Kohai

And why would they kill Vader over Castin, a tracker that has far more town utility

And wtf is a character cop doing in this game?

How on earth was Vader the NK?

we are now in LyLo so no one should be voting yet

Thank Gd I can go home and sleep without having to worry about this

Well that’s the hammer.

1000% agree

Why the right hell would Rex think up a role like this as scum, it sounds like horse shit

My guess is that he’s a scum role cop. If he’s a scum role cop claiming that off the bat would be really sus. In this setup a role cop for scum make perfect sense.

If ref is being honest and whiteflame is town then at least white white flame can use that role tonight

In the event he is being honest then Whiteflame can use it.

meanwhile everything about refs claim just makes no sense and he’s changed his story twice. In 10 years of playing mafia. I’ve ever seen a character cop. It also makes little sense in this fame given mafia have a yazkua and no really incentive to fake claim a character. He has to wait every other night to use it and has a very small chance of hitting someone that would even have the incentive to fake claim. It just literally is a useless role and I think Luna balances better than that. 

I agree with this analysis.

Why are you sussing Pie?

Only reason is he’s a prime recruit. That said he’s irrefutably not the original scum. Going by behavior he’s one of my stronger town reads.

Behavior wise I can almost bet there’s at least one scum between ref and pie. However there’s a zero percent chance pie is the original scum

Just caught up. I’m parking my vote on Rex. I argue we should lynch the role that has the least town utility

Unvote

I didn't realize ref was already at l2. I don't want to make the same mistake last dp!

1.) Nothing, I just die and my role doesn’t activate

OK, fair point. Thoughts on lynching the player with the least town utility?

I’ll ask, but my PM specifically says night killed. Thats why I asked earlier if your shot counts as a night kill if you remember

Please confirm with the mod what happens if you are killed by lynching or by a vengeful town

Unvote

VTL Rex

If we can’t come to any agreement then I argue we should lynch the claim that has the least town utility

That’s not how my role works. If I die in the night, the next NP gets skipped. That’s why I was trying to bait the NK.

can you confirm what happens if you are day killed?

I would say if this was DP1 and we had no info then pie and Mikal would be the top of my town pile

Whiteflame, pie, and Rex are in my POE.

From the claims castin is still my strongest town read. What real irks me about Rex is his foundering, contradictions, his refusal to claim, and his role seems to have far more scum utility than town utility.

I’d also be willing to lynch pie. If he dies we skip a night phase plus he’s a prime recruit. There’s a zero percent probability he is original scum, however.

Wryly

Mikal

RexFavilla

Vader

iLikePie5

Whiteflame

but the thing that’s making me second guess that is because you said Lina told you the split was hard. How would the split be hard if when Casey’s characters dies. It outright names your character. 

Exactly. Im town.

Exactly why I believe pie to be original town. Again, the question is whether or not he was recruited.

Also, if that's the case then maybe pie is the best lynch. If pie was original scum or was recruited then there won't be a NK. There's a high probability of him being recruited, far more so than other players like vader.

Character: Ellen Ripley

Role: Martyr

Justification: I am the protagonist of the original Alien moves and have faced Xenomorphs the most. In the third movie I was impregnated by an Alien Queen and jumped in a lava pit to kill myself so that Weyland couldn’t use my offspring as a weapon

From MS:

A Martyr's death negation may only work when the Martyr is eliminated. Alternately, a Martyr's death negation may only work when the Martyr dies during the night.

A Martyr may instead cause the next day's elimination to fail when the Martyr dies, this makes the Martyr similar to a Beloved Princess.

@Ilikepie, are you saying that if you die, either through lynching or nk that there will be no deaths during the night phase?

Shower thought: Whiteflame is extremely dangerous, possibly far more dangerous than I am. If whiteflame is scum, either original or recruited, they could obtain my vengeful status and use it the next day phase if they are lynched!

Also, I confirmed with the mod they would not block me from being recruited.

I’m David 8. Set out to make “the perfect Organism” using black goo, faked my own death, took Walter One’s place along with his role as the crew’s AI unit.

I’m the Scavenger. If I target a dead townie, I can inherit their role for that night and can use it. I picked Thoth, used his Apportioner on David, as I was pretty certain he was town coming off of the last DP (he wouldn’t put himself in a 1v1 situation with Thoth if he was scum).

Sounds legit. I wonder if that would also stop them from recruiting me

Disregard. My brain didn’t trace the part about Casey replacing.

Ironically this actually strengthens my TR on you.

Thoth or Casey knowing is scum is (say Thoth asked) is irrelevant. Unless they were both told the full set up after they died or somrthing. But I’m assuming Casey would not ask that. If you die as scum you typically can keep talking in the scum you pm (at least I allow it) so why would they ask and lose their ability to contribute. My point being is that Casey should be able to replace supa is he’s scum

I am really not following the logic. Casey is scum and replaces another scum they just get hyper lynched again because everyone knows they're scum.

Town can replace into scum (as I did in your game) but I don't see scum being able to replace into a game as any alignment.