Ok
Mag1cman · a year ago
Ok
Mag1cman · a year ago
No Mikal sent it
Mag1cman · a year ago
Could you repeat the justification for your character being ascetic?
Mag1cman · a year ago
I'm unclear, does this change the game? I'm familiar with Kriemhild Gretchen being Madoka's witch form (it comes up in at least one of Homura's time loops), but is this just flavor or does this signify some extra power for scum?
I think it’s flavor, but I don’t know or care.
Mag1cman · a year ago
*that this was
Mag1cman · a year ago
Mag1cman (Madoka, Doctor) was slain by a magical girl's weapon.
im intrigued by the fact that was specified
Mag1cman · a year ago
Why this order?
nvm I get it
Mag1cman · a year ago
I think I’ll give character after you and Rex do.
Mag1cman · a year ago
^^^
Mag1cman · a year ago
REF needs to claim first. Then Supa needs to reveal what he did. Then we can make a determination.
Why this order?
Mag1cman · a year ago
The same reason he chose Pie NP1: To investigate him. An unclaimed visit on Pie was intended to townlock him. I guess Mikal wasn’t fully confident in Pie.
Mag1cman · a year ago
In what world does mafia kill Mikal over Castin?
in the world where Castin has a weak role. And Mikal has an investigative.
If mafia wanted to kill Castin, they’d be wasting their time.
and again, the only reason I would deny a flip in this case, is if it town confirms someone who I sussed.
Mag1cman · a year ago
VTL Magic
I’m not buying his claim on protecting Mikal
Bro is just trying to get anything going 💀
Well I was, in fact, a doctor. And I obviously would protect someone. Critique the choice all you want; I don’t care.
Mag1cman · a year ago
I’m really confused by your claim. Mikal was radio silent almost the entire game. Why would he be the likely NK target?
*Second most likely. I had figured if the mafia had any brain cells at all, I was gonna be the one who died. I was essentially banking on them making a mistake, and going for someone other than me.
Now the whole reason we VTNL’d was to delay lynching to get more time to make a decision. If I’m preventing a flip, it should be one that town confirms someone on my sus list.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Anyway I’m thinking Kohai + Rex/Pie, being bussed by either.
Mag1cman · a year ago
I figured I was going to be the NK, but before going out I tried to protect Mikal.
I was pretty much playing to townlock someone in my sus list if for whatever reason I wasn’t the target.
Ended up choosing Mikal cause I figured if he’s town he’s the second most likely target for mafia.
And now that I’ve subbed in, I think I made the right choice. In my defense, my read on Mikal was the lowest confidence, essentially based on Pie being scum, and even then there’s no guarantee. Just a tinfoil.
Anyway Mikal opted to inspect Pie again. No one visited Pie last night.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Mag2cman lol
Mag1cman · a year ago
Rex slight scum, Whiteflame slight town.
dont have time to elaborate.
yes ik i have to be wrong on two people bc i have too many listed as slight scum.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Mikal
The way in which he revealed his role is dubious to me. Like he was gonna say he confirmed Pie but changed his mind, almost as if he’s considering whether he wants to tie himself to Pie or not.
Slight scum.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Pie
Ok so #46 of DP1. Don’t agree about the first paragraph, Pie complaining about the hidden roles is interesting to me. Like it get his complaint but I know Pie well enough to say he doesn’t really complain unless it negatively impacted him. I can see him being frustrated with me being townlocked in DP1 because of hidden ability that a different townie had.
His vote on Casey isn’t too special but I does kickstart the trend of just voting with the crowd.
The VTNL was bad strategy looking back, but I made the mistake too and it made sense at the time. So eh. Can’t say that’s scummy.
DP2:
Started townreading Kohai, then turned against him while everyone else did, although he does say he was convinced. Maybe, but it continues the trend of just voting along with everyone else.
I can buy that if he was offered the contract, he would reject because playing scum is not his favorite. Although it’s no guarantee cause the position could be perceived as advantageous for scum at the time. I think Pie loves winning more than he hates being scum.
anyway that assumes he started as town.
his idea to find the original scum is good, although fakeable as town. His logic is sensible.
He asked Mikal for results, which stands out to me as he could’ve been teeing Mikal up.
and Pie’s defenses do make sense but he’s just so off.
Skight scum.
Mag1cman · a year ago
I worded for 404 like an idiot. I just don’t see how Kohai gets a reveal on his hidden ability in a way that is towny, I don’t see how he has an argument around that.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Ugh. Maybe Kohai can really be that clueless and town then. Thing is, I don’t see a way around him getting a reveal on his hidden ability for something that isn’t a recruitment bonus. And the antics must seems way too specific, and I still don’t like how he jumps on people over small things.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Vader
Nothing to write home about DP1; I guess #92 of that DP was good. TBH I don’t even have to look at DP1 to know he started as town.
There’s no way scum Vader claims redirector, unless he knows town can have it this game, which he would only know if he started this game as a town redirector. Also makes sense with the setup since the mechanic central to this game is recruitment.
DP2 he’s clueless about the offer he got from Kyubey, even after everyone else. He did this by over analyzing / over thinking the contract. He does a similar thing with his read on Kohai, in his moment of poor reading comprehension. It’s plausible ignorance. He kinda just tunnels on Kohai.
I do like how he waited for Mikal to reveal action plus result before he did.
His night action justification is weird.
but wait, there’s more. He doesn’t immediately clarify whether he declined or accepted the contract, until a few posts after his first on me in this DP. You’d think scum would have a decision ready on what they were going to say on this from the start, no? Which tells me he *really* did not understand the nature of the contact (if that wasn’t obvious enough already), which tells me he probably didn’t get recruited. The hesitation to say whether he accepted or not, which likely comes from not knowing just how important it is to say, is the key that his whole misunderstanding of the contact (thinking it’s just a hidden ability thing), is real.
It’s so stupid because some things look fake, but in one area, the *specific* way in which he’s clueless in ridiculously towny, even if he’s on par with Kohai in it.
Love ya Vader, don’t want to disrespect you here, but I kinda feel like I have to.
Slight town, I guess.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Eh. Still solid actually.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Kohai back to regular scum. Not solid not slight.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Wryly
Immune to recruitment, likely because her character is male and males can’t become magical girls. (YNBAMG?) I buy the claim.
Also has towny behavior in both DPs. I pointed out something I like last DP and I stand by it. She’s misread a few things this DP and I think her ignorance this DP is not close to Kohai’s- meaning it’s within the range of believability.
Hard town.
Mag1cman · a year ago
oh, and in a other post he said now everyone should character claim. You know what? Hard scum. I’m gonna trust Thoth isn’t that weird. And I’m not gonna disrespect Kohai that much.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Kohai
So DP1 he's telling us not to character claim- not one person. So here's the deal. What the point in TMIing for towncred? There are other ways to try and gain towncred here, and he's going against mafia incentives by warning people about the specifics. We can certify that it did have to do with character claims, since his hidden ability outed only my character, which pairs well with the anticlaim he alleged. And because even Thoth said it was a hidden ability DP1 when my character was outed, we know Kohai didn't know about the specifics of it. So he couldn't have warned us.
I thought he was TMIing DP1 but just by analyzing incentives, I am confident in saying he was town DP1.
DP2 is where it gets more complex. So right off the bat, he says he accepted the offer, and tried to retract the offer when it was too late, but it didn't matter cause he failed (this was clear in his first post; anyone who said he lied has poor reading comprehension). His claim was a point of suspicion for me, but given he was town DP1, it is real.
Looks good right?
But then he says the anticlaim only triggers if two or more people claimed characters, and it is no longer a problem. I have a hard time believing this. It sounds too specific to be true. I think the mafia would want to hide if they got anticlaim on me, while lulling others into a false sense of security. Furthermore, the idea of a hidden role being revealed is absurd. And ofc it would've been revealed NP1, the same night that the someone took a contract and gained access to a hidden ability. For players who have a hidden ability on their card, I wouldn't be shocked if this was revealed to them while their new ability was also revealed. It would explain how Kohai suddenly knows of his original hidden ability.
Throughout the game, Kohai has been boldly asserting scumreads on variouis people. That's fine cause this game is hard to read, but the problem is his logic rarely makes sense, and he seems eager to jump at anyone.
Lastly, there’s the cluelessness. early in this DP, he says there’s a recruiter or cult, something that had long been speculated, ignoring clear signs from last day and night that there’s no cult. Then he says we may have multiple recruiters????? (Huh?) Then he thinks the setup is bastard for recruiting multiple people, despite the fact that said recruiter can only get one teammate at the end of it. There’s no way he’s actually this clueless, right? At first I thought it was towny, but after so many instances I feel it’s be disrespectful to say he’s not feigning ignorance here.
And yet, all I need to do to towncase him is to just disrespect him, and also assume Thoth only needed the anticlaim for DP1 only for whatever reason. And tbh, it’s possible.
Scum. Not slight, but not solid either.
Mag1cman · a year ago
Night actions info helps, plus at odds tomorrow we’ll be forced to lynch. This will be the last NL of the game
Mag1cman · a year ago
unvote plz