Before I get down to reading, I received game information from an unknown source during the NP. I can reveal that information at any time, though it might be best reserved for after we get some more character claims.
If it could narrow the POE that would be very helpful
I was glancing and saw 2/5 so didn’t pay attention cus I figured it was beyond safe.
Fair.
updated read list
Town core:
rex
castin
mikal
No read
Vader - start playing
Null:
whiteflame
pie
5- Vader
In my unofficial vote count I did specifically mention it was L-2. The only thing I didn’t do is update the 2/5 to be 3/5.
Unofficial Vote Count:
Thoth- 2/5- RexFavilla, Pie, Kohai - L2
Vader- 1/5- Kohai
Kohai- 1/5- Thoth
Castin - 1/5 Mikal (I missed this in the last vc)
Not voting: Whiteflame, Vader, Casey, Wryly
Another problem is that you hammered almost immediately after whiteflame’s vote so I don’t even think you saw that he voted before putting down the vote
But did you really need to full claim as well
Once you officially lay a counter claim yes
From a scum perspective, it just means you get to take out a townie when your dude is lynched. Is that powerful? Yeah. Is it better than taking over a top-tier player who is widely townread? Personally, I'd take the latter route.
Not a bad analysis. Also, I would add that the entire shit show yesterday would have been completely avoided if he didn’t immediately claim my character flavor.
Also Rex gets a town read
I swear God is sending this website a series of 10 mafia plagues to convince you guys that full claiming early is retarded
I feel your frustration and this is why I have a problem with flavor claiming in general. However when Thoth claimed my flavor I was essentially forced to counter claim immediately.
Kohai is town, is lynched, shoots the wrong person = insta-loss, scum reaches parity
Kohai is town, is lynched, waives = we're okay, but we're at LYLO next DP
Kohai is scum, is lynched = we're in the clear and at 3-1 next DP
It’s not instant if I shoot the wrong person.
assuming we are 5-2 and I get lynched it is definitely best that I do not shoot unless it’s voted otherwise or there is someone that becomes confirmed scum
Yeah that works. Why didn't this group change to that? Just an inconveniently longer word?
Meta and tradition.
Most sites use Vote: Playername to eliminate someone. We shorten it to VTL
Most places use the word eliminate.
If you are lynched this DP for math reasons, you intend to take the 66% chance of shooting a townie by mistake?
I confirmed I am waiving. I will do what the consensus is. If you vote to lynch me I want you to say if and who I should shoot
I’ll check. I think it’s voluntary though I intend on using it
I want pie to claim first. Mostly because he’s human. I have a pretty good TR on Mikal. Assuming there’s mafia between Mikal and Pie it’s probably pie
I agree. I’m free whenever, but tomorrow at noon CST seems reasonable
I’m at work at that time. I won’t be around.
Vader posted only once this last day phase. Granted he said he was busy and the day ended way earlier than it should have.
I am Ok with a game of popcorn.
Confirmed it does not count
Can you ask if your kill after being lynched counts as a nightkill
I don’t believe so. I’ll ask the mod
A recruit role really fucks with the game. There has to be some balance to it.
Yeah. Which is why I am thinking an anti recruit role could exist
Ngl this bothers the fuck out of me too. There is not even consideration of a TP, or some other scenario. It's an affirmative statement.
I highly doubt there is a third party
Math wise, if hes scum and alive tomorrow the game is over. Check me, but I've checked it twice. Assuming there is no nk preventions.
If you’re that paranoia then I’ll gladly volunteer to be the lynch today. Though I would want to have discussion on who I should take down with me. I’m not going to act without input
Nope. I am actually quite shocked tbh. I confirmed that with the mod. We could technically go to F3, I get lynched, and town can still win if I kill correctly.
How? 2-1, you getting lynched puts scum at parity and win
Because I kill them when I die and there’s only town left. This was confirmed with the mod.
also another possibility is they purposely did not recruit me to make me a lynch target and hope I’d kill town so they’d get three townies at once.
unlikely based on how a role stopping mechanic would work. Role would only trigger if it was successful. At least it would be stupid if she killed herself and the action did not go off. I can't see a world where a Mod would process something in that order.
this is fair. We will wait for others to claim
I know. Which is why I am really shocked I wasn’t the recruit.
A possible thought: Perhaps I was recruited but the recruit failed and Casey still died? Would this make any sense if I was jail kept or somehow blocked from being recruited?
wait your role does not stop at mylo or lylo?
Nope. I am actually quite shocked tbh. I confirmed that with the mod. We could technically go to F3, I get lynched, and town can still win if I kill correctly.
This is a fair point of discussion. MS and MU retired and banned the lynch word years ago. Our site meta is unique and never changed.
to be clear I’ll never ban or warn someone because they used the L word in a game as this has been our meta for decades.
I really am scared of you tbh. You had already claimed vengeful Dp1 so you are the logical mafia recruit (you mentioned this also). I am not sure if this is feigned either. But logically based you would make the most sense to grab as it is a free kill if you ever get targeted for a lynch.
agreed with all of this which is why I’m shocked I wasn’t the recruit. Plus I’m kinda tired of randing town all the time. I’d love to be able to play a proper scum game
He was one of my stronger town reads DP1 behaviorally. I really dislike that he is saying he cannot confirm my action.
fair point. I’ll wait for pie to claim. Who are your strongest town and mafia reads
fair point. TBH he is still my strongest scum read and it is not just because of flavor claiming
You need to claim also
