RexFavilla-
Comes in hot. votes the first person participating and doubles down . Less likely WvW between Rex v Mag here. I see the positive of breaking RVS but also the flat out aggression that could be NAI.
they come back with the first thing that pinged me. “Kohai is being retarded might be up for killing him.” The thing of note here is the flat goal of killing. Not pressuring for info or anything else. This looks like an intention indicator to flatly eliminate that tracks from a scum prespective. To consider why we look at where they expect to be town read. And keep in mind how they voice it “Do you think Kohai is scummy for not being able to see how town I am? Or do you think he is just bad at reading people?” Wow. That’s some certainty. Lets take a moment and unpack what Kohai had to work with at that point reviewing Rex’s posts:
RVS vote
Doubling down on the RVS vote for giggles
Correcting their vote so the vote counter accepts it
Blank vote on me
What part of these postings makes it retarded for Kohai to not town read them? And to the point Kohai should die? Who could possibly read Rex as town with those posts so far? What logic could possibly exist? I see absolutely nothing. But whatever. Maybe they are just being overly aggressive to break RVS?
Kohai gets mod confirmed as IC. Then I question what their reasoning was for their stance that they should have been town read and why I look suspicious to them knowing they just shoved 2 players I know are town. Their response is vague and shades me saying its scummy for me to even ask then later framing my questioning as being defensive. So lets look at how they could have scum read me from my posts:
I voice my challenge (that I decided prior to game start) and point out that the mafia team having questions has bearing on Thoth’s claim
I clarify why I make such challenges
I clarify why has implications on Thoth’s claim
I explain how I saw mafia night kill dynamics playing into Thoths claim and open that PoE back up
I push Mag1cman for a questionable read on Thoth
So what part of this justifies me being scummy? Vague feeling and all. Then I get voted. Again These are the posts they had to work with at the time of their read. While I think their “Kohai should be killed because they did not town read me” was absolutely unreasonable I can at least slightly see me being scum read for not trusting Thoth and pushing Mag1cian? Its also a bit of a reach but hey, breaking RVS and such is a thing. Now we dive into their interactions.
They question the Mago pressure. A bit early for me to consider a chainsaw play but logic follows given their focus on me leading me to take this post as aligned.
is where I shove Rex for reasoning. they respond that they had a vibe on the town confirmed slot and that me asking for reasoning was scummy. (Which is a very odd position) They double down saying because they are town they should have been read as such almost entering TSTBS territory and felt that I was overexplaining myself which is at least reasonable.
is the first sign of town I really see. A frustration at the IC reveal after mentioning it before and it does feel genuine even if its going ATE.
is just invalidating logical points and shifting the subject to a ‘You scum read me because Kohai decided to pop his IC, Not because of my absurd stance on Kohai’ narrative which I dislike greatly.
Summing it up I do not see much consistent thought in their positions. It really feels like they have intention to kill with little consideration or logic reflecting an intention tell and their purported reads just feel fake to me.
