Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

So why would you think the concepts of spotlight/non-spotlight and keeping options open, are closely related enough to be contradictory?

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

It’s straight up not a contradiction. I still don’t understand what you’re seeing.


You’ve been keeping your options open all game. And the part of the post I was talking about with you being forced into spotlight, was in reference to you saying Whiteflame was hiding while you’re not.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

All this flailing is so damn difficult to read. I've seen people do this as scum before, but my gutread is that it's town. Magoroth's frustration just feels so genuine and I have to wonder if he'd ever do this as scum.

lol. You’re so lucky Magoroth has been so scummy.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

You’re hard defending your own lynch. You’re forced into the spotlight.


You actually weren’t too active for the Rex lynch btw. Same as Shining.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

If either you are open to a change of mind, two things.


  1. At the end of the day, Magoroth’s character claim timing dos not align with the incentives of a townie, let alone an invesrigsive, but rather the incentive of scum looking to use their character claim for town cred.
  2. If I were Shining’s teammate, he would’ve distanced me a lot harder, and I would’ve bussed him eventually.
Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Yes he is keeping his options open. But so are you by constantly switching between me and him, and going g on about some Thoth/Wryly stuff.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Thoth dodged the pop quiz today lol


i was gonna quiz him to make sure he read it. Because Savant never read my case against Mikal properly in game shows mafia

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

And to your point, there a few things I don’t like about Whiteflame.


but you look worse

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Wow I thought we were done with the Thoth/Wryly mech tinfoils


very flexible of him

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

”If anyone hammers they will be lynched tomorrow”


right after you put me at L-1. On low time when a hammer is gonna be soon.


we have less than 1 btw people

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Town shouldn’t be uber secretive when a soft claim is expected, or when other townies are pressuring for a fake claim.


but they also shouldn’t be too eager to claim their character or role out of nowhere.


This is not a 180 because these two statements are not mutually exclusive.


The thing is, Rex clearly didn’t want to play anymore, so he decided to be weird, bucking what town should do. And Pie saw that and joined him, saying of Rex wasn’t gonna claim, he wasn’t either.



Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Rex was being weird, and Pie decided to join him. I see where I went wrong with reads.


but the reason I was wrong on those reads, points to you being scum. So my scumread from DP1 stays.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I’m actually not scumreading you for the same reasons as Rex, Pie. They were uber secretive, which I misread.


You, on the other hand, seemed eager to give your character. Which is notable because it’s a given at this point that scum was given a fake character claim.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I’ve seen people do dumb shit as town, it’s why I townread Thoth last DP before he was town confirmed.


mafia can do dumb shit if they don’t understand how others can see right through it as well


and trolling to blend in? You mean like a Ronnie O’Sullivan joke claim?


you’re defeating yourself here

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Doing what you saw others doing, is exactly what scum does to blend in. Town has more critical thought.


You saw Kohai do an SOP claim, because he is hated. That doesn’t mean you claim character.


and you said in 37 of DP1 that you didn’t want claim right away. And in 26 you expressed some concern about scum figuring out your role by your character.


So you are clearly “thinking” about the risks of claiming, while you did it in 24. If town thinks it risky, they aren’t going to do it. Full stop. Again, extra true for investigatives.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Because there’s an ocean of ways you can be scum.


all are reasonable, because at the end of the day, your character claim dos not align with the incentive of a townie who seemed very unsure about risks/usefulness of claiming, and it does not align with the incentive of an investigative.


I will continue to hammer this point until you defeat it.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Well, the way he’s going about it is flail-y.


But there’s a point to his pivot attempts on Whiteflame


yes I’m the easier lynch. But my innocent flip gives my read on him more credibility. So it’s better for him to save me for last and go for Whiteflame

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Mikal faked a lot of anger in game shows mafia


i ain’t buying it


and scum anger is not unheard of

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I was asking him why he was committing seppuku *by not claiming*


so his answer could’ve been oriented around why he didn’t claim

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Like the alternative theory is still possible, even if it’s not my main thought

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

As for the alternative theory: I concluded this DP that even if he has something scummy sounding like a town roleblocker, or bleeder, or even negative utility that he never SOP’d, he wasn’t going to tie up unless he just didn’t want to play anymore. With each of three scenarios I mentioned, he knows he’s town and it’s still better to claim and hope town lets him off the hook.


So if he doesn’t want to play, he could give up with any role.


I don’t believe in sensor but there’s a whole ocean of ways Magoroth is easily scum here

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Hey, can you re-read my whole case on Magorith confirm you understand each and every point?


and Thoth there will be a pop quiz for you on this later

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Because I misread the categories.


I missed the “not due to any action of the Bears” part of “events” so I thought events were in game things, and “decisions” were things like bad trades, bad signings, bad draft picks etc.