publically that he had knowledge a Poisoner was in the game. We saw an NK happen. Doesn’t make sense to give scum Poisoner and NK. It makes sense for a TP Poisoner to exist especially considering 8-2-1 is more balanced.

ILikePie5
hmm would make sense to be multiple roles that give favor


Its mod confirmed in OP that multiple roles exist

ILikePie5
nah, nobody was able to give a single fucking reason that actually stood up as to why I was scum. nobody.


I gave 3-4 reasons why you were objectively scummy. Not subjectively. Objectively. The fact that you keep doubling down on scumminess just solidifies my read. You’re WIFOMing the shit out of this. It’s stupid. You’re lucky I was busy with work and on vacation earlier, otherwise I would’ve secured that lynch


if you guys push me again today btw I will afk, not interested in being everyone’s punching bag for two days straight. this is not how you play mafia. you don’t have the entire game tunnel on one dude for 1+ days... especially when that dude is town. it’s literally the definition of stupidity, it harms everyone (me, I cannot scum hunt, I have to spend precious energy defending myself), 2. others (townies tunnel on me and can’t see shit)


Ive dealt with threats multiple times. Ain’t my first rodeo.


VTL Mago

ILikePie5

Probably the first time we got a Beloved Princess to work, I’ll take it. We need the 2 lynches in a row after that No Lynch yesterday. The fact that Mago escaped that lynch is mind boggling.

ILikePie5

I want to lynch Mago based on what I read last night and the TLDR Luna/WF posted. I was scumreading him yesterday and I still scumread him.


Claiming Framer is just mind boggling. It’s just stirring up more chaos. I think he’s just doubling down on all of his scumminess. Like asking for people’s starting Favor is so insanely scummy, and then mass claim, and then Empress, and now this? I believe he realized his mistake as scum and has been hard defending himself while trying to appear as scummy as possible to WIFOM us out. My strongest read is the redundancy that I talked about yesterday. I just caught Earth with it the previous game. It’s posting to post, and he’s basically been doing that all game.


VTL Mago

ILikePie5
I notice Pie hasn't talked much. No matter. With the topic of Mago, I feel like he is REALLY pushing for mass claim and I'm not sure hes scummy for it. If I was his buddy, I would be telling him to chill. Still, we should mass claim no sooner than DP2, at least. DP1 is just madness.


The scummiest part was asking everyone to reveal how much favor people start with. Like that is so direct, and I can’t believe everyone missed that so far in what I’ve read

ILikePie5
I still think we should mass claim what abilities we have access to. If scum tells the truth, and they don’t use their fake claim, they will be forced to use their abilities either in a pro-Town way, rendering them kinda useless to them, or take a risk and use their abilities anyway in spite of lying about it.


Absolutely not.


I will go first. One of my abilities is Watcher.


Congrats, if you’re telling the truth, you’ll probably be manipulated or outright killed