If either of you are ready for your games go ahead and post sign ups. Thoths isn’t a real mafia game and is held off site so your probably good to get it going.
If either of you are ready for your games go ahead and post sign ups. Thoths isn’t a real mafia game and is held off site so your probably good to get it going.
Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/31/2026 at 1:02 PM (post #16)
Sorry but that just irks me dude, especially considering it got four likes. I really could have planned better for his suicide, but I take exception to the idea that I shouldn't expect him not to commit suicide.
Hey I didn’t mean that as a jab at you or a critic of your play at all. You did very well in this game. In hindsight reading that I can see why you took it as “blaming the victim of being wylteds scum partner” lmao but I promise it wasn’t meant that way.
If anything I am agreeing that Wylted has a reckless playstyle. I am just saying since I know how Wylted will play, when I am his scum partner I will change my own personal playstyle to him, because I know him. I would do the same for any of my scum partners really. If I was scum with pie, I know we’d probably be making extremely safe plays that ensure the win with 0 risk, which is not my personal favorite way to play scum, but I know he’s all about securing the dub so I’d play it that way with him. Wasn’t criticizing your play at all I really hope you know. If anything I was agreeing with you about Wylted being reckless. I’ve just realized that complaining about how people play doesn’t help most of the time. Some times it does lol. But alot of these people that play still are still doing the same stuff they did years ago, so I just kind of started accepting certain behaviors and playing around them.
My bad if it sounds like I was lecturing you. Not at all what I was going for.
Tbh I wouldn’t expect Wylted to play conservative. If I was scum I’d just adapt my playstyle and strategy around him to make optimal plays
GGs guys sorry about inactivity. Looks like town clutched it up.
Originally Posted by wylted on 7/24/2026 at 6:06 AM (post #156)
When I pointed out that Role cop didn't CC cop last day phase, you didn't seem to disagreee, but now you do?
You're not the problem. There are others who either said it wasn't a CC or stood by and said nothing to disagree with everyone telling me both roles can be in the game, who are now saying the direct opposite thing
But you are voting me using that reasoning saying I forced your hand. If you don’t believe the CC thing is an issue, why do you have to vote me?
Originally Posted by Thoth on 7/24/2026 at 12:31 AM (post #154)
Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/24/2026 at 1:21 AM (post #153)
Originally Posted by wylted on 7/23/2026 at 10:15 PM (post #146)
Nothing has changed between that CC and now, and I thought we were no lynching but since lunatic wanted to play that game
When I pointed out that Role cop didn't CC cop last day phase, you didn't seem to disagreee, but now you do?
Does Rolecop normally reveal alignment? Like, would it show whether a role that can be either alignment is town or scum? If so, that's kind of a CC.
No, it should just tell a role.
VTL: wylted
Anyone else smell a potential Wylted and Thoth bus?
Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/23/2026 at 5:41 PM (post #135)
Man I don't have time for this game. Are we lynching wylted or VTNLing or what? And why tf am I being scumread?
Its more a POE thing than a scumread if your referring to my pairings. I town read bananas role, I doubt its pie since he’s hated, which basically leaves you Wylted and Thoth. You me and Wylted are all claimed investigative roles so it stands to reason that one of us is likely scum and I know it’s not me.
I will say I may be paranoid but your continued “surprised that people didn’t get your joke” thing is almost feeling a bit like theater which started with you and Wylted, but maybe I am looking too much into that. Not seeing a ton of interaction between the two of you otherwise which makes a pairing seem likely. I do give you some slight cred for being among the first to claim an odd/even factor but there’s is a possibility mafia was informed of that mechanic.
Scummier*
Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 7/23/2026 at 12:35 PM (post #130)
Who is your scum team at the moment?
Either Wylted / Wryly or Wylted / Thoth. Not sure who is scummed out of wryly and Thoth yet. I like wrylys claim better in a way but Thoths makes more sense for the night kill I think. I haven’t done a deep dive on their behaviors yet.
Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/23/2026 at 11:55 AM (post #127)
Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/23/2026 at 7:50 AM (post #118)
Thats kind of a knee jerk noob reaction to that imo. I was already forced to claim cop early. The probability of me surviving or even getting a result off in night phase two is very low at this point, so all I can hope to do to get value out of my role is make some sort of play or gambit. Didn’t expect so many even/ odd roles though so the gambit I had in mind didn’t apply well here.
Throwing that "noob reaction" shade when I am a proud patron of Weenie Hut Jr's, wow. I from the hood, son. I play the game.
Didn't mean to be harsh, but it seemed obvious at least to me, that a play to try to get any utility out of a wasted cop claim would be neccesary.
Originally Posted by wylted on 7/23/2026 at 5:45 AM (post #116)
Not using the vote detector is beyond retarded. I don't think that wylted would have used any other ability last night.
Are you kidding me?
If I use a role cop than I can potentially narrow down who scum is with a 100% certainty.
Censor doesn't do shit
Care to elaborate how denser “doesn’t do shit”?
Originally Posted by Thoth on 7/22/2026 at 9:16 PM (post #101)
Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/22/2026 at 9:58 PM (post #92)
Heads up I’m an even night cop, was trying to bait reactions to see if I was actually roleblocked or something to see if scum would have caught on to me lying and say something to give away that they knew my result wasn’t real.
No.
Counter Argument: Yes
Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/22/2026 at 10:17 PM (post #106)
Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/22/2026 at 10:58 PM (post #92)
Holy shit I so don’t have time for this game right now lol
Heads up I’m an even night cop, was trying to bait reactions to see if I was actually roleblocked or something to see if scum would have caught on to me lying and say something to give away that they knew my result wasn’t real. But I did not have the time and availability to do any sort of gambit or bait with my play. So no wryly is not innocent by result. Looks like banana is claiming even night roleblocker so if she is scum that is likely a counter to my role. Will have to think about that though Mikal also admitted to having a scummy role. Wierd for town to have a counter to cop though
Oh what the hell. I thought you saw my pureness of heart and deemed me worthy of Mjolnir!
Seriously, now you're claiming you're an even night and you lied about your result? Struggling to not see this as you adapting your role after you saw everyone else claiming odd/even abilities and reframing your inno result as a reaction test.
Thats kind of a knee jerk noob reaction to that imo. I was already forced to claim cop early. The probability of me surviving or even getting a result off in night phase two is very low at this point, so all I can hope to do to get value out of my role is make some sort of play or gambit. Didn’t expect so many even/ odd roles though so the gambit I had in mind didn’t apply well here.
I’m more and more confident this is Wylted just based on his action making 0 sense and he is one of the only roles without an odd even mechanic. And if he is a rolecop it would make sense if Vader was targeted over Whiteflame if they saw he was a lover and would get a second death out of it. According to wryly Whiteflame wasn’t visited right? Going off of memory so that may be wrong
Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/22/2026 at 8:28 PM (post #88)
Originally Posted by wylted on 7/22/2026 at 2:25 PM (post #75)
I didn't know we were all claiming.
Fine
1x tracker and vote detector, which tells me how many scum were on a lynch
Why tf didn't you use the Sensor on Kohai's wagon then? We could've had a POE.
^^^^^
Holy shit I so don’t have time for this game right now lol
Heads up I’m an even night cop, was trying to bait reactions to see if I was actually roleblocked or something to see if scum would have caught on to me lying and say something to give away that they knew my result wasn’t real. But I did not have the time and availability to do any sort of gambit or bait with my play. So no wryly is not innocent by result. Looks like banana is claiming even night roleblocker so if she is scum that is likely a counter to my role. Will have to think about that though Mikal also admitted to having a scummy role. Wierd for town to have a counter to cop though
I kid I kid. I’ll be on later on, going to bed.
I have an innocent on wryly. Taking it with a major grain of salt because I was left alone last night which means scum clearly weren’t worried about a cop.
Originally Posted by Thoth on 7/21/2026 at 7:30 PM (post #2)
Kohai’s speculation about an extra kill was less stupid than I thought. With Pie’s Hated in play, nobody casts a vote there unless we are collectively sure we want to lynch him.
I have jury duty tomorrow.
It was a lover death not an extra kill technically.
Well I have an innocent. Surprised I wasn't killed or blocked. I'll sit on it for now, and reveal before EOD just to see how people react around each other and see if I can do anything with the reactions.
Wonder who was targeted out of the two lovers. My guess would be whiteflame? I want to look at their reads when I have a sec and see who they seemed suspicious of.
I mean Kohai might be town, but we need a lynch and a vt isnt a huge loss, also he will never confirm his role, so its not like a bad lynch or anything.