Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Are you ignoring [Whiteflame, Kohai, Mag1cman]? There is literally one scum in this group, which includes YOU. Have you forgotten?


this assumes your role is real

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

cop + sensor + tracker is insane town investigative power and your role is way better than you give credit for.


Tracker is already in the game so either a sensor or a cop is fake. If the cop is fake, so is the miller. Unless Vader answered weirdly it guess. But that feels off. Why would he tell you 100% if a Mille could ruin it? Makes no sense. So I think either the cop isn’t real, or the sensor isnt real. And then it’s just you vs Kohai.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

if your results are guaranteed to be 100% accurate, then a miller would not register as scum then, no? That implies a cop and it scumlocks one between you and Kohai.


and no I’m not claiming miller I’m talking about Kohai

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I could be proven wrong quickly, but I’ve been doubting claim. I don’t think investigative claim character instantly. Y’all saw how Pie handled it.


The only thing that trips me up is how he asked Vader about his results. But that dialogue can be faked.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Like I guess it could technically be possible that a Miller would flip guilty to Magoroth’s role and there’s no cop.


but if a cop claims that’s wraps for him

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Wait there’s one scum between Magoroth and Kohai, 100%


Miller implies Cop.


Cop + Tracker + Scum wagon counter role


that’a too many investigatives

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Magoroth


As noted earlier, his progression on claiming was so weird. He was clearly thinking about the risks of character claiming and just, did it anyway. This feels like scum eager to use his fake claim.


There’s also the constant shade throwing. He never really pushed anyone, he just sits back and throws shade. Like he’s afraid to commit.


“Were you perchance looking for what character you could fake claim as scum? :P”


“Did you perchance try to call me out for claiming two characters as a way of “faking scumhuting” as scum? :P”


“I scumread one of your posts: “I always pictured you as Chinese for some reason”.

Tonally it feels off.“


He never establishes any real reads, just always has shade to throw. But he has joined wagons suddenly out of nowhere.


hard scum

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Still working on those reads, but I’m doing so while watching college football

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

One more thing before I type out those reads:


I’m not taking my vote off Thoth until he explains his read on Whiteflame. This is policy based on our agreement to lynch disruptive players from a few months back.


It’s disruptive because mafia is supposed to be a game of deductive reasoning, debates, mind game battles. If it devolves into “red sus guys trust me” then it’s not mafia anymore. And we all know this and are about to waste time pressuring him for his thought process.


So I’m just gonna cut to the chase and give him the ultimatum here: Thoth, I don’t care if you’re town or mafia. If you don’t explain your read, you will get lynched.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

After looking over the DP, I kinda think the sudden votes on Whiteflame are a nothing burger. But I don’t like the lack of explanation from Thoth.


also no claims violate the soft- I’m being lenient here because the distinction between 1 and 2 was missed by a few people, they were worded weirdly. I myself am one, I said event, not paying attention to the whole “no fault of the Bears part” because I pictured “decision made by the bears” as something like a roster decision or coaching hire, making me think events were in game stuff.


i’m “choking against the 0-3 broncos that just lost 70-20 to the dolphins”

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I finally finished my DP1 reread. Magoroth has been fake all game long.


And I can see a reason to sus Whiteflame, but I’m also becoming less trusting of Thoth. Leaning towards Whiteflame being scum between the two.


Shining’s still around but looking townier.


I still think Wryly and Kohai are town. Kohai is townier.


Give me a bit to type out my thoughts, I’m on mobile.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I have no basis upon which to trust your secret sauce. Quit being retarded.


You’re asking me to vote Whiteflame just because.

Mag1cman

VTL Thoth


for case on Whiteflame


I’ll read into Whiteflame in the morning. But for now imma do this. Not outing you thought process is stupid and one of my top pet peeves

Mag1cman

#15 DP1


Maybe not a good idea to use flavour to scum hunt then? Idk. I’m just spitballing.

#18

Oh wait “Mafia either got a fake character OR a fake role” so actually role claiming could be useful, maybe, to catch some Mafia.

#24


Oh apparently I’m Cody Parkey, missed a game kick from 43 yards

#26


Hmm is it possible scum knows what role corresponds to which flavour? Idk if that would count as anti-claim. Maybe it does?

#37

I didn’t slip. I am Cody Parkey. Just didn’t want to claim right away.

#357

I’m not FPSing. My character role or name does not give any clue as to what my role is.


weird progression here

Mag1cman

I didn’t finish rereading DP1 but I still have Magoroth as my top sus. Visiting family

Mag1cman

Yeah I’m still just bad at reading Pie. Always paranoid about him. I don’t know why. I guess I just respect what he can pull off as scum and think he could be doing any master plan at any moment.

Mag1cman

If you think I’m town behaviorally, great. But this is bad logic to clear me. Pie’s dead because his refusal to claim, and vagueness around softing indicated he was a PR.


Also I suck. That was findable for me.