Mag1cman

I’m me, I have an ability called “claim analyst.” Justification is me tearing apart multiple fake claims in the past. If someone full claims, I can pick either their character or their role and learn if it is true or false.


I targeted Kohai NP3 and got a “true” result, and my action failed when I targeted Awesome last night. I think there is a godfather or lawyer in the game so I still sus Kohai, but it’s why I became willing to go for Shining and Banana first.


My role is affected by millers and godfathers and the like, and it fails when targeting other guilds, which made me think I Pie was redirected into me for a bit.

Mag1cman

We still got two scum lmao. We are winning. Even if this is a mislynch we are far from behind lol

Mag1cman

tbh my confidence in Banana/Kohai is very high and I wouldn’t care if that were hammer anyway

Mag1cman

I’ll hold off on claiming until next DP. Pie and Whiteflame already have the full claim so they can out it if I die

Mag1cman

Did you get confirmation that a strengthener would nullify that, and make your results read town if a miller was town?

Mag1cman
Wryly basically said she was going to investigate but not who and had Awesome strengthen her. He says he did. I confirmed to Mikal that if a non-strengthened cop targeted me, they would get a guilty, and if a strengthened cop targeted me, they would get an innocent. Wryly got an innocent on me. This was all her plan, literally nobody knew who she was targeting. So, If Wryly is the town cop (which everyone accepts as far as I know) it proves that I am town and that Awesome is a strengthener and strengthened Wryly instead of doing something else. There was no way to bus drive the targets as they had no way to know it was me. We did mention Banana as a possible investigative target, so there is the small possibility that it's an Awesome/Banana scum team and they have a redirector and manipulated the result to get a false inno because they thought Banana would be investigated, but unless Banana flips scum Awesome is basically town.

Can you two confirm this?


@Wryly are you able to confirm the bolded part by asking Mikal?

Mag1cman
My worry is the SJW is a TP who can choose to side with scum, not that he was given as a fake claim.

fwiw I've been trying to poke Whitelfame now and then in guild chat about this.

Mag1cman
I really want to trust Luna's read on REF, but that's so far the strongest reason I have to townread him and I can't say it's strong enough at this point to keep him out of POE. The role itself is interesting enough that I have trouble believing it's a fake claim, so he's still slight town to me, but only just.

I have few behavior things I like but it's not super strong.


Kohai is a bit of an odd duck. I have a little more reason to townread him than not, but I'll have to go back through his posts and see if that holds up. Didn't like him early in the game, but he's given me more reason to townread him as the game has gone on. Maybe that's just from my experience with him as scum coloring my opinion.


I'm highly confident he's scum here. He TMI'd two DPs ago and he vs Shining has been a thing all game long.


And that leaves three.


Banana and Awesome are the obvious ones, I don't think any of us have strong reasons to buy their claims at this point. I think Awesome's claim looks like something Mikal would make up, but that's about the best I can say about him. And Banana was on the verge of being lynched last DP in direct opposition to Shining who has flipped town, so she's bound to look scummy at this point.


I could see either with Kohai at this point.


Mestari is tricky. I think a lot of people are quick to write him off as town because he was very effectively scum hunting and helped take down both Thoth and Alyssa. In almost any other game, I would agree and view him as almost certainly town. But this isn't a usual game. The activation of the Ant King mid-game makes me question whether scum have a player who is/was separate from the main scum team and sees a benefit in taking down much of the scum team to boot. The Ant King activated only after the Ant Queen was lynched, so yes, I could see that as either part of their wincon or just a way to take over and run the team on their own. Thoth and Alyssa would probably have flamed out without his help, so I can absolutely see wanting to change things up to put both himself and the remaining member of the scum team in better position. This theory is not a reason to outright scumread him, but it colors my perspective of behaviors I was reading as townie for much of the early game.

I have a few town behavior things I like about Mestari but honestly this isn't that crazy of a theory. I didn't consider this.

Mag1cman

Pie and I talked about the Shining lynch last DP in guild chat. I felt if Shining was somehow town (yes Rex I see that he was), the odds are high it's Kohai/Banana. 1. Based on Kohai vs Shining being something that didn't peg me as scum v scum, 2. General scumminess of Kohai, 3. Banana vs Shining from last DP.

Mag1cman
I could argue Casey added a few irrelevant details in the PMs, including yours. Your's (Pheonix) said you bluff alot. I would argue Pheonix is flanderized a bit and he bluffs as much as he considers the most outlandish option and has it turn out well for him. You say that Godot's coffee gimmick isn't important but Godot's three character traits are coffee, liked Mia and hates Pheonix. It might be weak in retrospect but you are nitpicking in hindsight and lets face it, you are only doing it because you have nothing else on me this game and want to find any reason I am scum.


Lol @ going from saying I'm town to OMGUSing me.


  1. Mharman - You are Phoenix Wright! You are the famous bluffing defense attorney who always finds a way to win, even when all seems hopeless. You’ve saved many clients over the years, including ones who likely would have received the death penalty if found guilty. You are the 2x Doctor. Once per night, you may choose to save someone. That player cannot be killed that NP. You may only use this ability twice in total. You win with the Town.


This was my PM from that game. Bluffing was more flavor than the justification for Phoenix Wright being the Doctor. You advertised the love of coffee like it was a bonus for Godot being strengthener in that game.

Mag1cman

Anyway that's all I have to say this DP. Let's lynch Shining guys. I think he's scummiest (it's close with Kohai tho), and the results will be very useful for both Banana and Kohai.

Mag1cman
It wasn't just "I love coffee lmao" it was also the fact that Godot was a major ally of Mia Fey before she died.

I'm aware you had a main justification but 1."Love of coffee" was unnecessary to tack on and 2. irrelevant to the story of Ace Attorney.

Mag1cman

Also, I'm not too concerned with Mestari faking being silenced. Doesn't change my townread of him, if anything there's no chance scum would ditch and expose their own silencer gambit. If you want my thoughts on Awesome, ISO me, you'll see it in previous DPs- those haven't really changed.