Wryly

Vote Count

Kohai 3/9 - Mag1cman, ILikePie5, wylted

Mag1cman 2/9 - Casey_Risk, RexFavilla

Mestari 1/9 - Alyssa

Thoth 2/9 - Kohai, Mestari

Why Helz?

Done is done. The information is out now. It's not a terrible loss.

Why are we not lynching Pie again?

Also, somebody tell me who Thoth is please.

Because most of us know that being a brazen bull who charges unapologetically from target to target is NAI for Pie.

Actually, I think Black Noise is a fine instrumental outro

Not a bad track to listen to while playing mafia tbh

Mafia was bound to infiltrate the mason chats and learn the guild leaders' identities anyway, but I find myself agreeing that we could have learned a few things from either withholding the info or declaring it much later in the DP.

Why would you out yourself right away?

There was a protracted debate about it. One camp advocated for withholding who the guild leaders were in order to farm alignment-indicative behavioral data, the other advocated for outing right away in order to narrow POE.

On evens you get a free no lynch. 6 players, 2 scum, 4 town, if you no lynch the mafia reduces the game to 2v3 reducing the poe.

Ah, tyvm

Newb question, but why does it matter if it's odds or evens?

Did you rec Rex

Neither of them are words, why did I correct myself

*unrecruitable

Do you get a second try if one of your recruit targets turns out to be inrecruitable

What am I fucking thinking, they're town confirmed

I'm so tired

Yes if we openly discuss our recruiting plans, maybe they will look past the fact that were both actually scum and pulling another crazy gambit here. It's so crazy it might just work...

Fuck you for mindfucking me like this

Why did Mikal need to specify that dead players don't count toward faction totals

Are there roles that have utility after death and might blur the line enough to require that clarification?

Really don't get just straight up claiming this under limited pressure (I see 3 votes leading up to this), but here we are. I would give you some towncred for claiming this early, but given the info in the OP, everyone knew that peoples' characters could just be themselves.

Cut him some slack, he has quick-lynch PTSD lol

Vote Count

Mestari 2/9 - Alyssa, Thoth

Mag1cman 2/9 - Casey_Risk, Rex

Kohai 3/9 - Mag1cman, ILikePie5, wylted

ILikePie5 1/9 - Mestari

Pie's tactic, whether town or scum, is to go for weak points -- it's a bulldozer approach where the point is not necessarily to uncover scum but to narrow his POE. Or to give the appearance of narrowing his POE, obviously.

I'm tired of lynching Kohai!

My Kohai lynching muscles are exhausted!

Just send me to Gary, I want to be with Gary!

That one person who gets your reference and saves you from the crickets 🫂

Vote Count

Mestari 3/9 - Alyssa, Mestari, Thoth

Mag1cman 2/9 - Casey_Risk, Rex

Kohai 3/9 - Mag1cman, ILikePie5, wylted

Yeah catching up is gonna be murder this game

Did I miss Kohai claiming Kohai and Thoth softing himself?

softing himself *snort*

hey you technically hammered there miss

laughed so hard when I found out he was a Lie Detector too

I came up with a custom role for Culture (Iain Banks) Mafia where you could get a live feed of scum chat after you died and forward messages from it to a living player, after the messages were sanitized according to some strict rules. I gave it up because I couldn't figure out how to stop it from being broken without draconian restrictions, plus it felt like a violation of privacy to me.

Interesting. Seems like if you sanitized it to the point of being fair there would be little actionable utility in the information anyway.

It's more about the kind of personality than the degree of it

I must point out that being a blowhard is NAI

You weren't in the scum PM last game. You have no ideal why we are doing this. :)

That bus was crazy work

This whole game feels like that episode of Rick and Morty where new characters started popping up everywhere but the main characters remembered them always being there, and they turned out to be brain parasites that implanted you with long-term memories of themselves

Basically Mestari is Sleepy Gary

Can't believe we're turbolynching Mes for an excess of personality

I didn't even know that was a thing, I'm in danger

Vote Count

Mestari 6/9 - Alyssa, ILikePie5, Mestari, Kohai, wylted, Thoth

Mag1cman 1/9 - Casey_Risk

Kohai 1/9 - Mag1cman

Not town-confirming the leaders makes an interesting mindgame where townies could fake-claim to bait kills from the real guild leaders and the guild leaders would have to decide whether it's kill-baiting or scum trying to pocket town. I can see now why Mikal didn't officially confirm them.

Bait kills from guild leaders? wat