Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Anyway, anyone outside of Whiteflame’s dream is town confirmed. Kinda similar to the ruling we had on Magoroth’s sensor from last game

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Had Thoth among his town picks for much of last DP, but also mentioned at the top of this DP in post #5 that Thoth is in his town pool despite being... dead.

I said that was my town pile headed into NP1. Yknow, before Thoth died.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Soldier is hard for me to buy but so is Motion Detector. I don’t care, I think Wylted is correct that there’s one in there.


I’m Stephen Miller, current deputy policy chief of staff, and former speechwriter guy. I put Donald Trump’s actions into words making me the Messenger.


Last night I visited Thoth, thinking Wylted would be the night kill. From there it was a 50/50 between him and Rex and I couldn’t tell the difference between either choice. So I went with Thoth.


I got unlucky, but it’s not 1x so I can try again in the night phase to at least confirm my role.



Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

My town block entering NP1:


-Wylted for CCing Kohai

-Thoth for the consistent an early sus of Kohai

-Rex for being an early adopter of the Kohai wagon

-Magoroth for choosing Kohai when he could've helped me start a Rex wagon.


I'll double check a few things but I still kinda like this. The potential for a tinfoil on Wylted is not something I'm particularly excited about.


PoE is Shining, Whiteflame, Banana.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Hate to be that guy (especially because I townread him behaviorally), but I don't like how Wylted isn't dead.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Bruh. Little brother decided to go do something else.


Anyway, I see Kohai has been CC’d and lynched. Interesting.


Could prove me wrong on Rex.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Wylted has been towntelling all game long. Thoth is my other big town pick. Kohai I'm a little less certtain on, but imma trust in Post #51.


Anyway Imma play Minecraft with bro again. Go ahead and lynch someone; I personally want Rex here. I've concluded his whole "just asking questions to start a discussion guys" is pretending to be unaware, while fence-sitting and seeing what discussions he can get around someone that might get them mislynched, all while fake contributing.


VTL Rex


I don't care for VTNLing, but it's out of my hands. If you need my vote for any lynch, I'll briefly check the thread with 15 minutes to go.


If you are scumreading someone off their character claim, it's a stupid read. Scum has four questions to use for a fake claim; they are not gonna straight claim their characters.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I have more pause on Rex. The version of events he gave is somewhat accurate- Kohai did vote for Thoth before Wylted pushed for policy on Thoth. But Kohai’s vote was a joke vote. It became serious after Wylted’s pushed to policy on Thoth. So it’s not damning discrepancy imo.


I will say that being so quick to join a policy, and staying after the mod has resolved the issue, is a bit concerning. I remember Shining was the only person to join me when I wanted to policy Thoth last game. But Kohai remains slight town in my book.


Back to Rex, his explanation for not voting is interesting- but you can still throw a vote at someone you sus and have a discussion. If anything, a vote forces people to react and discuss a bit more. So I still think he don’t generate discussion the right way. But the explanation he gave, somewhat gives me the impression that he really believes his theory behind not voting. So hmm.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Idk how many votes Shining is on but I’m down to get a full claim out of him

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

this is the bulk of my scumread. If you think something like this is an obvious contradiction/lie, this should be an instant vote, not just “a bit suspicious.” I’ll go fact check him on Kohai real quick. Only thing that gives me pause is if he’d shade his teammate DP1.

the idea being that if his analysis of the events is correct, it’s highly scummy from Kohai and scum Rex mostly probably doesn’t shade this.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Are people up for Thoth? What's the case for him?


why not have your own input here? Like he’s not even reading the game. “Are you up for x?” is just a scummy question in general.


I find the Thoth post by Kohai to be suspicious - if he voted for Thoth before editgate and then comes out saying editgate is why he voted Thoth that is a bit suspicious.


this is the bulk of my scumread. If you think something like this is an obvious contradiction/lie, this should be an instant vote, not just “a bit suspicious.” I’ll go fact check him on Kohai real quick. Only thing that gives me pause is if he’d shade his teammate DP1.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Sure but 51 was pretty early in the game. With all the people in this game adding additional details to their claim, I’d look at the mid and back of pack.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Caught up, didn’t really gear all my brain cells toward reading. I’m like 50/50 on Banana. Still null on Whiteflame.


Thoth, Wylted, Kohai are my town picks for now.


Magoroth is an obvious null. Shining null.


Rex, slightly scummy.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

My understanding of 51 is that it’s his entire claim. People don’t usually say stuff like that without being able to back it up.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

If you’re speculating scum’s characters, you’re wasting time. They aren’t gonna straight claim when they have four whole questions and our softs to work with.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I’m here. Haven’t been invested as much this time around.


We have until 10:30 pm est

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Honestly in this game it might just benefit scum more. Doesn’t really pin them into anything, because there should be a few good characters to work with in any category. That means softing is less dangerous for important PRs, like investigatives, but scum will use this soft and now know what category they can claim in the easiest.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP1

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

On Wylted:


Wylted always starts the game with a bit of fluff, I don’t think it was excessive here.


He does try to form a town block early as town, that checks out. I don’t like the unexplained reads, though. Could be a sign of forgery.


As for him basically giving his character away, that’s very townie. I either have to buy that he was gonna straight claim his character as scum, or that he used his questions that quickly. I don’t think a teammate would let him do the latter, and the former is ridiculous considering his character is a lawyer (meaning that if his character were scum it would likely have lawyer as a role). I don’t think he’s that crazy.


I’ll go town on him.