Mag1cman

hold on guys


i think the most compelling point here is the behavior about his claim


the request to be rolecopped was the big one


but i still don't like a lot of things

Mag1cman
 I can only see him pulling off such a massive YOLO if they desperately need the 1x Permanent Roleblock or the 1x Rolecop to win the game.

This is actually a pretty good reason, since the rolecop goes to a random townie if I read it correctly. That can be used to town confirm someone and shrink PoE further. Thing is, I'm not sold Wryly was the target.

Mag1cman
I have a 1x Bulletproof because my character was saved from a cruel fate by a magic girl's wish.


Wryly, 230


So you’re claiming 1x Bulletproof?

pie, 232


Fuck it, we don’t have time. I am CCing Wryly. I am the 1x Bulletproof. My justification is that I was the only one to survive a car crash and fated to be an orphan

Pie, 238, about ten minutes after "asking for clarification"


It explicit. He doesn't need to ask for clarification. He asked as a placeholder, then he went away and spent time looking for a reason for Mami to be bulletproof.

Mag1cman

The case against Pie:


  1. The situation: As it stands, the choice for this DP was between Rex and Kohai. The case against Vader had been refuted, and any pressure against Whiteflame went nowhere. Wryly and I were firmly no-gos. The POE was Rex, Vader, and Kohai, with two scum. The problem is that town has three lynches and can win the game by lynching all three. This means that mafia needs to steal a DP. A successful sac CC works in scum's favor, since a DP spent lynching Wryly means town has to choose between Kohai and Rex in the final 3.
  2. The sudden push on Vader. At the start of the game, it was announced that scum has a target. Almost immediately, Pie was on Vader. Last DP, he concluded the OG scum was between Whiteflame and Rex, but this DP, he decided it was between Whiteflame and Vader, disregarding his original points on Vader.
  3. The unlikelihood of an organic CC. The recruited scum can just straight claim their character. And the original scum has fake claim help of some kind. Scum needs to have help that isn't a fake role, and needs to have wasted, and needs to have happened to choose a role that is in this game. It's unlikely.
  4. The disappearance. After Wryly claimed bulletproof, Pie asked "did you just claim bulletproof?" and then disappeared for a sec, and reappeared shortly to CC. Why not CC on the spot? I think this was Pie looking for a justification for his character being bulletproof, to CC Wryly with. Pie's defense was that he was just seeking clarification. The problem? Wryly claimed bulletproof explicitly. He has no need to seek any clarification.
  5. The x-shot discrepancy. Earlier, Pie had sussed Vader over having a 1x. But here, he says he has a 1x bulletproof. His defense was a pedantic difference between passive and active, which I am not buying. If he had 1x of any kind, it is bonkers that he wouldn't at least consider that Vader really is 2x. There's absolutely no reason to sus Vader over being 2x, unless the reasoning is motivated (see point 2).
Mag1cman

Rumi and Zoey were town because of a protag/antag theme split.


I think there are better reasons; let me assemble a list of points that really stick out.

Mag1cman

Mafia has some level of claim help this game too. Not sure of the exact level, combine that with a game where the recruit can straight claim their pre-transformation role, an organic CC is pretty unlikely

Mag1cman
Oh no no. That’s part of it. The main part is that I was the only one to survive a car crash

And Kyoko was the only survivor of her father's madness. Both were orphaned as the only survivors. This is a pedantic nitpick. I think it's more likely that Mami's real justification has to do with her life after the tragedy, before she became a magical girl.


A) Lol that’s a POE from your POV, not everyone else’s

You tried to get a lynch on Vader. It failed. You tried to put pressure on Whiteflame. That went nowhere. Wryly and I have been effectively off the table.


It's common sense that's the PoE.


B) I lynch either of those 2 unless I’m bussing them cause one of them is guaranteed town vs killing myself as scum lol


You and your teammate are still under fire after getting that mislynch. You mislynch Kohai, you and Rex are the only ones left under fire. You mislynch Rex, you and Kohai are the only ones left under fire.


Lmaoo, I wanted to confirm that’s what she was claiming and then when she said she was leaving I CCed. Again. Why CC when I could’ve gotten a free town lynch in Kohai or REF.

She claimed 1x nulletproof, verbatim. You don't need to spend time confirming because she said it explicitly.



Mag1cman
 just looked back at my rolecard it gives three additional names: I'm a classmate of Madoka and Sayaka and I develope a romance with Syosuke. This leads me to think they're probably originally town.

Question: Does anyone else's role PM list other characters?

Mag1cman and Mag2cman do not have others. I'm pretty sure the reason for your PM is that way is because your character is a side character, who is only relevant because of her relationships with other characters.

Mag1cman
Tomato-Tomahto. I’ve been softclaiming BP since early today lol.

Meaningless if you were going for this play to begin with, given the Rex-Kohai-Pie PoE.


The fact that you wouldn't even question the similarity is alarming.


Oh, and for all your softing, you never CC'd Wryly right away. You questioned it, and didn't CC until a few posts later. You were likely putting down a placeholder while you were searching for a justification to CC with.

Mag1cman

If Pie's claim is true, we'd have two slots (Mami- Bulletproof, Kyoko- Inspector) whose justification relies on being an orphan. Not completely out of the question, but unlikely.

Mag1cman
It does?? I thought x-shot implies, like, x-shot.

No, it doesn't. This is a quick on the spot excuse.


Active or passive doesn't matter, 1x is still 1x.

Mag1cman
Which is why I'm tinfoiling both of you being town and town just having two bps. I'm working on a long post so please let's slow down for a few moments and think things through

???

Mag1cman
Then why do I CC here vs taking the Kohai lynch lmfao
Lol what? If Im scum, then why am I hounding Kohai since DP2. Okay let’s say I’m bussing. Then I go ahead and lynch REF lmao.

Honestly, both of these are refuted by the fact that POE has basically shrunk to you, Rex and Kohai. Scum's gotta do something here.

Mag1cman
Here's the problem: We already had a doctor flip. BP + Doctor by itself doesn't make sense. As scum I would never fake claim bp after a dr flip.

There is a massive tinfoil possible here, but it seems likely we do have a bulletproof around.

Mag1cman
Lol what? If Im scum, then why am I hounding Kohai since DP2. Okay let’s say I’m bussing. Then I go ahead and lynch REF lmao.

Ok, then REF is your teammate.

Mag1cman

I don't buy that for one second.


VTL Pie


I've said previously that we win the game with lynches on Rex, Kohai, and Pie. With the Vader lynch (likely mafia's target for the day) going away, and with no traction on anyone else, scum has to make something happen. If one DP is stolen by mislynching Wryly, then we have to make a call between Kohai and Rex in the F3, at which point his teammate (whichever of the two) has a fighting chance.