SatanLucy
Yes, I agree, but I dont understand your objection to induction I guess. I mean, let's say only one card has been drawn from the deck and it was black. Your syllogism is 100% true, but the level of certainty regarding pulling another black card is functionally ~50%. Is it the pretense of certainty that you like?


I prefer certainty, and I do think deductive reasoning reaches it better. I have no problem relying on induction when certainty or probability cannot be established by deductive logic. My issue with inductive logic is that establishing probability based on it is extremely difficult in some cases. Because its different from probability established by deductive logic. there are some probabilities in inductive logic which are almost certain, such as "sun will rise tomorrow". Its the constant repetition of something which establishes higher probability of further repetition. However, when we are dealing with probabilities which are not high, inductive reasoning gives a lot of false conclusions. If probability is 60%, then we are faced with problem that 40% of our conclusions are wrong, and from those conclusions, more incorrect conclusions are derived. However, we dont even know what probability exactly is when we are dealing with situation where observed world is smaller than non-observed world. It is true that in theory, induction produces 100% certainty when everything is observed, and higher certainty when most things are observed. However, in any situation where non-observed world is like 2x of observed world, issue rises with inductive logic. I think science doesnt even observe 50% of Earth, let alone universe. Its reason why science such as sociology and psychology is terribly unreliable, and whats worse is that other science which are considered hard science also face issue that we just dont know if our current knowledge even applies outside the tiny portion of the universe we observe.

SatanLucy
Deduction doesn't operate on probabilities and chance


Deduction operates on deriving conclusion. What that conclusion is, is another thing.


You can quite perfectly make deductive argument that something has higher chance of happening.


P1. If there are more black cards in deck than white cards, then it is more likely to draw black card.

P2. There are more black cards in deck than white cards

C. It is more likely to draw black card


This is deductive reasoning. As long as premises are true, conclusion certainly follows.

SatanLucy
Probability doesn't reduce uncertainty, it measures it.


I mean, if you have probability, you are less uncertain. I am more certain about outcome which has 90% chance of happening than outcome which I have no idea what's the chance of happening.



We don't always have clean numbers to make precise calculations, and we are forced to use intuition to guess at the uncertainty


I never quite understood the intuition, mainly because so many people get the wrong intuition about something. From my point of view, if you don't have probability nor deduction, I don't know what do you draw conclusion from. Maybe some people have a stronger sense of a priori premise, so they don't need probability nor deduction to get that premise. But such people are usually rare. I get that when you don't have probability nor deduction, the only thing you can rely on to begin with is the intuition. My issue tho is, that intuition is a mystery to me. I don't really get how someone can know something based on intuition, because it's not really a form of logic. It's more like sixth sense.

SatanLucy
Induction works in scenarios where uncertainty is built in


It works sometimes, sure. My complaining is more about time when it doesnt work, which happens a lot. My issue is that probability as a way to reduce uncertainty only works if we assume unobserved will follow same probability as observed. It's a huge leap of faith in all cases where amount of observed data is insufficient or just tiny.


I mean, how exactly do you use deductive reasoning to determine what the next card will be in a shuffled deck?


Usually by knowing which cards aren't in the deck and which groups of cards are more present, so the ones which are have higher probability of being drawn.


Its sort of like if 50% of cards were white and 50% black. If you drew 6 cards and all were white, the remaining cards contain more black cards than white cards, so higher chance of drawing black card.


Those who play poker usually divide cards into good cards and bad cards, and if you have a really good hand, there is actually a higher chance opponent doesn't have even average hand. But same works in opposite. If you have below average hand, chances are higher that opponent has above average hand.


I haven't played poker in a long time, so I can't really remember all the tricks. Math changes based on number of players, because more players means higher chance someone has a better hand than you do.

SatanLucy

I buy the idea that AI is indeed doom for some people.


What I also realized is that a lot of people who oppose AI do so out of personal reasons.


AI didn't affect everyone positively.


Take for example, digital arts. Ever since AI appeared, these guys lost 30% of their income because why would someone pay someone to make digital art, when AI will do it for free.


Entire degrees in digital art went to waste, and people who today buy digital art are only doing so out of charity.


Today, if you want to be a digital artist, you cant be average. AI outperforms average. You need to be like way better than AI to merely survive.


Same applies to some other arts too. In past, people used to pay an artist to draw them. Today, you can just give photo to AI and have AI do it in few seconds, for free.


Artists are probably most negatively affected by AI out of all groups.


There are some other groups which were also negatively affected. Private instructors, such as instructors in English language, are also slowly being replaced. Advisors likewise.


Then there are also some people who were victim of AI, especially due to fact that AI can make porn out of anyone.



Then there is the predicted deepfake chaos. AI is being used to fabricate things, like AI being used to make fake photo of dead Benjamin Netanyahu. There are also social media accounts ran entirely by AI. Literally fake people and personalities on social media.



However, the main argument about AI taking jobs is that in past, machines used to replace unskilled labor, so unskilled workers got fired.

What's special about AI, is, that apparently, AI replaces both skilled and unskilled labor.


So there is I guess some fear that AI will replace everyone, because in future, there won't be a job AI can do.


However, I think people who make these arguments about jobs don't realize this isn't a bad thing. Having an AI worker to do job for me, actually sounds pretty good.



Creation of AI was really like opening a Pandora's box. Once opened, it cannot be closed. Everyone knows how to make AI. There is no way to effectively regulate or stop it.


So I am afraid that doomsayers better get used to AI, because it's not going to go away. Actually, from this point on, the only question will be who has a better supercomputer to host a better AI.


The idea that boycotting AI is gonna stop it, is silly at best.


AI is pretty much here to stay, and this is true even if all countries banned it.

SatanLucy
Inductive reasoning doesn't yield absolute conclusions, and that is a strength of science not a flaw.


It is actually a flaw, because a lot of people get wrong conclusions due to induction.


"I was winning in gambling so far, so I will keep winning."


"I was safe when speeding in traffic so far, so I will keep being safe."


"I am smoking a lot and my lung health is great, so it will keep being great."


the problem with induction is in fact that its conclusion is not certain, so basing your thinking on that conclusion makes your thinking uncertain too. In simple terms, there is a decently high chance the conclusion is wrong. Even if that chance is merely 40%, it does make 40% of your conclusions wrong. And this chance of being wrong skyrockets the bigger the unobserved world is, and longer the unobserved time is. Its why I can make prediction that I will be alive tomorrow and have a reasonably high chance of being right, but same applied to next 40 years becomes less likely to be true, and we know this by observation of average population. However, when we dont know something based on observation even approximately, the chances of induction being wrong skyrocket. It becomes more like tossing a coin than doing probability predictions.

SatanLucy
Making reasonable assumptions based on intuition. Like if you travel across the country and look online and everyone you see is cheering for a specific candidate and he won the last 10 elections in a row, he's more likely to win the election than the guy everyone says they hate.



that is probability based induction. I agree some induction has higher probability than other, mainly the one which repeats more and where place is same and time is not distant. Same claim about that man across 40 years future prediction would be less likely, as well as that man trying his chances in another country.


It doesnt really solve problem of science in cases where 99% of existence is not observed, because observed repetition compared to non-observed world is lower.

SatanLucy
I think you are conflating induction with just bad argumentation/fallacies


No, the basic rule of induction is:


"A is observed to be true everywhere, so it is true everywhere (even in non-observed areas."


or time based:


"A is observed to be true in all times, so it is true in all times (even in non-observed times)."


While large scale induction does increase probability with more observations being made, probability which you talk about is strong specific time/place based induction.


Its like me saying "Sun will rise tomorrow". I have seen Sun rise in this place each day for thousands of days. there is a chance Sun might not rise tomorrow, there is a chance that one day Sun wont rise (and that day will happen too, science says) but I expect it will rise tomorrow because constant repetition increases probability of something repeating. It is a probabilistic based reasoning.


However, you miss the point which I was making, which wasnt about specific time/place induction.


I was talking about all time/all place induction.


Making claims about all of the unobserved world is not same as making claims about specific area/time.


Maybe guy who only saw black cats does live in an area where all cats are black. However, if he were to make induction that all cats are black, that would be clearly false, even if he never saw a non-black cat.


Science faces these same issues when making claims about all of unobserved world based on observed world. Generally, the greater the unobserved world is, higher the mistake rate.


But the principle itself is flawed regardless.


Saying "A is true in observed world = A is true in non-observed world" is a leap of faith.


Forecasters sometimes get things right. Sometimes they dont. Some who use effective deductive reasoning, using principles which always repeat and which are expected to repeat in specific area, are one thing. Its sort of like betting that Sun will rise tomorrow, when you already know it did rise each previous day. Making absolute claims about whole of universe based on tiny portion of universe? Entirely different area.


Maybe large scale induction increases probability of being correct in a specific area and specific time, but even that faces many issues, as we see in psychology and sociology which are soft induction based science which often get things wrong. Any time you see an article saying "5 habits of smart people, according to psychology", its really just probability based. It doesnt mean someone who doesnt have those habits is not smart, or that someone who has them is.

SatanLucy

Nuclear energy

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

China leads the world in Solar energy use.


Not per capita.


It doesnt matter if you have most solar panels in the world, when your population is higher than in most of the world, hence more pollution despite all the solar energy.

SatanLucy

A lot of people confuse induction for observation, but the two arent same thing. Definitions, induction, observation, deduction are all separate forms of logic.


Observation would be:


"All cats I saw so far are black."


Induction would be:


"All cats I saw so far are black, so all cats are black"


Definition would be:


"I defined cats as black, so all cats must be black by definition"


Deduction would be:


"All cats I saw so far were black, so one cat I also saw before must be black."



Out of all of these, induction is weakest. Definition is at least true by definition. However, induction cannot even be proved by induction itself, or anything else.

SatanLucy
Your post is specifically blaming the issue on inductive logic even though we both agree that the issue is with the argument and not the logic used.


Inductive logic is defined as an argument, the specific argument which I said is flawed. If issue is with the argument, its also issue with inductive logic defined by it.



"since we can convert inductive logic to deductive logic without changing the argument, we can do the same there."


Converting inductive logic to deductive logic does nothing to solve problem. Deductive logic which uses inductive logic (specific to general) will always face same issue.



I think you clearly agree with this, since your posts are based on examples and not collections of syllogisms. Heck, your initial post is almost entirely inductive logic.


No, my posts are deductive logic, not inductive. It may seem like "inductive logic" because I used examples, but examples dont make something inductive logic.


If I tried to prove the claim "all cats are black" as false, I would merely need one example of a cat which is not black. this is not "specific to general" inductive logic. this is "specific negating general" deductive logic.


Sort of like:


P1. All A are B.

P2. Some A are not B


One of these two must be false, by law of identity.


If I really needed to put my argument in pure deduction form without observations, it is that:


"A true in specific conditions = A true in all conditions" is an unproved premise which doesnt result from law of identity.



Its like saying "Some A are B = All A are B".


Conclusion doesnt follow, even if we dont use all the obvious examples where this specific logic is blatantly proved false. Law of identity simply cannot prove it, where in opposite case:


"All A are B = Some A are B"


Conclusion follows by law of identity.


to be clear, "=" in this case is forward deductive chain. It doesnt go backwards. A = B isnt same as B = A.

SatanLucy
My point is the issue isn't unique to inductive reasoning


Of course, but it still remains an issue.



Also you will always have unproved premises in order to avoid circular reasoning or an infinite chain.


this is where I disagree. If starting premise is based on laws of logic, or on point that violations of laws of logic are a fallacy, starting premise is always true to anyone who accepts that logic exists and is a foundation of everything.


the only way to disagree with starting premise which is logical law,


such as:

A = A,

A = / = Not A (Law of non-contradiction, which foundation for contradiction is derived from),

A true under all conditions = A true under specific condition,

A true in all places = A true in specific place,

A true at all times = A true in specific time


is to abandon logic itself. I am comfortable if my debating opponent says he abandons logic.


As I said, the problem with induction is that it takes a different path from established logical law on deduction.


Established logical law of deduction is:


"A true in all conditions = A true in specific conditions"


or


"A true in each part of B = A true in specific part of B"


Socrates is human. (A is specific part of B)

All humans are mortal. (all parts of B are mortal)

Socrates is mortal. (specific part of B is mortal)


this is general to specific.


Induction is the other way around:


"A true under specific conditions = A true in all conditions"

SatanLucy
If A does not conform to A then it is no longer A.


Yes, that is the most common critique of induction. Its that it doesnt follow law of identity (A = A).


While sometimes there is a strong induction, such as A which repeats everywhere and each time in same way, such induction only belongs to those hard science categories, and even there its not always consistent.


Induction is basically assuming that if A repeats here, it will repeat elsewhere too.


Sort of like, if truck moves 5 meters a second, it will travel 50 meters in 10 seconds. this is assumed true everywhere on Earth, and for a long time it was considered universally true until concept of wrapping spacetime, warp drive (from Star trek) and alcubierre drive came to mind, where something which normally travels 5 meters per second can at same time travel faster than that if spacetime is wrapped. Its sort of like making path shorter instead of increasing movement speed.

SatanLucy
Isn't this deductive reasoning?

P1: If A was true everywhere we observed, A is true everywhere
P2: A was true everywhere we observed.
C: A is true everywhere

It's bad reasoning, but deductive reasoning is only as good as it's premises.



Deductive reasoning is only one half of the equation. You can have perfectly valid deductive reasoning which is at same time completely absurd. Let me demonstrate:


P1. If flowers exist, then I am God

P2. Flowers exist

C. I am God


Now, this is perfectly valid deductive reasoning. Conclusion naturally flows from premises. Yet premise 1 is obviously unproved, making this deductive argument not proved true.


However, moving from specific to general is not deduction. Its how induction is defined. You may call it deductive argument, but its still definition of induction.

SatanLucy

today, there are 7 year olds with 2 smartphones, tablet and computer, bicycle and electric scooter, and they want more.


I am sure 70 years ago, people were happy to just being able to own a radio or tv, and kids were happy if they got even one doll (which looked more like a bad piece of surreal art than a doll kids today would want).


No one wants a radio today, and kids want bunch of toys of high quality.


I guess when new things come, old technology and old lifestyle become a lot less interesting.

SatanLucy
"I have a Nokia...It's at least 10 years old, and does exactly what I need it to do...Phone or text"


Yeah, but this depends on what you want for phone to do. I usually want a lot because I am greedy and I dont believe in moderation.

SatanLucy

Biggest problem with inductive reasoning is a huge leap of faith from specific to absolute.


It works in a way of "ok, so far everywhere we observed, A was true, so A is true everywhere, even where we didn't observe"


The leap of faith happens because despite the fact that induction holds true in areas which were observed, assuming it holds true in non-observed areas is simply impossible to conclude.


So using induction to prove an absolute claim is logically impossible no matter what.


The best example of failed induction is relativity of time. If you merely observed Earth, you could conclude a clock works just about same everywhere, with some small insignificant differences of time mismatch. If you observed parts of universe with different gravity and properties than Earth, you would come to an entirely opposite conclusion. Clock would show not just small mismatch, but an hour on Earth and an hour elsewhere would not be close to same. Hence, relativity of time which showed that time measuring instruments are actually not consistent in all areas in universe.


This same applies to gravity. While Earth's gravity remains true on Earth, it does not remain true anywhere else. Induction pretty much fails any time when observed area and non-observed area could mismatch.


We didn't observe even 1% of things in this universe alone, so basing absolute claims on 1% of area which we observed is a serious leap of faith.


Problem with induction is always going to be that as long as induction isn't based on observing everything there is, making a claim about everything there is will always be leap of faith.


Induction actually has two problems which science could never effectively solve:

1. Observing one area to make absolute claim about all areas

2. Observing one time to make absolute claim about all time


2 is actually pretty funny. You can never prove that what you observed to be true today will still be true tomorrow. Science proves things in present moment, but future moment represents a gap which induction cannot cover.

SatanLucy

Nuclear energy

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Nuclear energy is sure fun. I never really understood people who want more coal. I think humans have already polluted this planet enough.


It's why I wish I was born 3000 years ago. At least I would breathe in clean air.

SatanLucy
And as far as I can tell, it does exactly the same as the old one.


That's not my case. This laptop I ordered has 2x more RAM, better graphic card, and also dual channel RAM. It means video games run a lot better on it.

SatanLucy

the biggest problem of modern causation theory is in this claim:


"Everything needs a cause"


the obvious problem with this is, if each thing needs a cause, and each cause needs another cause, the causation chain is never realized to begin with.


Sort of like: A needs B. B needs C. C needs D... and so on to infinity. the condition for A to exist is the existence of infinite causation chain, but that infinite chain cannot itself be realized because it also needs a cause, creating unsolvable problem where each dependent thing depends on another dependent thing. the chain never enables its own existence no matter what. If cause enables existence, and cause also needs its existence enabled, there is nothing in this chain which ever enables anything to exist, because no thing in chain even has its existence enabled to begin with.


Some tried solving this with circular causation, such as "A causes B, B causes A".


However, this too is absurd for same reason. All causes in this chain are themselves dependent just like in infinite causation chain. If each thing only exists if another exists, there is nothing which determines if this chain will even exist or not.


So people reached for what is left, and thats uncaused cause.


However, uncaused cause has its own problems. First there is the infinite past regress problem, where something which is uncaused and eternal also has eternal (infinite) past. Problem with eternal (infinite) past is that it makes it impossible to reach present moment. Another problem with uncaused cause is impossibility of explaining its existence. there is simply no possible natural way to explain how something exists without a reason.


the only thing which doesnt need reason to exist is "nothingness", but how did that gave birth to "something"?


It seems that all natural explanations for existence are pretty much exhausted. there is simply no way to explain how or why "existence" as a whole even happened. No answer fits.


the only answer which is left is supernatural, because simply, reality cannot explain its own existence without falling into circular logic. Anything which is part of reality, being used to explain reality, ends up being circular explanation. this means the only non-circular explanation can be something above reality.


SatanLucy
But men today are declaring they are women when there is no biological justification for the claim. As a result, women are being injured, both physically and emotionally. What justifies those injuries so a man, who could not compete and win with other men, can usurp roles and compete, and win, pretending to be a woman?


there is a difference between biological woman and trans woman. Obviously, I dont think trans women entering some of woman's sports does any good even to trans community. Most trans women dont even compete in sports, so its pretty much a point which can be conceded.