whiteflame wrote:
Helz wrote:
whiteflame wrote:
I agree, though a bunch of roles like this is necessarily going to fall prey to (2). This role and others like it exist as roles used in actual games. I'm not saying that it's unimportant as a result (part of the reason I didn't use it in my game is that I didn't want to have to deal with determining whether any given post by Luna was "drunk enough"), just that it's going to be generally hard to accept the existence of a role like this regardless of whether it's real or not.
3 points as clear as I can make them
1- Such a role is borderline offensive to the player. They are placed into a game with a constraint by the host, not the scum and nerfed to have no role at all on top of it. I would almost certainly refuse to play if a host gave me that.
2- Such a role is literally bastard. Its the hosts decision on a super vague demand if the condition is met or not and someone will die if they do not meet it impacting the game. So the host has direct impact on the game.
3- This is a modkill function and the very last game Lunatic was super pissed about a mod kill. It would be wild for them to then turn around and cram a modkill obligation on a player that is not even any sort of rule break kinda deal.
Im pretty stuck on this.
Regarding 1 and 2, again, I'm not arguing that the role itself is a good role or one that people should be using in the game, only that it exists as a role that gets some play. I agree, it's the reason I didn't use the role in my game despite considering it and having a character all prepped out to use it. And if your point is that, as a result, you don't expect a mod would include this role and instead would more easily believe that a player would fake it, I agree with that as well. The only reason why this case is different is because I literally discussed this exact role with Luna in my Frieren game, which is why I'm having more trouble just buying into that.
Regarding 3, yeah, that's a sticking point. Even if I believe Luna would want to have some fun with this role, I can't see him opening the door for a potential modkill. He'd have to be absolutely confident that Kohai wouldn't fuck it up.
Two be kleae Luna did state thattt it really only had to be une or two words. Ive beeen a bit tooo deeeo into my karacter.
+My autistik brain enterpreted to mean every post
