Gun to my head, my scum reads are rex and wylted though I don't neccesarily think they are scum together more likely one or the other, though its possible. Rex seemed to get baited hard into the mago thing, and then appeared to back off of it to a null read, just to double down again on it. Considering he was the host of Ruyi Zhan and saw mago's town behavior first hand, it feels strange to me that he is scum reading the lie here so hard. Especially when it seemed (at least to me) super obviously a town lie.
Wylted I am scum reading for the convenience of the claim. If he had claimed miller at the start of the game it would be more believable, and I would almost call him confirmed from it since I would have doubted mafia would have used their fake claim at that point. However the late entry and claiming AFTER the cop is giving me bad vibes. Like I am understanding that this is wylted and its something he would do as town as well, and it could just genuinely be bad luck that he didn't know about the day phase until too late. But we also have 4 claims on the table, and I don't think we need to narrow down POE for scum any further, so out of all the claimed individuals, I probably would be the most comfortable lynching wylted.
VTL wylted.
Pie feels okay for now, plus he told me he was town and he would never lie to me! (Joke btw)
Alyssa gave me some town vibes for not instantly pursuing mago, but I 100% understand the suspicion of him since I went through the same thing with mago in a recent game. Mago is just a baffling player, so the fact that alyssa is being reserved about this is a town tell, and shows shes not being oppertunistic.
Shining, thoth, are null.
Vader is town. At the very worst, scum used both role claims and got cop/miller combo, but it feels highly unlikely.