SatanLucy

Are positions on topics chosen randomly? Like, am I forced to be pro or con? I know topics are chosen randomly, and a lot of topics I have no much interest in, but if I have to also defend a side I disagree with on topic I didn't choose, then that's a big disadvantage for me because my motivation would drop severely.

SatanLucy
I find it creepy that you think of infant circumcision sexually


A lot of abusive pedophiles probably become circumcisers because it let's them abuse infants legally. And the ones who are into torture can also legally watch torture child porn in form of circumcision videos.


So the real question is, why are you defending the rights of abusive pedophiles?


That's just creepy.

SatanLucy
And if such videos exist


Oh, there is bunch of them on google. Apparently, its enough to just google "infant circumcision video" to get countless results.


But the problem with these videos is that they are not merely child porn. they are also sexual torture gore videos, where babies scream in pain while their dick is displayed, touched and cut painfully, with blood involved.


So if posting sexual torture gore child nudity online is okay when doctor does it, that raises a lot of questions about what people find to be okay.

SatanLucy
No, they dont. If that were true, punishment of any kind would be against the law and/or immoral.


False conclusion.



Argument from repetition? You're not addressing the counter-argument...


Your "counter argument" is that it was on subjective foundation, which it isnt.



That is really not very clear.


If you cant follow simple line of logic, then you probably dont need to bother with anything here.



Morality itself is subjective.


False.


SatanLucy
Secondly, autonomy isn't an absolute for every person for every situation. For instance, a child doesn't that hasnt achieved the age of reason/consent doesnt have full autonomy. Parents have the ability to override a child preferences to protect them. Barring that means a lot of youth will die ir suffer unnecessarily


Children have same autonomy as adults.


This is because removing autonomy for subjective reasons is a self-defeating principle.


Person A wants to remove autonomy from others for subjective reasons = autonomy can be removed for subjective reasons = People can remove autonomy from person A for subjective reasons = person A loses ability to remove autonomy from others for subjective reasons

SatanLucy

Violating autonomy is good = violating autonomy of those who violate autonomy is good = violating autonomy by removing ability to violate autonomy is good = ability to violate autonomy disappears, removal of ability to violate autonomy becomes justified


You are describing a recursive moral structure where a principle turns back onto itself.


The chain can be expressed more clearly like this:


1. Premise: “Violating autonomy is good.”



2. Then violating the autonomy of autonomy-violators is also good.



3. Preventing them from violating autonomy may require restricting or removing their capacity to do so.



4. Therefore the principle justifies suppressing agents who practice it.




So the principle contains a tendency toward self-negation: a universal permission to violate autonomy authorizes others to stop you from violating autonomy.


This resembles a kind of self-undermining universalization problem:


If everyone may violate autonomy,


then everyone may also suppress autonomy-violators,


which can lead to systems that eliminate the very freedom to violate autonomy.



The result is not a strict formal contradiction like “A and not-A” simultaneously, but rather a self-consuming norm: the principle authorizes conditions that can abolish its own exercise.


Your reasoning is structurally close to ideas in:


Thomas Hobbes — unrestricted liberty leading to conflict and the creation of constraints,


Immanuel Kant — universalization and contradiction in willing,


and modern “paradox of tolerance” discussions associated with Karl Popper.



The underlying pattern is:


> A universally permitted destructive principle permits its own suppression.




That does not automatically prove autonomy is absolutely inviolable in every imaginable case, but it does show that a principle of arbitrary autonomy-violation struggles to remain stable when universalized.

SatanLucy
It doesn't matter how much you whine about it being unfair, pedophilia is illegal


Sure, I merely demand some consistency from my enemies. If they want to ban pedophilia, that's fine, but then they should also ban circumcision videos, or someone will say they are being terribly inconsistent.

SatanLucy
Hmmm, in my opinion child circumcision is physical and sexual abuse of a minor...Therefore falls under the umbrella of paedophilia.


Apparently, touching a baby's dick is a crime, but touching it while cutting it by circumcision isn't.


One must really go a long way to think that touching baby's dick is very horrible and harmful, but completely stops being harmful when it's touching and circumcision.

SatanLucy

Yeah, if someone is caught with photos of naked baby boys, he would be arrested for child porn.


Yet if same person was caught with having circumcision videos, he would not be arrested for child porn despite those videos also showing naked baby boys.


Make it make sense!

SatanLucy

Age restriction for smoking means person under certain age isnt allowed to smoke cigarettes.


When it comes to "should/shouldn't" questions, debaters are expected to not merely suggest a standard, but also justify it with deductive logic.


Burden of proof is shared.



So umm yeah, as description says, debaters must use deductive reasoning to justify their standard. thus, no subjective morality is allowed to begin with.


So reasoning must be in form of:


A = B


B = C


C = A


With of course starting premise also being logically deduced.


Due to is-ought gap, using observations to derive "should" is not possible, because observations merely tell what is, not what should be.


However, using logical axiom as starting premise works as foundation to derive morality from, and the only way to deny logical axiom is to deny logic itself.


thus, my reasoning will be in form of:


A or not A


Not A, when accepted as true, results in self-defeat and establishment of A.


thus, only A remains as true.



I. Body autonomy objective morality


When it comes to what "should" be done, some moral principles survive A or not A much better.


Some examples of moral principles are:


Body autonomy


Property rights


Person's wants


Harm


Freedom



We can logically deduce body autonomy by saying:


Everyone has body autonomy = No one can take away body autonomy of another


this principle remains self-consistent, but opposite principle does not:


Any person can take away body autonomy from others for subjective reasons = Everyone can take body autonomy from everyone for any subjective reason, including their ability to take away autonomy from others = Ability to take away autonomy itself disappears as principle.


Suppose someone says:


"I have right to take away body autonomy of others for reasons I choose".


We can respond to that by saying:


"We have right to take away your ability to take away body autonomy of others for reasons we choose".


thus any attempt to take away autonomy results in symmetry justification to prevent that same attempt.


Any person has right to take away choices from others = Any person has right to take away choice to take away choices from others.


thus, any attempt to take away body autonomy for subjective reasons, results in also subjective reasons defeating same principle.



Because topic is about smoking and age restrictions, body autonomy is important argument.


Suppose some person wants to smoke and has money to buy cigarettes. to impose age restrictions which prevent that person, then his wants, choices, autonomy and property choices would all be violated.


And if violating body autonomy is good for subjective reasons, it results in justification to violate all autonomy, including ability to violate autonomy, hence self defeat of "Not A".


Likewise, violating property choices is self-defeating:


Any person can take away property choices from another for arbitrary reason = All choices regarding property can be taken away, including choice to take away choice.


Any person can deny goals of another = Any person can deny goals of all others, including goals to deny goals.


Freedom likewise works same. If freedom can be taken away for subjective reasons, all freedom can be taken away for subjective reasons, including freedom to take away freedom.



II. Future wants argument


One of biggest counters to body autonomy of children is that violating it maybe upholds their future autonomy.


However, such counter doesnt work, because justification for it rests on same subjective reason as any other violation of autonomy.


We can logically deduce that "no one can violate body autonomy of others".


We cannot logically deduce "We can violate autonomy of others if it possibly upholds their future autonomy".


Because when:


Autonomy can be violated = Who gets to decide when it gets violated and for what reason?


And that question is a core self-defeat of all principles which attempt to violate body autonomy.


Any person can decide when autonomy gets violated = Any person can decide to violate autonomy of anyone always


And violating autonomy to preserve autonomy is a self defeating principle, because autonomy remains non-violated only if never violated. If it is violated, it is no longer autonomy but a removed autonomy.


It is not possible logically to follow a principle "No one gets to violate autonomy of others" while violating autonomy of others, for whatever reason the violation occurs.


And as autonomy principle is deduced from deductive logic, "future autonomy > current autonomy" argument is not only unproved and not logically deduced, but is self-defeating because it attempts to use subjective justification to violate autonomy, while same can be used to defeat it.


Principle is justified by subjective reason = Principle can be defeated by subjective reason



III. Harm argument


Another big counter to child's autonomy is harm argument, usually in its more objective form:


Any person can cause harm to others and justify it for subjective reasons = All harm becomes justified = Harm to prevent harm becomes justified.


However, the flaw of harm argument is essentially misunderstanding what harm is.


Harm entirely depends on desirable state of things or desirable functions being violated.


However, when it comes to wants and desires, cigarettes can be desirable on balance, so to not allow smoking would itself be harm.


Any person can deny wants of others for subjective reasons = all wants can be denied for subjective reasons, including wants of person to deny wants of others, hence resulting in inability of any person to deny wants (opposite principle)


Wants can be denied for subjective reasons = Wants to deny wants of others can likewise be denied for subjective reasons.


thus, "no person can deny wants of others", remains as true objective principle, because opposite principle simply doesnt survive dichotomy.


Harm argument likewise can be negated by body autonomy.


Body autonomy = Objective principle


In dichotomy between harm and body autonomy: Objective principle of body autonomy prevails.


Because harm can be justified by using not arbitrary, but objective principle of body autonomy.


Harm justified for objective reasons =/= Harm justified for subjective reasons.


So if body autonomy results in what person considers to be "harm", that harm is still not objectively wrong, because it isnt done with subjective justification, but an objective justification of body autonomy.



IV. Power/authority argument


One of big counters to moral principles and body autonomy is "might makes right".


In other words, someone can say:


"My decision to deny autonomy of others is justified by my power to do so."


However, power principle doesnt work in "should" debates, because it doesnt say what should or shouldnt be done.


Society has power to both impose and remove age restrictions, and having power alone doesnt deduce logically which decision should be made.


Likewise, morality which uses power as justification justifies anything, even my position. If something is justified by power, then all thoughts and actions which exist are justified by some power which enables them to exist, including my own position.



V. Subjective morality justification


Any moral principle derived from arbitrary reasons cannot be justified, and any excuse for violating objective principle by using arbitrary reasons merely enables its own denial by other arbitrary reasons.


Arbitrary reasons can be used to deny principle = Other arbitrary reasons can be used to deny those arbitrary reasons, and justification of "arbitrary reasons can be used to justify or deny" becomes self-defeat.



VI. Symmetry reciprocity principle


Any attempt to justify denying autonomy of others rests on these conditions:

  1. Justification for denial
  2. Ability of denial


Because justification is always arbitrary, same can be denied arbitrarily too, and 2 can be denied arbitrarily as well.


the only justification which would work is objective justification.


But who decides what objective justification is?


If anyone can decide what objective justification is = Anyone can decide to deny others of body autonomy based on what they think is objective justification, including denying ability to deny body autonomy, hence self defeat of any attempt at justification to deny body autonomy, even with what person thinks are "objective reasons.



VII. Opponent's burden


Because my opponent is ultimately arguing to violate body autonomy, the conditions for his position to be true are:

  1. Objective justification derived through deductive reasoning with starting premise being logical axiom
  2. Who decides what objective justification is?
  3. Who decides who gets to decide?
  4. Can objective justification be denied by some other objective justification?
  5. Solution to "ability of anyone to decide objective justification resulting in self-defeat".
  6. Who has ability to decide, and who gives that ability?


Compare that to simple body autonomy.


Everyone has body autonomy = No one violates autonomy of another


Principle is self-consistent, not self-defeating. the opposite principle, when accepted, defeats itself and returns to original principle after futile struggle to come up with justification which ends up being justification against the very principle using it, because symmetry argument which relies on same abilities defeats it.


If person says: "I can decide what objective justification for violating autonomy is",


I can say " then so can I, and I reject yours".



Conclusion:


With objective principle of "thou shall not violate autonomy of others" being logically deduced, and opposite principles resulting in self-defeat,

what follows is:


Choosing to smoke = allowed by body autonomy

Allowed by body autonomy = Allowed by objective morality

Choosing to smoke = Allowed by objective morality


Age restrictions = not allowed because they violate body autonomy

Violate body autonomy = Violate objective moral principle

Age restrictions = Violate objective moral principle.


So a person who smokes in private and doesnt smoke with others who are unwilling to inhale smoke, isnt violating autonomy of others.


But placing age restrictions is a violation of body autonomy and property choice.

SatanLucy

There’s a strong ethical argument that publicly sharing or distributing infant circumcision videos can violate the child’s privacy and bodily dignity, especially when:

  1. the infant cannot consent,
  2. their genitals are exposed,
  3. the footage may remain online permanently,
  4. and the child may later object to having intimate medical footage shared.

Legally, it depends on the country, context, and purpose. Some recordings are made for:

  1. medical education,
  2. parental documentation,
  3. or clinical training.

In medical settings, there are usually consent procedures involving the parents or guardians. But parental consent does not automatically settle the ethical question of the child’s future autonomy or privacy interests.

Many people also distinguish between:

  1. a private medical recording kept securely for educational/clinical use, and
  2. videos uploaded publicly to websites or social media for general viewing.

The second case raises much more serious concerns about privacy, exploitation, and digital permanence.

There are also broader debates around infant circumcision itself involving:

  1. bodily autonomy,
  2. parental rights,
  3. religious tradition,
  4. cultural practice,
  5. and medical claims.

Different societies and individuals weigh those factors very differently.

SatanLucy

What I never really understood is why circumcision videos of infants are legal?


Infant obviously didnt agree to be recorded, so its a violation of privacy.


the only difference between it and child porn is apparently "intention", but some people are probably jerking off to circumcision videos, so I dont see how that helps.

SatanLucy
You wouldn't stand a chance and you know it.


Against you? Not much of a challenge, to be honest. Most of your responses are like ramblings of a mentally ill person. But if you are interested in formal debate, sure, I don't mind. Tho topics I debate are probably out of your intellectual range.

SatanLucy
But tell use more Lucy oh great one about what qualifies as rational


I would love to tell you, but given that you don't believe in objective morality, there is no such thing as "rational behavior" in your playbook, so to you a violent ape is as justified as Immanuel Kant and Aristotele himself.


Of course, I would love to debate you on a lot of topics, but given your absurd positions, I wouldn't have to try very hard to win.

SatanLucy
"Brainless apes" cannot be provoked by words because they lack the ability to understand them in any meaningful context


Unproved claim.



To say that words cannot get an emotional reaction out of you is to say that you lack the capacity to formulate ideas in response to them.


Response =\= Emotional reaction =\= formulate ideas =\= beating someone up


Try a bit harder next time.


SatanLucy

Bumble scandal

SatanLucy · 6 months ago

Boycott Tinder if you actually care about punishing those with Epstein. If you don't, then you don't really care about stopping pedophilia.


I dont use tinder.









SatanLucy
Typical response from Dbl.


the guy thinks many absurd things. Of course he wants corporal punishment of children legal, which is also assault. He wants assault to be legal if someone calls him a nigger. He "wonders" if assault should be legal in cases someone is provoked by words. In words of one famous song: that boy needs therapy. He is crazy in the coconut.