Mag1cman
Shrug. I didn't. I think it's a legitimate stance that once a mass claim is started, it should be finished, otherwise it defeats the purpose, exposing info about town but potentially letting scum slip through the net. However when whiteflame brought up some valid points that we had a better target and if we were wrong you'd be soon to full claim next DP anyway, I acquiesced.

I disagree with the mass claim idea but that’s a better explanation of things from your point of you. Hm.

Mag1cman

If I’m looking for a prominent fake claim I’m not taking from a list of mostly minor characters. I’m going straight for coaches or players; mods usually leave out a few major characters in these games.


And as do your history with Shining, does that encompassing one of you getting the other lynched DP1? Pretty sure it doesn’t, and my history with any teammate is to distance some, not full-on hard bus. Absolutely no reason to bus Shining DP1 when I could’ve gone for Wylted and bussed Shining DP2 or later, at least securing a mislynch there and getting use of his redirector.


”How much that point is in my favor” shouldn’t even be a question here; it’s 100%. Literally all of it.

Mag1cman

I took the asking for a consensus as a further attempt to keep looking for info. I felt it had already been settled at that point

Mag1cman
Wryly

Kinda did nothing all of last DP, although was busy. I don't like her vote at the end of last DP, and this DP, I don't like how she pressed on after I got online, whilst everyone else listened to me.

She is however, asking some ok questions about the situation at hand. Yes, I got a justification, although it feels half-assed.

So here's my read of Wryly from DP2. I forgot about a few of these points. Asking questions is fine, I still don't like continuing to press for claims after I hard rejected doing so.

Mag1cman

honestly Wryly not knowing she could VTNL and then use her role is apoint in favor of her possibly doing the gambit

Mag1cman

vote to not lynch


the idea is that we limit things down to the final three so there's one less person in the equation to worry about


usually done in evens in mylo, converts the situation to lylo


I don't want to do it here bc if you're gambiting outing your actual role as scum, VTNLing is auto loss

Mag1cman
It's more like I forgot about the softclaim and thought you'd have a broader range of options than you actually did, but fair enough.

I'll give you this.


Flo was at the top of the "Other" list, so she would have stood out as the most likely safe claim in that bunch.

If she was at the top of the list, you mean least? Otherwise you're just contradicting the point you just made.


Wouldn't be a first for Shining to encourage some bussing even that early (I've been scum with him enough to know), but fair enough that you would have had to push him pretty hard.

I doubt he would want to go that far, and regardless, I wouldn't have cared if he encouraged it. If I'm his teammate, I'm not hard-bussing him like that. There's distance, and then there's getting your own teammate lynched. At the time of my first vote on him, I had the choice to pressure him or Wylted. I felt he was scummier than Wylted.


If writing out my conflicting thoughts in real time makes it look like I'm blowing smoke up your ass, then I guess we're not reading the same thoughts. I never said you were lock town, just that I had behavioral reasons to townread you and one potential indicator from Kohai's play. I'll be happy to give you a full breakdown when I've had a chance to go through everything.

Sure.

Mag1cman

As for Wryly:


If she's gambiting, this is a crazy gambit. I can understand Wryly feeling the need to gambit since she was everyone's secondary scumread. Votebuyer is pretty crazy. I think there's a few other roles she could gambit. Even not gambiting and just claiming some small PR would probably be better. There is a reason it could be plausible- and it's basically just Shining + Wryly = two mafiosos who have no idea how to claim. But it's still a crazy aggressive move. Why not hide it and VTNL? Maybe she didn't spot such a play and overthought things?


As for her behavior, she did basically nothing the first DP only to vote Wylted after it was over. If she was late, it doesn't change the fact that scum has an incentive to hammer at that point. DP2, not really much to write home about. Lemme go double check what Wylted had to say about her

Mag1cman
I don't think you'd claim Flo given that you knew everyone else's characters at this point. I gave you a list of major characters from which a couple are still missing. You could have chosen any of them, and your risk of claiming a different role and avoiding a CC wouldn't even be that high.

Yes and no. We all softed. It's fair to say I could've claimed a different category than "other," (so there's truth to this on a macro level), but what you said just isn't correct.


I don't see you letting Shining crash out that hard, not with the 2X Redirector on the table. At the very least, I don't think it's likely you'd call that much attention to his claim in particular.

It's not just that, it's the fact that I would've hard bussed my teammate DP1. For basically all of the DP I had Shining as the #1 guy I wanted dead.


I haven't had much time to dig backward yet, but looking at Kohai's posts, he solidly townread you just for pushing back on the massclaim. I found that odd at the time, but it makes me wonder if he copped you innocent. I think it's far less likely that he copped Wryly guilty and just assumed she was the hidden Miller. I'd say it's roughly the same likelihood as him having targeted REF, but it's a factor I'm considering.

Possible.


Idk man. Some of this logic looks off. Like you're just trying to find reasons to townread me while only sneaking in the big one. Feels like blowing smoke up my ass to get me off you.

Mag1cman
At least at first blush, I buy Wryly's character and role more than Mag1c's. The 3 Vanillas are a factor, but Flo is a significantly more minor character than anyone else that has been claimed/flipped so far. I'll be spending some time digging back into the previous two DPs before providing more thoughts, but I figured I should start with this beforehand.

It's part of the reason I didn't buy Rebecca being vanilla. And you yourself said a minor character could be in the game. What changed?

Mag1cman

If anyone needs a reason to believe I'm town, here you go


Honestly I don’t care for either Rex or Shining. Shining’s lazy like usual but post 30 is weird to me. The thought process is literally just that is probably not Kohai by the numbers… which just ignores past setups. Also opens the door to arguments for any guilty result being the hidden miller.
I actually wouldn’t mind claims from both.
VTL Shining

124


Shining’s actually my top scumread.

127


I don’t doubt he has the role. It’s like Banana’s popular claim, people are gonna test it.
The issue here is that scum can, in fact, be ascetic.

138


Shining’s still probably the lynch here.
VTL Shining

184


Well, if Pie was shot out of nowhere it’s probably a sign mafia wanted him dead.
Which is probably a sign he was accurate with his read on Shining

213


Yeah let’s just finish what we started
VTL Shining

221




Mag1cman

Flo Collins, Vanilla


The role pm is basically a description of her and what she does in the series. I think the justification is the part where it talks about her bringing out the best in Rebecca and being truthful to her, even when the truth hurts. Like I said last DP, feels half-assed.


Was trying to draw scum's attention away from an actual PR, since y'all were making things too easy for scum by outing characters. Either they saw through it or they had Kohai down as a kill earlier in the game.



Mag1cman

After constantly getting distracted by other things, I've run out of attention span for the day so I'll make this quick


Banana


Everything I said last DP still applies. Suboptimal play, but behaviorally townie response to Wylted's accusation. As for today, I appreciate her not pressuring for other claims after I jumped in the thread, even if she doesn't(?) agree with me. Still town.


Wylted


Last DP he threw susses around constantly, in particular after it looked like Shining was about to be lynched. Yes, he was on the wagon but he was far from the first person to join. As has been documented, his claim is weird. I don't think Pie's PM makes for a good point, but "almost passive" and then claiming vanilla makes me think he was looking for a claim for later and just fumbled with what he was trying to soft. the things that gave me pause on DP1 remain, I'll admit.


This DP, he's not done much to defend himself at all. I understand his hand is burned, but he was online earlier, and all he had to say was something about serving eggs to a celebrity. I'm not impressed.


Wryly


Kinda did nothing all of last DP, although was busy. I don't like her vote at the end of last DP, and this DP, I don't like how she pressed on after I got online, whilst everyone else listened to me.


She is however, asking some ok questions about the situation at hand. Yes, I got a justification, although it feels half-assed.


Whiteflame


Was mostly null last DP, although I felt he gave a lot of lip service to the Shining lynch before actually joining, but it was mostly because he was on Wylted's ass, which I can understand. I think he should've known better than to start that mass character claim with Kohai. Just not much to go off of here.


Kohai


For reasons explained last DP, I think Kohai is town. I will add here that I have a lot of respect for him being early on the Shining lynch. I don't like him starting the mass character claim, but what happened last DP is extremely hard to ignore. So still pretty hard town. There is a possible tinfoil surrounding the info scum was given at the start of the game, but meh.


If I had to order it I'd go like this:


Wylted

Wryly

Whiteflame

Kohai

Banana


VTL Wylted

Mag1cman

Well, you know where I stand.


Giving scum all our characters is exactly how we throw here.


And I’m down for deal Whiteflame proposed.

Mag1cman

Well, you know where I stand.


Giving scum all our characters is exactly how we throw here.


And I’m down for deal Whiteflame proposed.