Mag1cman


Checking my own work here


I’m trying to read Pie in good faith (Merry Christmas Pie) but I’ll admit 
Wryly’s case does have a very valid point. I suppose it’s worth noting that he opted not to go for the soft at a time when the soft was suggested, not started, but then he refused and had people pressure him for it. I don’t care for it. Now there is something in my mind that he could be doing with all this as town (again, good faith), but I’m gonna wait and see if he’ll make that defense for himself. Some ok vibes posts, some takes that I like, on Wryly and Rex. “Are you retarded?” to Kohai is very towny. So I guess the game here is to ask why he would refuse to soft for so long.


Eh. Vibes posts don’t amount to much. It isn’t hard to speak from the heart on Kohai as scum either. I think the townie things I pointed out aren’t that great.


@Pie still wondering why you wanted to wait to soft so long


As for Rex, the point about fluff from Pie is a good one. And I see Wryly’s point; it does address mine pretty well, but still, I’ve been given no reason to townread Rex. I do know that he likes to hang back as scum; I’ve seen him do it twice in the last two games I’ve hosted.


So here’s the deal. Excessive fluff isn’t great. But I’ve been burned scumreading fluff before. Recently Kaenite over on MU. And a few other people. And activity isn’t a great metric, although there is some precedent for Rex I think.


And yet it’s very hard for me to get past the fact that he hasn’t really advanced the game at all. Like he’s low activity, fine, but does little when he is active.


Magoroth, I can picture a DCraft noob just outing a character to be helpful. Especially when it could be CC’d. But mafia has some fake claim of some kind. And if it is the character claim like Pie speculates, it’s really not so towny. Now here’s the thing: While he’s new to DCraft, I know he played in a rolemad, closed setup heavy community before becoming an MU player. I kinda feel he should know that claiming his character would help mafia figure out his role. I don’t like this. I guess the one thing I’ll say here is that he did just do some fancy play syndrome thing on MU.


Hard for me to understand what such an FPS plan could be here.


@Magoroth what say you?


Shining’s long-ish post was a W. Bit of borrowed logic on the Wryly scumread, and applied pretty inaccurately imo. That’s my one gripe but it’s very hard for me to hate on him posting something substantial like that.

I guess I have a bit of bias here. I hate the idea of scumreading good activity from Shining.


i forgot to mention that he did start townreading Wryly almost immediately after. But the initial scumread was bad logic. But bad logic is far from the worst thing. I think this is the weakest sus of the four.


Side note: I’m down to say Pie isn’t just bussing/distancing Rex. Should be an unpairing.


Mag1cman

Thinking about the theme split, also wondering if scum Magoroth would straight claim the character.


Like I can see playoff/non-playoff heartbreakers but then the double doing can’t be the fake claim

Mag1cman

Thoth still reads town. Wryly reads town. If you need me to elaborate I will but it seems obvious.


Whiteflame is still only slight town.


Shining’s long-ish post was a W. Bit of borrowed logic on the Wryly scumread, and applied pretty inaccurately imo. That’s my one gripe but it’s very hard for me to hate on him posting something substantial like that.


Mag1cman

I’m trying to read Pie in good faith (Merry Christmas Pie) but I’ll admit

Wryly’s case does have a very valid point. I suppose it’s worth noting that he opted not to go for the soft at a time when the soft was suggested, not started, but then he refused and had people pressure him for it. I don’t care for it. Now there is something in my mind that he could be doing with all this as town (again, good faith), but I’m gonna wait and see if he’ll make that defense for himself. Some ok vibes posts, some takes that I like, on Wryly and Rex. “Are you retarded?” to Kohai is very towny. So I guess the game here is to ask why he would refuse to soft for so long.


As for Rex, the point about fluff from Pie is a good one. And I see Wryly’s point; it does address mine pretty well, but still, I’ve been given no reason to townread Rex. I do know that he likes to hang back as scum; I’ve seen him do it twice in the last two games I’ve hosted.


Magoroth, I can picture a DCraft noob just outing a character to be helpful. Especially when it could be CC’d. But mafia has some fake claim of some kind. And if it is the character claim like Pie speculates, it’s really not so towny. Now here’s the thing: While he’s new to DCraft, I know he played in a rolemad, closed setup heavy community before becoming an MU player. I kinda feel he should know that claiming his character would help mafia figure out his role. I don’t like this. I guess the one thing I’ll say here is that he did just do some fancy play syndrome thing on MU.

Mag1cman

Oh I forgot about Whiteflame for a sec.


i townread taking the time to research some things, although scum has to research as well. The difference is that he took the time to post thoughts, and then follow up with his logic.


slight town

Mag1cman

I kinda townread 58-59


59 is a townie who doesn’t want to get mislynched over something stupid


58- the clearing of any 3P concerns for a very weird reason when the simple answer is right there (9 players, has never been anything but a 7v2 here), is from the mind of someone worried about third parties. Which makes sense cause in the game we just played on MU, there was a serial killer.