Hello. this game is kind of confusing to me but ill do my best
Any behavioral thoughts so far?
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Hello. this game is kind of confusing to me but ill do my best
Any behavioral thoughts so far?
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
So, wait, what's the issue with Magoroth now? Awesome says his "posts are atrocious" and Wylted's just buying in because he trusts Awesome. I guess the pushback on softclaiming flavor is a little off because he's almost defensive of scum here (who have been given two fake claims anyway), but nothing has looked that bad.
Read my previous posts. I think I’m seeing exactly what Awesome sees
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
To inject some behavioral analysis into our flavor analysis, I'm curious about wylted's history of fake-claiming. Does he tend to concoct weird claims, or would he probably just say I'm a Miller?
Wylted is horrible at fake claiming. If there is no Miller, he’s either town or this was a fake claim given by REF.
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
I don’t really want to soft-claim flavour just because it would feel like shit if I was Scum and got caught due to flavour. So I’d appreciate flavour not being a part of the discussion.
But you’re fine with roles being revealed? That doesn’t make sense at all
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
I'm scumreading this. It seems to me like that the central element of a harem-themed game should be sweet-talking the Emperor. Scum probably do have at least some counters to town's abilities, but not incentivizing scum to charm Vader would be flavorless.
My issue with this is that it’s redundant. Like ya scum have counters to town, no shit. It’s how I caught Earth the previous game. It’s talking to talk
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Wylted is probably town. Miller is a risky claim but the way he claimed it and his realization about the complex mechanization of his role makes it seem more legit to me. I think we can move past him.
If it were anyone but Wylted, I would’ve agreed with you, but the way he specified after that it was only when he got to Imperial is weird to me. I’m wondering if it was a fake claim to begin with.
Also heads up I am generally not a fan of games that have weird flavor mechanics, I signed up for this one as a return favor since rex signed up for mine, but I just wanna play normal mafia, so I am going to try to treat this like a normal mafia game as much as possible. I honestly don't understand why mods want to over complicate stuff like this all the time, it seems like it always frustrates the players and ultimately always favors mafia.
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
First initial read is that Wryly seems kinda shy. It could be her personality, it could also be due to her alignment.
VTL Wryly
What do you find shy?
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
I do want a character and justification claim from Wylted because I can imagine this is something like, "the court gets more dangerous for you the more attention you attract".
+1
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
If I have this right, we've got an Emperor (Vader) who will be handing out favor every NP. The favor determines your ranking, which can fall into one of five categories: Concubine, Consort, Noble Consort, Imperial Noble Consort and Empress.
Scum have been given two fake claims (I don't think we get a lot out of pushing for softclaims with those, nor do I think outing the Empress is a good idea with a complex theme split), which means it's likely there are two scum in this game, with maybe a TP in the mix.
Hopefully I've at least got the gist. I've read through the posts so far and I find it pretty confusing that a negative utility role like Miller would activate from having more favor.
I think you’re just forgetting the ranking piece.
I agree with the Miller being activated with more favor being odd. But on the flip side from a balance standpoint it makes more sense. My concern is that this was a fake claim and the back track was a consequence of fellow scum realizing the slip
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Hold on, I didn't understand my role. I am only miller when I get a certain amount of favor. I guess I probably didn't even need to say anything
Thats really really odd.
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Well... here’s a thought. I assume Empress is Town. I also assume scum know which abilities are in the game, so it’s not like they would have to make up some night actions that aren’t possible, so there’s no value to the Empress hiding these night actions.
I think Empress should instaclaim right now and tell us what abilities she has access to. Then, Vader decides on who to make the Empress. We can also determine who to give favour to, etc.
Honestly, maybe it’s a good idea to claim how much favour everyone has? Idk.
This post is just full of red flags for me. First, there’s no guarantee the Empress is a townie based on OP. The double vote is OP in the hands of scum. Ideally there should just not be an Empress as it’s too risky.
Second, if you think the Empress is town, it makes no sense for them to reveal themselves cause they become a target for scum.
Third, if you believe they’re town there’s no point in them claiming cause it purely benefits scum
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
I doubt Rex would force scum to “work their charms” on Vader so that he grants them night abilities. It’s likely that whatever night actions Vader can grant, scum have the ability to counter them (somehow).
People have roles in the game that can also give favor. But yes, it’s kind of common sense that scum have counters to town roles
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
I'm at a loss as to what soft claim format we could use, if we decided to soft. We're all female, all with variable ranks subject to change, and all harem... ites? Haremites? No that sounds like hare mites.
I don’t think soft claiming has any benefits at this stage with scum being given fake claims. I think the justification is going to be key here. If I die, which I usually do, focus on justification
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Fuck it. I am a miller.
Well, you know my thoughts on this. But based on OP, you get a passive role at Imperial Noble Consort
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Just like a good and righteous Emperor, I will be taking bribes for favor. Venmo 100 dollars will get you unlimited favor from me. I just payed for a vacation so any donations welcome
On a serious note. This will be interesting
What if I say that if I have enough favor, I can basically carry town the entire the game
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Whoever figures out this favor system and can tell me how it operates in a way my brain can understand would be great. Also keep the explanation concide
I think just reading it over a few times, a spreadsheet would help. The gist I got was that there are 5 ranks based on how much favor you have compared to others:
Concubine (less than 3 favor or 8th rank or worse)
Consort - (greater or equal than 4 favor + rank 4-7)
Noble Consort - (greater or equal than 6 favor + rank 2 and 3)
Imperial Noble Consort - (greater or equal than 8 favor + rank 1 ie most favor)
Empress - Appointed/Deposed by Emperor (Supa)
Now the other part is that each rank is connected to abilities. Concubines are Vanilla. Consorts have an odd or even ability. Noble consorts have both an odd/even ability. Imperial noble consorts get both odd/even and a passive. Empress gets both odd/even, passive, and a double vote
Once we get claims going, we can start populating the spreadsheet with starting favor and based on favors given by Supa
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
Alright I’m here. If anyone hasn’t gone skiing, they really should. It’s amazing
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
The big issue I have is when a game can be solved by mass claiming. If a game is able to be solved through claiming characters alone then the game is fundamentally broken.
Where I come from flavor claiming is usually extremely banned and is only permitted when flavor is NAI.
The point of the rule is to preserve the integrity of the game.
Then give fake claims or make the theme split complex. Not that hard lol
ILikePie5 · 9 months ago
No point to having a theme if you ban talking about character. Like what’s the point lol
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
I have an SOP claim. I will make it before the end of the DP. Just putting this here so nobody cries about how it should be my first post or some shit.
Why not just make it right now?
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
Don't think I've ever been in a 12p before. Are there guaranteed more than 2 scum with this many?
Usually 3 scum in a 12p game. But per OP, technically Supa doesn’t have a vote, so it’s really 11p, which is more balanced usually with 2 scum + TP imo
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
I’m fine with a Shining lynch. Whatever we decide should be done by tonight tho cause DP ends early morning tomorrow
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
What type of vibes?
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
I also dislike the whole talk about a commuter from REF. It’s oddly specific. Like I’m curious where that thought even came from.
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
Ascetic is one of those scummy claim. Usually when Luna gives role hints, they’re pretty substantial though. I don’t think Ascetic would be a derivative of one of those role. Still, it’s impossible to prove, and the behavior I don’t like either
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
unvote
VTL Shining
Does anyone else get sus vibes from Shining?
You read my mind. I’m fine nailing him down early.
VTL Shining
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
Anyway I literally see zero town motivation for banana to claim. It's dumb. In fact why not just wait until there is some heat on her before claiming so we can at least see some behavioral reads on her train later?
Can one of yall see if Banana has ever played in a past game where someone was a popular. I’m curious
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
ya im nowhere close to being n e where near pies level lol
Practice practice practice. Ive been playing for probably a decade now lol
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
Just asked Lunatic about this. He attaches mylo/lylo clauses to populars, so the quick hammer play isn't relevant.
Banana's still null. We have no behavior to go off, and the role isn't towny or scummy.
At best she’s role confirmed. Once we get more claims and flips, balance analysis will out her if she’s scum.
ILikePie5 · 10 months ago
Null on everyone but Kohai btw. In particular, everything Whiteflame has done is NAI in my book. Literally everything I can see as legit or faked.
Agree with this take. Very minimal scum lean in Shining though, but he’s just always scummy