SatanLucy

"Give me one example of existence of something which in its existence doesnt follow law of identity."


I notice that you blatantly failed to respond to this.



I made the point that non-existence is the default position


And I disproved it in many ways, some which you failed to respond to at all, such as that your position on the issue is entirely irrelevant to the existence of God.



The phrase in this context clearly meant failure to abide by the rules of logic in terms of reasoning.


the rule of logic is law of identity. So go ahead, give me example of reasoning which in its existence doesnt follow law of identity.

SatanLucy
Your argument was about people "wanting something to be true." Even if people wanted to believe the world sucks, they don't want it to be true that the world sucks


This is only if you define pessimism as "believing things you don't want to happen happening", and not some other alternative definition, and it still means people want to believe that world sucks, and it still can mean people wanting world to be the way some other part of them doesn't want.


Just listing a bunch of false beliefs doesn't really support your claim, especially since you're cherry picking


My argument isn't based on deductive reasoning, so I am forced to go by examples. And these examples do show clear cases of wishful thinking happening not just in past, but also today.


If I were to go by deductive reasoning, I would say people cannot believe in things they don't want to believe in, as that is a logical contradiction. So believing requires some form of wanting to believe in, and this is true even in case of evidence. Person realistically only believes evidence if person wants to.



If people never considered evidence, no one would learn anything and we'd reach an information heat death. In fact, you'd have no way of knowing your claims are based on evidence, so it's a bit self defeating


I didn't say people never consider evidence. I said people consider evidence only when they want to. And there are a bunch of people pretty much denying evidence to such high degree that this is simply true in those cases obviously, and it happens on mass scale from time to time too.

SatanLucy
Most people want the economy to be doing well and that the world is doing great, yet they have no problem believing that the economy is terrible and everything sucks


Nah, people actually prefer believing in pessimism. The economy is pretty much doing better than ever, and world is probably one million times better than it was 100 years ago by some standards. But when you want to believe that world sucks and that economy sucks, one must merely use a different standard to evaluate it. Anything can be made good or bad depending on standard, and people will always use a standard which better suits their wants. This is also true when it comes to determining truth. It is a well known fact in justice system that people actually evaluate evidence based on what they already assume is true. If they think something is not true, they are ready to reject even a very strong evidence. If they believe something is true, they are ready to accept even tiniest hint of evidence to make it true.


What I am talking about isn't some unknown theory. It's a well researched theory in psychology that people are more willing to accept evidence for things they already agree with, and more willing to reject the opposite.


Call it confirmation bias, or wishful thinking.


It works in a sort of way: I believe in A, so I will search any kind of evidence or excuse to support A, and I won't bother to even consider non-A evidence.


It's why people who have Muslim parents are most often Muslims themselves. Same for pretty much any religion. When people get some idea in their head which they learn to like, they are not gonna abandon it even if evidence for other side is stronger.


Of course, it's not true for all people, but people are emotional creatures, not logical.


There are emotions attached to ideas, and those emotions override evidence.


Did Germans in 1944 really believe they could still win? Yes. Was there one bit of evidence suggesting they could? No.


Did Iraq have weapons of mass destruction and was about to use them against USA? No. Did Americans believe it? Yes.


Did Americans believe Trump will stop all wars in 24 hours? Yes. Was it even logically possible? No.


Do some people believe Earth is 6000 years old? Yes. Is there a single drop of evidence supporting that claim? No.


Do some people believe that their religion is the correct one? Yes, virtually all. Is there a single logical evidence supporting that claim on any religion? No.


There are countless things people believe in on a daily basis which literally have no evidence supporting it, or such weak evidence accepted only because person wants it to be true.


A choice to trust a politician or anyone is essentially wishful thinking.


Choice to pray is wishful thinking.


Choice to accept something as true just because it's popular is likewise wishful thinking.


Wishful thinking is basically not about what is true, but about what person wants to be true.


Reality is, wants come before evidence.


If I want something to be true, I will keep searching for evidence and excuses, I am not gonna stop and say it's not true. If I can't find evidence, I will just dismiss opposing evidence and call it a tie which still means I keep my belief.

SatanLucy
The question I asked couldn’t have been simpler; ‘is statement X a logical contradiction?’. There is absolutely nothing about that question that implies you argued anything nor sets you up for any kind of gotcha. But that’s what you have to resort to when you know everything you’re arguing is complete nonsense.


It is still irrelevant question, given that my argument was about beliefs, not about any written statements. So why should I answer a question which is not only irrelevant, but also stupid because statement existence likewise cannot violate law of identity.



You just argued that you can simultaneously hold a belief that God exists and that he does not exist at the same time. So following up by asking you if you believe that very set of positions are logically contradictory is of course relevant


written statement = / = belief



First of all, we’re not even talking about the law of identity, that’s a totally different thing


No, law of non-contradiction is built from law of identity. You cannot have a contradiction without violating law of identity.


Second, you’re the one who claimed that you can believe God exists and does not exist


Yes.



not you’re claiming a person holding positions that violate logic is not possible? WTF?


How is it possible to violate logic? Please explain. Give me one example of existence of something which in its existence doesnt follow law of identity.



You are obviously trolling, nobody is this stupid.


Given that you are failing to understand even basic things in logic, you probably should do something more productive, like playing with lego. Its more on your level of intelligence. this isnt for you.

SatanLucy
A question is not a strawman genius.


It is when it questions a claim I didnt even make as some pathetic attempt to make a strawman argument point which at same time is irrelevant to anything I said.



All you have to do is answer it to clarify what you’re actually talking about


Why would I answer irrelevant question? Why dont you answer if you have herpes? Its about as relevant as your question is.



So you seem to tacitly acknowledge that holding two contradictory positions simultaneously is a logical contradiction


No. At this point, I must assume that you have severe hallucinations caused by herpes, because I literally said that holding opposite positions is not a logical contradiction.



, but argue that the holding of the positions itself is not a logical contradiction because that can in fact happen in the real world.


Yes, what is true in reality cannot at same time be a violation of law of identity.




No one is arguing that people cannot contradict themselves, that’s a stupid direction to try and take the conversation down.


Actually, it is impossible to violate law of identity, so literally any belief which violates it couldnt exist in the first place.



We’re talking about whether the position of accepting a proposition is logically compatible with not taking a position on that same proposition.


I dont think you even know what you are talking about, because to be honest, I have never seen a person struggling so bad to comprehend that people can have opposite beliefs.

SatanLucy

About 25% of women have an abortion.


Because abortion is child murder, it means that over 25% of women are child murderers.


So 1 in 4 women is a murderer.


I don't think there are any exceptions to abortion ban.


Simply, whatever happened to a woman doesn't justify killing innocent unborn any more it would justify killing innocent born.


If woman was raped, and she has an abortion, then she is child murderer, so she is worse than rapist and then the rapist should get financial support because woman killed his child.


SatanLucy

What I see constantly is that people don't actually care about truth.


If they want something to be true, they will take tiniest argument in favor of it over countless arguments opposing it.


Because people don't want truth. They want what they want to be true.


This is why people always get persuaded by even weakest arguments for something which they want to be true, while at same time dismissing much stronger arguments against it.


Because people don't want truth if truth disagrees with them. They are ready to go to great lengths to deny all arguments against their beliefs, while at same time unconditionally accepting even weakest arguments for their position.

SatanLucy
Let’s be very clear. Evaluate the following: ”God both exists and not exists (at the same time in the same sense)”
Is this a logical contradiction? Yes or No?


I don't know why you are now doing a strawman, because we were talking about belief in existence there, not existence of God.


Logical contradiction is something which can't exist in reality logically.


However, believing in both that God exists and doesn't exist is not a logical contradiction, and can exist in reality.


Mainly because it doesn't violate law of identity because opposite beliefs exist in their separate spaces and aren't actually a negation of each other's existence even at same time.


Of course, this level of logic is not imaginable to you, because you don't get it. Logically contradictive beliefs cannot even exist because what violates law of identity cannot exist in reality logically. So all beliefs which do exist are in fact following law of identity, not violating it. If they existed and violated law of identity, they would be supernatural. So contradictive beliefs either dont exist or are supernatural. No 3rd option exists here.

SatanLucy

One of biggest issues in biology as a science is in fact failing to define anything. I asked countless "biologists" on the definition of "species" in evolution debate, and nothing. they literally cant provide a definition of species. they cant even define specific species in any sense, mainly due to individual difference issues which general definition fails to account for.


Also, if having a vagina makes someone female, one merely needs to remove vagina to stop being female. So yeah, claiming that having a vagina makes someone female is actually pro trans claim.

SatanLucy


SergeantLynch wrote:
Perhaps that which dictates social order and more importantly progress rather than anarchy and chaos, is reliant up on a natural selection of Hitler's, Sub-Hitler's and various tiers of obeyant underlings.


I dont blame Hitler for being Hitler. tho I do find it amazing how general population keeps falling for same scam over and over for thousands of years. You would think that 12 years of education will make them at least a tiny bit smarter, but no. they are literally still on level of cavemen when it comes to power play.


And its not really any benefit for them. the government will literally fuck them in every way it can, because they dont get it. Its in government's full interest to have a fully obedient population to prevent rebellion, and all governments will do anything to make that happen, as their power depends on it.


In this sense, there is not much difference between USA and North Korea. North Korea brainwashes its population through education and propaganda, and US does exactly same just on much greater deeper level.


Its why average American cant figure out why he goes to elections every time to vote, and gets screwed every time, and instead of making a better choice next time, he just gets screwed again each next time.


Government doesnt follow people's interests. It uses people's interests to control people. thats what average American doesnt understand. When trump says he is against abortion, its not because he actually cares about what his voter base wants. Its because he wants their vote so he can do corruption in other areas.


It sort of works like "Here is some candy while I violate your butt".


thats what politics is. Politicians give some candy to population so that they can fuck them later.


Its candy politics.

SatanLucy

I am sure you are not aware of this, but people can actually say things they dont agree with. Amazing, right? Well, you learned something new, thanks to free education I provide here.

SatanLucy
This is a direct violation of the third law of logic. You might want to google it.


No, its not. For example, my one txt file on computer can contain both claims "God exists" and "God doesnt exist". Its not a logical contradiction. Is your brain less advanced than txt file on my laptop? If so, then its a problem with your brain. Your brain doesnt have capacity like my txt file does.


Not knowing whether you accept a proposition is by definition, not accepting a proposition.


this is likewise a false claim. Its like saying "I dont know if Double_R has herpes, so Double_R has herpes.".


Not knowing if something is true or not true, cannot at the same time be knowing that its not true.


"I dont know if this is not true, so its not true" - is a logical contradiction.



Now, it seems that even tho you believe that logic exists, you are still very bad at it. I dont believe that logic exists, but it seems that everyone who believes that logic exists at same time greatly suck at that same logic, which is very embarrassing to be honest.

SatanLucy

You would think that after Hitler, people would learn to doubt the government more, but sadly, it didnt happen and now we have trump, Putin, Kim and Xi who are also Hitler.

SatanLucy
8 people out of 9 in charge are completely qualified and normal.


that joke is funny because people actually believe its true.


Its like those people who believe that government is benevolent and well meaning, and that law is ultimate moral authority.


People believe a lot of silly things, and there is a significant portion of population who literally believe whatever government tells them.


Its like some terrible parody in a cartoon, except its reality.

SatanLucy
I can understand the frustration but overall it protect children from engaging with pedophiles.


It doesnt protect anyone from anything. It just makes roblox lose players.


Probably same idea was in Australia about social media ban for those under 16, and guess what? Most people under 16 in Australia still use social media.


And whats funny is that people only support bans which dont affect them. People over 16 in Australia generally support the ban. People under 16 oppose it.


So the very ones which are supposed to be most benefited by the ban are the ones opposing it the most.


I assume same is gonna happen to UK lifetime smoking ban.


People are generally hypocrites and would support banning anything for others but banning nothing for themselves.

SatanLucy
Actually, that’s incorrect. You can only be for or against a proposition (you accept it or you do not accept it)


thank you for correcting yourself, but sadly, you are still incorrect, so the "self-correct" was actually just one mistake replaced by another. Its like saying "Oh I made a mistake, 2 plus 2 isnt 5, its actually 7". So yeah, self-correcting only works if its actually correcting and not just one dumb thing replaced by another.


So, the first problem in your claim is a false dichotomy. One can actually both accept and not accept a proposition, and not just at different times. Also at same time, it is possible to both accept and not accept a proposition. Or you can just say that you dont know if you should accept it or not accept it.


the second problem in your logic is a contradiction, because if we go by your false dichotomy, one can not accept a proposition that God doesnt exist. So to claim your false logic is unique to claim "God exists" is just silly logic.


the third problem is that what you are saying is irrelevant yapping. You not accepting the claim that "God doesnt exist" is entirely irrelevant to if God exists or doesnt. So its literally just yapping.




Simply not accepting a proposition is no different than asserting it’s false.


this is false claim too. Asserting something is false means saying its false. Not accepting a proposition doesnt require saying its false, or saying anything in fact.



Either way, you do not think or behave as if the proposition were accepted as true.


this is likewise logical fallacy of "similarity = same". Its like saying "humans and ducks both drink water, so humans are ducks".



Now, do you have more logical fallacies and yapping which you need to vent here? I am a professional psychologist. I am happy to tell people their mistakes.

SatanLucy
When it comes to what we believe about a proposition, you can hold one of three options; for, against or neutral.


this is incorrect. You can also not think about a proposition at all. No need to hold anything. You can also be both for and against. Or you can just be neither, or you can be slightly more for than against, or you can just say that you dont know which option you should hold.



When it comes to your approach and your actions, there’s only two; for or against. Natural doesn’t exist


this seems like unproved claim. Also, you said "natural" instead of "neutral". So yeah, that was embarrassing.



Think of any scenario in real life where the word default comes in; like the settings on your phone. Notice how when you go to reset, default doesn’t mean “duh I don’t know”… instead it means we’re going to choose certain settings for you and you can adjust them if you want


Irrelevant yapping about phone settings. I am sure you are not aware that the word "default" doesnt have same meaning in phone settings as it does in question on if God exists.



In the course of everyday life we have to choose how to live. Whether to pray before we go to sleep, whether to go to church on Sundays, whether to burden ourselves with knowing what the Bible says. There’s no neutrality there.


Your actions are irrelevant to question of if God exists or not. So yeah, more irrelevant yapping.




You either do or you don’t


False dichotomy. Person can both do and not do something. I can both drink water and not drink water at different times.


But other than being a terribly false dichotomy, it is also a very irrelevant yapping. Yap Yap Yap. What you do or dont do is pretty much irrelevant on the question of if Gods exists or dont. Even if you acted your whole life as if God didnt exist, it wouldnt prove that God doesnt exist.

SatanLucy

Chatgpt is just general AI. It is not specialized in anything other than giving answers to some wide range of questions.


It sucks in areas such as gaming, chess, and even some areas of logic. its image generation is generally decent but nowhere near top tier.