SatanLucy

Trump could shoot someone in the head and he still wouldn't lose any voters.


You need to accept that power is everything.


If rapist is powerful enough, you will bow to him and lick his feet, thanking him for granting you permission to lick his feet.


If God was rapist, people would be worshipping him and kissing his feet still cuz they don't wanna get spanked in Hell.


It's all about power. The one who has power gets worshiped. The weak gets spanked.


Life is all about who can beat up who. I learned that in school. If someone can beat you up, you better do as he says.


In life, you are either strong or obedient. The disobedient weak gets spanked always. Disobedient strong doesn't.


So if you wanna be disobedient like Trump, you gotta be strong.


There is no mercy in life for the weak.


If you are weak, you depend on someone to protect you and that someone will eventually screw you.


Be strong or be screwed!!!

SatanLucy
I mean they have to decide on cases somehow. Picking an appropriate definition kind of matters.


Picking a definition like that pretty much determines final decision in the first place. Its a boring and pointless way to try and win a debate here, to be honest. Like what, did Fauxlaw think people here would just accept his definition? Was that his great victory plan when he made this topic?


"Bio-male thinks he's a female? Well... no."


What was this supposed to be? If he wants to convince anyone in this, he probably shouldnt base his entire argument on definition no opponent on topic would even agree to.


If all I have to do to win is to reject a definition, then honestly, its a pretty easy win.

SatanLucy
Biology is irrelevant to physical sports?


It's irrelevant to definitions. Definitions are always arbitrary, irrelevant of what you use to make a definition.


Saying that male is someone with certain characteristics is still arbitrary definition, even if those characteristics exist objectively, because the assigning of definition still depends on mind to assign it.


The job of the court is to interpret the law, not to convince trans people or anyone else.


Sure, but then it's irrelevant to what I should accept on these issues.

SatanLucy
The method does matter insofar as it affects the definition you come up with. And if you want to discuss [x], then you need definitions based on [x], whether that's biology or something else.


It's still arbitrary. None of the things you say make definition non-arbitrary. Even choosing biology to make definition is arbitrary.



They're the judicial branch. It's their job to rule on cases. Also, this ruling was about state laws on sports, not about people calling themselves women, so it has an effect whether or not trans people accept it. I think it would make more sense for you to be criticizing the legislative branch than the judicial branch on this.


Buddy, you could make 1000 courts do 1000 decisions on trans issues, and none of those will ever be accepted by trans people. You aren't convincing them by making some silly court cases. Even if you ban them from sports or ban them entirely, you still ain't convincing them at all. Fauxlaw wanted to use court decision as some kind of "gotcha" in a debate about definitions, but he doesn't get it, court decisions are irrelevant in debate. It's not an appeal to authority as much as it is appeal to something entirely irrelevant.

SatanLucy
It's just a clump of cells hindering a woman's choice.


Contrary to popular belief, woman's body doesnt belong to a woman. Her body is one of 2 biological roles necessary for continuation of species.


If all women chose to never have kids, and thus end humanity, would we just let them do it? Nope lol

SatanLucy
Lol


I dont support trump, but my response to this topic is lol indeed.


Leftists arent actually competent to fight trump. He outplayed them like 20 times so far. He banned abortions while Biden was still in office.


this is mainly because leftists are for the most part just assembly of angry idiots. they dont understand how power play works, which is why they push women who have no power skills to be their play candidates.


trump got in power because stupid democrats were stupid and trump just took advantage of their stupidity. thats just basic politics. All your mistakes will be fully exploited and used against you.

SatanLucy
Yeah but in this context it's clearly about people using biology to make a definition.


Still arbitrary. I could use "biology" to define woman as an ant or a cat. It doesnt matter what you use to make a definition. It is still you who assigns definition to a word, not any biology.



Is he a crybaby if he's happy with the SC result? Seems more like he and the SC are the ones rejecting others' opinions and calling them crybabies.


Even if he isnt a crybaby, people can still have opinion that he is. And honestly, crying about some tiny part of population calling themselves women and making irrelevant Supreme Cort decisions which wont even be accepted by trans people anyway is like punching the air and claiming you are winning.

SatanLucy
FYI, every human is female at conception.


the problem here is Fauxlaw inability to understand that just as "is ought" gap applies to ought claims, "is" to "definition" gap applies to definitions in a much more brutal way. Observing something as it is, is one thing. But using what is observed to define some specific word that way is entirely arbitrary. It is literally impossible to prove that some word is defined in some specific way. Observation doesnt define any word on its own. Its people's minds who choose to assign specific observation or description as definition of a specific word.


And as much as I dont care about trans people, on the issue of definitions, they are entirely right. Its actually a very stupid argument to even make by trying to definition your way to victory, because people dont have obligation to accept a definition, and trans people are the last ones to accept Fauxlaw's definition.

SatanLucy
Actually, Cognitive scientists generally concur that stupid people's brains are biologically hardwired to develop spirituality and supernatural beliefs


I have seen a lot of atheists and theists. Neither are any smart.

SatanLucy
It's a specific type of evil though. Like people in wheelchairs are less likely to beat people to death, don't think that means being paralyzed makes you a better person necessarily


We are not talking about "better person" as some intentions. At least I am not. I don't count intentions. Just results.

SatanLucy
In this case, the Supreme Court (people) decided on a definition using biology


Same thing. I can use ants to make definitions. It doesn't mean ants made a definition.


Also, fauxlaw is a person proposing a definition. So kinda weird for you to reject his opinion outright after saying opinions are necessary to make definitions


He has right to opinion, and people have right to reject his opinion and call him a crybaby. Same applies to everyone.

SatanLucy
As if it were better under SloJo. By the way, higher employment, stock market, 401K,. Gold and silver and most other commodity investment, etc, now than then


No one but you handles your personal economy



Does Trump run the economy or is economy at personal level? Make up your mind.

SatanLucy
Once you start aggregating people based on gender, biological circumstances are now the primary factor you're studying


The only thing I am studying is difference in evil in men and women. Saying men can't do evil isn't really saying men do evil.

SatanLucy

I changed my mind on abortion issue, partly due to what I learned from your debate with Bones.


First is the uncertainty principle, which goes in a way of:

Abortion is okay and this is known

Abortion is not okay and this is known

Abortion is okay and this is not known

Abortion is not okay and this is not known


Tho uncertainty principle goes both ways here, same can be made for "not abortion".


But it does show that the only way to truly know that abortion is okay is with certainty, and certainty is only achieved with deductive logic.


Later I realized there actually is deductive logic which can be used to ban abortion, mainly the duty to care for others, and no human survives without care.

SatanLucy
I agree they could accidentally be right, but if they are right randomly they're not learning because they won't be more consistently right over time, they will continue being right at the rate of chance.


People can want to learn and can want to be more consistently right. However, it still entirely depends on want. It doesn't depend on what truth is. If something was true, I would only believe it if I wanted to. If I didn't want to believe it, I wouldn't. And examples I provided are clear cases of people not evaluating evidence at all. The claim "people believe in truth and reasonably evaluate evidence" is an absolute claim, which gets disproved pretty easily given that at least 80% of the world believes in incorrect religion, many more believe politicians lies, and many more don't even care enough to do research in the first place, and most can't even apply laws of logic to evaluate evidence in the first place.

SatanLucy
Men can't get abortions though. So if not getting an abortion is a test of morality, men aren't being tested in the first place.


Yes, but this is irrelevant. Maybe some murderer was in circumstances I wasn't in, but still it doesn't make him same as me. Everyone lives under different circumstances, so circumstances don't matter much and aren't excuse. Also, if abortion is bad and men can't have abortion, it just means men can't do what is bad, which is also good and makes them better than women.

SatanLucy
If you believe what you want, then it doesn't correlate to what's true


It can. I can want something to be true, and it can be true at same time. There is no "what people want to be true must be false" mentioned anywhere. This is just about making a clear distinction that people don't believe in truth in any sense of "I believe this is true because it's proved true". It is just "I believe this is true because I want it to be true, and if it is true as well and has evidence supporting it, great".