Banana

i know this is out of the blue but i can prove my role at any time. idrc if mafia kill me tho either, its not a super powerful role imo

I'm not sure that anyone is clearly the most townread, and anyway that could backfire horribly if we've misread people.

Townreading Magoroth. It would be industrial-grade WIFOM for scum to claim that where it's most likely going to get them lynched in the absence of a stronger scumread.

see? problem solved, we have mago choose our lynch

I've had that same concern before. How could we pick someone at random and prove that our choice was actually random?

mayb have the most town confirmed player or the most widely townread player pick

In this setup, we literally don't have a choice other than lynching someone and seeing what happens.

if we r gonna do this i say we should use a randomizer or somethin bcuz mafia can just suggest we lynch someone "random" n then we just lynch innocents

trying to decide if wylteds lynch every1 and see what happens attitude is more likly town or scum from him

Maybe he feigned arrogance because he thinks we would wonder where that arrogance would come from? I doubt it, but Mafia is ultimately a game of WIFOM.\

mayb but then we are just looking for any reason to call him scum at this point with this logic

i kno the basics of star wars from the movies but i havent seen all the shows

u just comited genocide and high treason against my ppl…

forgive me for tunneling but I think you outed yourself.

seems more like omgus then tunneling

i have never seen andor btw

Waaait a sec. No Pie... no Mag1c... no Lunatic... no Shining. Gasp. There is no one to check our fluff at all.

fluff 4 days!!!

/in

ty

4 anyone still suspecting me or voting me i can confirm my role at the end of the day phase if needed n theres no way my role would b on scum

wryly isnt on the player list. i wanna town read this

Yes I determined pie was town by asking him, revealed that I am a male and started a train on whiteflame. 

i am just sayin not much has happened yet

i was very active in live mafia you can scroll up in the discord and see all of my posts. N i think it’s funny you saying im not active when uve been voting Wylted for his pfp. I don’t see how that’s game advancing at all. anyways i will try to post more but I haven’t seen much that stands out to me just yet other than townreading magic a bit for town leading

not yet

have u made any game advancing posts?

my character is female

VTL Banana

hi how can i help u

i play

if someone wants to help me with mine lmk i asked mharman already but havent heard back

I thought Castin and Banana both played well. Banana held her own against Pie, which is no small feat.

ty and no it wasn't. hes just too good.

Your posts were pretty fire despite being under pressure, props

ty, i just need to work on my skills at convincing other people the way pie does, that whole ordeal was an uphill struggle but it seemed ez for him lol

and i knew you were town, i had town read u from the beginning, ur my only read that i was like 100% sure on and never changed all game

aww pie was actually scum... darn it i tried guys

anyways I don’t really have time to keep

responding to everything pie is saying here, n it’s getting repetitive. here’s what I’ll say tho, pie is making a lot of assumptions about balance and mechs that he can’t possibly know n that are heavily based on his opinion but disregarding my own opinions about a cc with an even night slanderers. he keeps making excuses for himself but is bein a giant hypocrite. its okay to use bad logic to accuse me but he uses the same logic to defend himself. u all can read everything and see it for ur selves but he is not arguing in good faith, his sole intention is to get me mislynched at all costs.

i am town. i really dont know what more to say other than it sucks to be lynched bcuz people are choosing not to believe my role. idk what to do about that. this is the role the mod gave me. at least i wasn’t directly cced like pie was.

She’s not new anymore lol. She literally fake outrage at Mikal for 4 DPs straight to hard bus him and they both won that game

mikal took the lead on all of that plus i got lynched in the end on that one. also if ur saying i was outrage in that one what r u saying the similarity is here cuz im not outraged

Town can use those roles to harm scum. Your role…ONLY HARMS TOWN.

not necessarily. what if it Vader was gonna do something he passionately thought was to help town but I saw it differently. like say he could kill wryly or something. i townread wryly so i would probably veto that. also if he is t doing something like that im just gonna not use the role so it doesn’t matter. it should only be used against me if i use it in a scummy way, which im not gonna.

You’d feel silly when I flip town if you’re town. But you’re gonna be happy when I flip town as scum.

im jus sayin ur scum reading me for my actual role that i have is actually silly. i have no control over the role the mod gave me. are u just going to blame the mod when ur wrong here or what

So…you were bandwagoning both times. You just voted the left to never be seen again twice. 

i agreed with the scum tells and plus we needed to get lynched off. would it be better if i never voted at all? n the part about me never to be seen again is wrong, ive been here and ive been open about my reads all game. ive been just as active as u if not more so i dont wanna hear that

This is just wrong. I sussed Mago before he did the whole Framer thing. The fact that you’re being this disingenuous and people are buying this just shows we don’t deserve to win the game. Town just falls apart when I can’t carry. And then I do, I get NKed. This isn’t even fun anymore.

sounds like u have a bit of an ego there…

i reject that i am being disgenuous…

Thats exactly what you’re doing because the premise of your argument is there can’t be 2 Slanderers when there are literally 2 Benefactors, and you’re one of them.

ur purposely ignoring the part about synergy and gaslighting my argument. 2 EVEN night slanderers. my benefactor and kohais is odd/even. even Whiteflame agreed this is odd

I already said I don’t scumread you for that part. But you pinged everybody and specifically pointed out how everything is connected except my one role. Your role makes ZERO SENSE with a townie.

that’s an opinion not a fact, and it happens to be wa wrong opinion bcuz i am town and this is my real role

So again. Do you think I’m lying about claiming Even night Slanderer? Because it’s a confirmable role. It’s in the OP that there are multiple roles like that. If there are 2 Benefactors, why can’t there be 2 Slanderers?

yes i do n ill use the same argument Whiteflame jus used on me, if you haven’t proved ur role yet you cant say ur confirmable like it means anything just like i cant yet because there was no even night phase

Im talking about my Lynchproof that I can unlock with a little more favor. You conveniently ignored that too. So ya I can confirm my slanderer, and I can confirm my lynchproof.

my response to this is the same as the above. y do you get a pass to live to confirm ur role but I don’t

i gotta go to work guys ill be back a bit later