Mag1cman
Casey is my biggest scum read right now, but I've been wrong on her pretty catastrophically before and I don't want to lynch her on her first DP back from her mafia vacay because it's kind of a dick move. So, VTNL

This feels slightly fake from Rex but everything he has said has felt towny from the vibes standpoint


prolly willing to let this slide

Mag1cman

I feel Pie has been opportunistic at points this game, plus I feel he'd be more irritated with my paranoia of him as town. He's usually more gracious about it as scum bc he doesn't want me to go after him even harder


And Pie is definitely laying back more than he should I feel

Mag1cman

sure it's most likely correct, but why not think on any other scenario?


also I still think you have a hidden ability that outed my character


could be negative utility, could be scummy, not sure either way... but please explain that tmrw too

Mag1cman
Town win when all threats to town have been eliminated. Mafia win at scum parity, i.e., when there are at least as many scum alive as non-scum. If there are neutrals, they have their own win conditions.


Perhaps a mod confession that there's no cult

Mag1cman

lots of possibilities


2v6 but the mafiosos cant talk with each other


1v5v1, single mafioso + third party


Cult OR mafia recruiter that starts alone


heck maybe just 2v6 but town is loaded with power

Mag1cman

ok, and what of 1v5v1 (TP)? Or a pair of lone mafiosos? Or a recruitment mechanic?


Why not give any consideration to those and just assert that there's another scum? This is why I say a lot of what you post feels like TMI.


I expect big things from you tomorrow



Mag1cman

Kohai in #11

If anyone is forced to claim them kt should be a soft role claim. Absolutely no character claims.

This has been repeated various times by Kohai. When asked later, he says that he knows characters specifically trigger something. Still feels a lot like TMI. I don't see a real way a townie just knows what does and doesn't trigger anticlaim. I want to suspend judgment because "no way scum has the balls to claim such a special and unheard of role, right?" But I remember Mikal doing the same thing a couple games ago.


And yet, there might be a way this works with my setup speculation. Doesn't even mean Kohai is town tho


#17

I can guarantee that there’s at least one scam on my wagon.

For the record I think this is a towny reaction. I will grant this


a few other things Kohai said feel towny.


flip flopping on Kohai. Once again, water is too muddy to convict just yet. Wouldn't lynch here either


Mag1cman

I'm just gonna out my setup speculation now


I waited bc I didn't want townies to act anti town, hoping to be recruited


I think Kyubey = recruiter of some kind. Maybe cult, maybe a lone mafioso. If cult I would imagine no night kills, if mafioso, I imagine the recruit is 1x.


8 players is weird so i felt just having two scum isn't what we're dealing with here

Mag1cman

#15

Hello, everyone! It's good to be back. I know absolutely nothing about this theme aside from what WF has already shared, so I appreciate that. I agree with not character claiming due to possible Anticlaim.

VTL Kohai

I felt like this was blend-in behavior, with the vote on Kohai just a way of following the crowd, possibly with the added sinister motive of getting pressure on Kohai for basically nothing. Not really a reason to reaction test someone, when I'm already doing it.



#29-30

I wouldn't jump to this conclusion; seems like boilerplate OP stuff to me. I doubt there's a 3P in an eight player game. That sort of thing is hard to balance.
I'd be cautious about leaning too hard on this sort of analysis. It's not all too uncommon for protagonists to be scum - hell, I made the main two characters of Deltarune the scum team in my game. Granted, I'd agree that he's more likely town than scum, but I'd still only put him in lean town at best based on his character.
This much I agree with, I don't think Thoth would put in a mechanic that could punish the town just because of random chance.


Just general thoughts and speculation. I don't fully agree with it, but it seems harmless, with no agenda. I briefly felt the first post could have an agenda behind it- leading town away from something that could be true. But eh. That's just a circular argument that assumes 3P is real Casey knows and is TMIing... all possible, but also just possible that this is her honest thoughts.


And while scum has no reason to help things, one would think scum Casey would have at least some defense of herself here, rather than just letting herself get lynched.


So there's a case against her but it's not very strong. I wouldn't lynch her here.

Mag1cman

eh. kinda flip flopping on Casey. just not sure, not enough info to make a decision, plus i think night actions will clarify things


VTNL

Mag1cman

idc...


for this game i would say you started with 72, leave it that way.


but if everyone else wants to shorten the DPs I won't complain

Mag1cman

Honestly, upon reading Casey's posts idk why I ever scumread her.


The only thing we can even lynch her for is inactivity


at this point I'm more sus of the people on the wagon who know it's basically a free mislynch

Mag1cman

it honestly sucks


just when mafia was getting back to its peak


boom


DART dies in the middle of a game. Lots of old users don't make the trip to DCraft


players slowly quit, activity dies down, and now everything is boring

Mag1cman

yeah i can see why lunatic quit


maybe we should do rapid games, like on MU. 24 hour dps and such


maybe that would be fun


or more live games