Mag1cman

for clarification, the idea is that Rex tries to roleblock Thoth in the night phase.

GAME (MOSTLY) SOLVED.

First things first, my claim.

Erak Starfollower, Universal Backup. Justification is that I became the new Oberjarl after the previous one died, completing my foe-to-ally arc.

"Everything and nothing." I don't start the game with any power, which is the nothing. But the everything is that I could gain the power of another townie. With my version, I simply inherited the role of the first townie to die. That was Mikal.

NP1, I hid under Whiteflame, but didn't die, which is how I knew there was some fuckery last DP. After Thoth claimed, I had to ask Pie a ton of questions, but as it turns out, Thoth's results can be unfucked. If, for whatever reason, a Hider self-targets, he wouldn't be told his action failed, but he wouldn't be immune to night actions, making a self-target visible.

I didn't claim last DP for a few reasons. First, claiming puts me in a position where scum can get an extra NK if they call my hide target. Second, there's an off chance I attract an NK or roleblock/similar. Not high, but worth. Three, the specific scenario from last DP: If Casey somehow flips town, it's near guaranteed there's one scum between Lunatic and Wryly. Hiding behind Lunatic is safe no matter who is scum between the two. This means I keep myself safe and test Lunatic: If he reveals results while having been visited by me, he's scum. It would take a mistake on his part, but it was worth a shot. Unfortunately, Rex ruined that test when he claimed his actions.

However, Wryly's claim of her night action is a blessing. Unless she was messed with last nigh, she should have received word that her night action failed. Combine that with the fact that Thoth would by far, be a better target for a doctor and you have a really bad look. The NP1 waive also isn't great, and behaviorally, I'm now scumreading her due to the whole "Lunatic is faking everything" then a sudden switch to Casey from last DP. Never had a reason to townread her DP1 either. High scum odds.

The last question here is if Pie would leave a doctor out, and he has before: CoD Mafia had no doctor.

As for the teammate:

If Thoth is telling the truth, then the only role that could've possibly redirected me to myself is a Mirror Maker placed on Whiteflame, at which point Rex should've had his roleblock bounced back at himself, which is something I completely missed last DP (which is why I just realized I didn't need to wait on Thoth). This would easily make him the teammate, and the claim was simply something he pulled out of his ass. I've realized that although Rex is more passive of a player, it doesn't mean he can't try something when he's almost certainly going to be the lynch.

However, a custom role, or a simple lie from Thoth are not out of the question, although unlikely in my opinion. A mafia tracker/watcher is an interesting concept I've been thinking about here too. Still, I think Thoth looks better behaviorally. The only thing odd to me is how Thoth won't vote Wryly now, but was oh so willing to believe Lunatic last phase, even voting Wryly. At least I've had behaviors I've liked from Thoth. I've never really had a behavior I liked from Rex.

But here's the beauty of the situation: We don't need to worry about Rex vs.Thoth. We can solve that in the night phase.

If Rex dies, we know it's Thoth. If not, then it's Rex. Simple as. A refusal to comply is a lynch.

But for now, I've decided to vote Wryly.

VTL Wryly

im not very fast at this man

I'm typing it rn. Got distracted with some irl things

Wait I did t even need to wait for Thoth. I think I have a game solve gimme a sec

*works

That would be 1pm for me, but yeah, that pwkrs

I’ll give you Erak Starfollower for now

I want to get Thoth’s results first.

little bit of a minmax here

Bruh

*too easy

i I can’t type for shit

It is way to easy to double post on accident here

He changed his username to Kohai. That’s why.

oh he died anyway I’m retarded

oh he died anyway I’m retarded

oh he died anyway I’m retarded

Why can’t I tag RT? What the heck?

Post 11

Post 11 is meant for you

Don’t reveal your night actions until after Thoth reveals results

Actually I’m ok with Wryly revealing her visit

You as well

I would have preferred you wait before revealing your visit

Any results from last night?

Any results from last night?

Not by my own intention, I should add

I think so, yeah

The circumstance is specific, but the it’s worth holding my cards to my chest here.

If I do things correctly, I can win the game for us on the spot DP3.

I would like to claim DP3 if at all possible. I have a very good reason for this.

Yall I’ve been busy basically since I woke up today and this is the first time I’m able to post anything.

I do agree with Casey lynch cause I think she looks the scummiest out of three by far.

i never had a reason to townread her last day phase and i have even less right now. When it comes to the claims, hers is the only one that’s easy to fake with little risk. As for behavior, she was null for me yesterday and the back and forth with Lunatic isn’t a good look.

VTL Casey