Wryly

I took the asking for a consensus as a further attempt to keep looking for info. I felt it had already been settled at that point

Shrug. I didn't. I think it's a legitimate stance that once a mass claim is started, it should be finished, otherwise it defeats the purpose, exposing info about town but potentially letting scum slip through the net. However when whiteflame brought up some valid points that we had a better target and if we were wrong you'd be soon to full claim next DP anyway, I acquiesced.

So here's my read of Wryly from DP2. I forgot about a few of these points. Asking questions is fine, I still don't like continuing to press for claims after I hard rejected doing so.

If by "pressing" you mean saying I get why you might not want to claim, and then asking for a consensus on whether to leave it there, and then agreeing with whiteflame to leave it there, sure, I pressed you like a panini.

That's why I said "welp that's taking us nowhere, we'll have to give wylted the benefit of the doubt."

Lol, you meant surprisingly yes you have a justification. I thought you meant surprisingly yes you mind telling me if you have a justification.

So what was #92 about?

I never suggested we VTNL.

Or a drunk two-year-old

Explain it as you would to a tired moron who just had to change an old lady's diaper after dragging an extension cord into a snowstorm to blow dry a frozen gas tank regulator

Hypothetically

No idea what you mean about VTNLing, but I'm cold and bleary-eyed

Sam Obisanya,1x Activist. Seems to be a custom role because I can't find it on the wiki, but it lets me pick one player during the night, and the next day phase, I will control that person's vote as well as my own. Waived both NPs bc I've had no time to think about the game and forgot this is MYLO. Justification is Sam is a beloved team member who inspires his team to protest Dubai Air.

Played poorly this game between taking care of my grandmother and dealing with the winter conditions in the country, and with me being late with my vote DP1 I look pretty bad too; doubtless why scum has kept me alive. Really wishing we could've heard Kohai's results so far before he was NK'd.

In my defense I can only say that I've been busy and I was just 30 seconds late with a post.

I don't sus Banana, so for me it's between whiteflame and Mag1cman.

In the future I don't think I'll be agreeing to "low activity" games even though it was nice of Luna to make an exception for us busies. Definitely enjoy the game less when I invest less time in it. I miss chewing over the details and rereading the day phases.

Rebecca Welton being a Vanilla is odd to me and so is your "passive at best" comment. The way you suggested lynching Shining again until it succeeded could be a point in your favor though. I don't think Pie's PM necessarily means anything because it also mentions Beard (Rex).

Guess we'll have to give him the benefit of the doubt on the no-justification thing then.

Other reasons to sus him remain.

Popular makes sense for Jamie Tartt so I'm guessing Banana got a justification. Everyone in the graveyard had a justification. My role card does as well. If it's the same for you three, wylted would stand out as the only one claiming there's no justification for his role. Each role PM seems so carefully crafted that I'm kind of skeptical Lunatic would do that.

Just a yes or no question

Do you guys mind telling me if you got a justification for your roles

I get where Mag1c is coming from because he didn't have any input on this decision to start claiming characters. Whether he's town or scum, I can at least make sense of why he wouldn't like this. Now that we're most of the way into a massclaim, I'm not fond of him just refusing outright to cooperate, but I'm not going to hound him for being absent.

From where I'm sitting at least, we have a good lynch target in Wylted, so it doesn't bother me as much if we don't get all the character claims on the table. If we do lynch Wylted and he somehow flips town, everyone will be expected to full claim next DP because we'll be at MYLO.

So to give a straight up answer to your question, while I personally would rather go through with it since several of us have already given up our claims, I'm fine stopping here as long as those who haven't are first to claim next DP.

Yeah I'm good with this.

We have a conflict of opinion on whether to mass claim. When it comes to mass claims I say everyone should do it or no one should. What say you.

Banana seems pretty townie to me. whiteflame is as unreadable as ever. Mag1c too. Kohai, idk. Claiming there's a hidden Miller seems like a great way to give yourself a cover if you're copped as scum. "Oh the hidden Miller must be me!" They could have used their role hint for that purpose. wylted is sus.

Tired. Bed. Nightmares. Dreamed strangers kept breaking into my house to take my socks off in the dark and hold my feet.

Doubt you can guess my role from my character so it's no biggie to me, but if his role is guessable from his char I can get Mag1c refusing to claim. Could just as easily be scum reticence under the guise of "don't claim you fools", though.

Wait did Kohai character claim

I feel a bit bad that Lunatic put this game together with a few neat mechanics and had to settle for a low activity game.

Anyway, still suspicious that Rebecca Welton would be a Vanilla and of there being no justification for it; my character has a justification. Banana's seems to as well. Anyone willing to weigh in on whether their character has a role justification?

Wonder if the hidden Miller will have a justification. I guess it could work for Rebecca? She seems like the antagonist at first but (according to whiteflame, I was still in the middle of her arc) becomes a solid ally later on.

That doesn't get me past "passive at best" though. Maybe I'm overthinking it.

Anyway, VTL Mag1cman for inactivity and lack of claim.

Gonna have to hard agree with whiteflame that "passive at best" is a weird thing to say about Vanilla.

I'll popcorn to Mag1c for no particular reason.

It’s 1 in 7 given two scum, but who’s counting? Actually, looking back on it, we made this easy for them. It had to be someone in Coaches and Staff, and if Wylted is town, that leaves only 3 players with that softclaim, and he claimed a woman so they had a coin flip between REF and Pie. Oops.

Lol, doy. Guess my brain hadn't caught up with me.

Also, I never watched season 2 and cannot BELIEVE Nate turns bad.

Sam Obisanya. Will role claim if we're doing that.

Hopefully you're reading this from urgent care, wylted.

Just hadn't updated the thread to see whiteflame's hammer, lynch me for it if you want. My role is influential but not critical so if we're gonna mislynch we could do worse.

I can't believe Shining picked correctly with 1 in 9 odds. And Rex inherits the role of the first player to be killed by the mafia but is the first player to be killed by the mafia. D:

VTL Shining

Has to be tied to him

Custom role maybe? Sheds a vote and kills an innocent. Wild.

#ComfortZoneVTLs

#LynchKohai

#LynchShining

Well done wylted, foolproof solve.