ILikePie5
Considering what he softed (i.e. one of the three main characters of this movie), I doubt that it's something scum were given as a fake claim. It's possible that one of them just isn't in the game and Mharman gave scum the fake claim, but I'd consider that less likely than the possibility that the claim Kohai is giving is a fake claim. Just strikes me as a lot for Mharman to not only have created this game with a theme he isn't invested in only to nix one of the three female leads and then choose to hand it over as a full fake claim complete with role for scum.


If you believe this then maybe he’s just soft claiming the gender of his true character. Overall my point is that his softing of a female is NAI when we don’t know what the theme is. Maybe it’s 1-2 of the main girls vs everyone else

ILikePie5
Right now, the only two people I’m uninterested in getting are Kohai (whose character and role I believe I know) and Thoth (I have more reason to buy his soft than anyone else so far). If I had to pick among the rest of you, I’d take Rex first, then you. 


Depends on what he’s sifting. Scum were given fake claims. Doesn’t mean anything that he’s softing

ILikePie5
I have a strong suspicion of who Kohai is and, like Thoth said, a good reason to townread him. I’ll leave it at that. I also have good reason to townread Thoth as I said earlier. Guess we’re just generally on the same wavelength because I’m also sussing Luna just a tad. Be able to explore that more after he softs.


My initial reaction to Luna’s post about Vaarka is that it’s townie, but coming from Luna I think it’s null. He’s a smartie.


Gut scum read is Thoth. Some of his posts just read as TMI to me. Especially the one about 2 scum but they can’t communicate


I’ll get into the “why” of these later. For now, though, mainly want to see more from Pie and Rex, both of whom haven’t posted much (2 posts apiece) and I’m null on both as a result. Slightly more interested in hearing from Pie first, so that’s where I’m starting:

VTL Pie

I get that this theme isn’t something you know much about, but I’m going to need more than just frustration from you.


Ya, don’t really care about theme + basically doing 2 jobs at work cause a coworker took another position on another team. Just super busy right now

ILikePie5
Yeah and i am kind of wondering why he would tell people to put their discords on private if there was only one scum, but it could just be because he sent out pm's via discord and people could read into timing of night action submission, etc. Idk. Hard to say one way or the other, I can see there being two scum or one and a third party though. 


This is a good point, but I think it makes it more likely there’s one scum. Cause if we pull a Mikal and analyze the activity on discord, then the game is basically over in one fell swoop

ILikePie5
Mharman said this back in May, but he tends to be pretty consistent with his modding when it comes to numbers:

"the rule i operate with is that town should be able to survive as many mislynches as there are scum. Vaarka taught me that, so I refer to it as Vaarka's Golden Rule (he may have been taught by someone else, but idk who). I taught the concept to Whiteflame and Casey btw. 9players, 2 scum. 13 players, 3 scum. 17, 4. So 5,9,13,17,etc is a sequence in those numbers halfway between numbers in a sequence, I put 0.5 scum, a tp.


So since two mislynches equals a town loss, going by mharmans logic, I am guessing there could be one scum and one third party, since this game is an in between number of that sequence.

There is the off chance that mharman didn't stick to that logic, so take this with a grain of salt, but if mharman is consistent with this then there is probably just one scum (with a fake claim) and one third party (not sure if he would have given a third party a fake claim, and he didn't clarify in the OP). So characters claims may be useless here, or at best only might expose a third party. 


I agree. 3-1-1 makes the most sense. Don’t necessarily agree with the hard fast rule, but logically it makes sense that he would follow it.

ILikePie5

Current Games:


None



Sign-ups:

 

Thoth - Culture Series Mafia

 


In the Hopper:


Whiteflame - Frieren Mafia

Vader - Heartbreaking Chicago Bears Moments

Pie - MAGA Mafia

Mikal - Hero Academia Mafia

REF - Ruyi Zhuan Mafia

Lunatic

Savant - Andor Mafia


On Hold:

 

AnonymousIcon

Wylted - Lulsec


ILikePie5

I don’t think it’s bastard. It’s harder to balance and town should obviously be compensated for a role like Yakuza. If town is not then it’s just the mods fault. Scum have the power of being informed. Town doesn’t need to be informed