Periodic Table of Elements Mafia - DP2

Shining wrote:

Okay, so still not liking Lunatic. I honestly find it hard to believe we went from Lunatic Koolaid maning into the thread hours before DP1 ending saying Magoroth is totally scum and strong arming us into lynching him to Lunatic saying Casey is a little sus. His claim seems off to me as well. My PM is more justified than "lol Krypton means hidden".

This feels weak to me. He hasn't written off the possibility that I'm scum, as he shouldn't if he's town, but I'm definitely not the focus of his posts here, so it's weird to describe him as saying that "Casey is a little sus." Where did that framing come from?

Also, there's almost always one or two weaker justifications in any game. They can't all be perfect. I've definitely seen weaker justifications, even from Pie.

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Mikal (3/6): Bullish (p#146), Banana (p#185), Lunatic (p#326)

Bullish (3/6): Helz (p#287), whiteflame (p#324), Mikal (p#329)

Lunatic (1/6): RexFavilla (p#384)

Not Voting (4): Casey_Risk, Mag1cman (p#127), Shining, Thoth (p#338)

With 11 players alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day phase ends in 16 hours.

Whats yours like? Mine at least draws from the chemistry. Also, I get that hes not sussing you directly, but I am just having problems with his mindset this game. I'll ISO his DP1.

Whats yours like? Mine at least draws from the chemistry.

#122

Also, I get that hes not sussing you directly, but I am just having problems with his mindset this game. I'll ISO his DP1.

I'm only responding to what you actually said, and what you said didn't make much sense. Now you point to vague "mindset" stuff without specifics and say you're going to ISO him. Okay...

Does anyone here have any reason to TR Shining?

Shining is a bitch to read. This is his playstyle every game we always mislynch. Above post was very weird but its nai. Killed him a few games ago for similar reasons if I recall and he flipped town

Def think there ie some scum in magic Anna or shining. Mentioned this in an above post of mine

Think that is backseat to the larger issue if you and bullish though

Poe to me atm is you or bullish

Then magic shinning Anna

People that dont post coast. Down to a few hours so need to land on something. I wish people could see the utility in you but dont think its happening so staying bullish. Id shot bullish over luna anytime. I think there is a world wher3 luna is scum but just dont see his claim being something a scum luna does

Magic is also unusually inactive and seems to be lurking

Issue with this game is activity atm. Way to big of a pool of nulls.

FYI we need to consolidate votes. We do not need to end up in a situation where there is a cfd last min or we just get a no lynch cus we dont agree

A no lynch is literal worst case. Means if there is 3 scum we only get one lynch.

Above post was very weird but its nai.

What makes you so sure? To me, it feels like an opportunistic scum move, trying to get momentum on a wagon after Rex started it.

People that dont post coast. Down to a few hours so need to land on something. I wish people could see the utility in you but dont think its happening so staying bullish. Id shot bullish over luna anytime. I think there is a world wher3 luna is scum but just dont see his claim being something a scum luna does

I can get on board with a Bullish lynch. Still hate Shining's recent posts tho

I agree. Its weird as fuck

Just more like. Shinning does dumb shit in every game. Him and kohai are bitches to read

The behavior in general is scummy

Coming from him its nai

Its like when kohai says retarded shit that's stupid. He does it as town and scum

Not saying hes not. Just that there are some people that post very little and are just mislynch prone lol

I have an idea that i dont want to mention. Going to tell wf in chat but I just thought of a fucking genius way to solve this game. Assuming everything you said is true

Mikal wrote:

I agree. Its weird as fuck

Just more like. Shinning does dumb shit in every game. Him and kohai are bitches to read

The behavior in general is scummy

Coming from him its nai

Its like when kohai says retarded shit that's stupid. He does it as town and scum

Not saying hes not. Just that there are some people that post very little and are just mislynch prone lol

I agree that Shining often does stuff that can be read as scummy in general coming from other people, but that doesn't make him unreadable.

Thats true as well. Just saying from me its hard to discet. I do think hes scummy as shit though

Luna voted Rex DP1 but then immediately pivoted to Mago and forced a Mago lynch. Now, DP2 Lunatic points out how its odd there is three investigatives and then drops it after. You are investigative. Thats why I pointed to you, you fall in that group. Hes sus as shit

I've given wf a mechincal solve to nail poe heavily

Not putting it here cus i dont want it to be fucked with. But saying it so he can validate it when I point it out tomorrow

Between one us. There should be at least one of us alive. Assuming I dont get yeeted today and that info can get passed on

Your role works exactly as you said correct. If you come back and say something diff. It fucks this up horribly.

Shining wrote:

Luna voted Rex DP1 but then immediately pivoted to Mago and forced a Mago lynch. Now, DP2 Lunatic points out how its odd there is three investigatives and then drops it after. You are investigative. Thats why I pointed to you, you fall in that group. Hes sus as shit

Incorrect on multiple counts. Luna did not make a point about three investigatives being strange, and he's been consistent about sussing both Bullish and Mikal, but Mikal more. And you specifically said that Luna said that I am sus, which is really inaccurate. Out of me, Bullish, and Mikal, Luna has been consistent about sussing me the least. Why are you lying?

Mikal wrote:

Your role works exactly as you said correct. If you come back and say something diff. It fucks this up horribly.

As I said earlier, my role does have a very minor variation. I don't want to say exactly what it is yet, but it may, in fact, make your mechanical solve not quite work

caseyyyyyy why are you doing this to yourself. What version of scum me puts myself on the chopping block when I can just go along with mikal's plan and lynch you? I'm gonna be making the exact same arguments next DP except with a dead dreamer.

Noted

save me waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa casey's about to suicide herself on to mikal when I flip town

Bullish wrote:

caseyyyyyy why are you doing this to yourself. What version of scum me puts myself on the chopping block when I can just go along with mikal's plan and lynch you? I'm gonna be making the exact same arguments next DP except with a dead dreamer.

What the hell is this whining? I don't think I've ever seen you act like this before, and it's not helping your case.

What are your thoughts on Shining? Surely I can't be the only one who sees that he's blatantly lying, right?

How do you read Lunatic's post 144 then?

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Mikal (3/6): Bullish (p#146), Banana (p#185), Lunatic (p#326)

Bullish (3/6): Helz (p#287), whiteflame (p#324), Mikal (p#329)

Lunatic (1/6): RexFavilla (p#384)

Not Voting (4): Casey_Risk, Mag1cman (p#127), Shining, Thoth (p#338)

With 11 players alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day phase ends in 13 hours.

It's not whining I'm just pointing out scum/town motivations of today's happening.

I could have agreed with mikal and voted you at anypoint that his vote was also on you. But I didn't, instead I put myself on the chopping block to save you and 1v1 mikal.

If I was scum, this makes 0 sense. There's a 50% chance I die and and clear 3 other people. If I mikal dies and flips town, I'm STILL on the chopping block cause of the dreamer POE, and we lose our #1 advocate for lynching the dreamer.

Except as scum if you lynch her and she flips town, you are in the poe with confirmed results. Town should want to lynch her so they can consolidate night actions based on the flip results. This is exactly what I mean by tmi.

Shining wrote:

How do you read Lunatic's post 144 then?

Missed that one when doing a quick ISO. But did he ever say that he town reads either Rex or Bullish?