ILikePie5
I agree that mistakes were made on the town front here, though the extra NK is just such a huge overcorrection and made the game tremendously swingy, putting town in a situation where we could (and did) end up at MYLO in DP2. That's the biggest issue I have with this because it almost seems like it was here to correct for both the pseudo-mod confirmed players and a pretty big town advantage in roles that would have taken more than one NP to fully exploit.


Issue is that it was modkillable. The rules clearly stated don’t copy paste. I personally thought they should’ve been mod killed, and I advocated for that in the scum PM. But instead of 2 townies being modkilled and another lynched, only 1 townie was eliminated with the extra NK. I agree that it was broken, but so was the fact that Thoth and Mikal weren’t mod killed.


The Luna thing and Max thing, I didn’t really care about. Even with the PM thing, we could’ve at least argued that scum received the town win con, but David went in and interfered, which gave them the mod confirmation. That’s basically 3 players who were mod confirmed town.

ILikePie5
I have literally only seen GF’s in mashes (36p+ games) and automated closed role madness turbos (maybe a 1% chance of them showing up and they last less than 2 hours so if someone loses due to it, which has happened, it’s very low stakes and people tend to shrug it off)

let’s be real there was no way I was not going down today, probably


Realistically yes. If you wouldn’t given your character and justification, it probably would’ve helped a little

ILikePie5
Since when has a Framer or Lawyer ever shown up in games? I have not seen one in god knows how long 

especially in a 10 player game, maybe Framer is possible, but Lawyer? No way in hell


it’s actually pretty common on this site along with Godfather


ILikePie5
My goal here is not to say that you are proof positive scum. I'm explicitly not going down this rabbit hole to explain that you must be scum because you could have done all this. I'm pointing to reasons why you should not be dismissed you as obvious town. If you've got some basis for confirming yourself as town that I'm unaware of, be my guest and present it.


You kind of are though. On one hand you’re saying Mikal doesn’t have to be scum, but on the other you’re saying because of our roles, he has to be scum.


I’ll just shoot you a question point blank: what is your scum exactly scum team?

ILikePie5
I love how both Mikal and REF are justifying the decision for the latter not to claim on the basis that this lynch is absolutely assured to be scum. I understand the basis for Mikal thinking that since he has solid evidence to that effect. REF should at least be a little unsure. Both of them keep talking about all the WIFOM reasons why scum would fake well or use their fake claim in a way that nets them an obvious lynch (as if there's no obvious lynch on the table that requires absolutely none of that).

Do any of the three of you agree that the priority should be to avoid further claims, even among players everyone has acknowledged are in POE, in MYLO/LYLO on the basis that we might get a night action that isn't meddled with? Seriously, polling the room on this.


I would like all claims on the table before I decide, but it’s basically a certainty that Awesome is scum. Getting the big picture is the best thing. Also, why have you not pressured Awesome to full claim? Do you townread Awesome?

ILikePie5

Agree with Post 125 from Mikal. That result is very damning.


1) Timing is irrelevant to me. But mod confirmed there’s something that causes day chats for another faction. Could be a TP Neighborizer, but then the 3rd kill doesn’t make sense. Claim and everything check out


2) I’ve been saying from the beginning that Awesome’s role could be a scum role. Ending town communication is a positive thing for scum any day of the weak. Unfortunate we didn’t lynch him yesterday. The issue here is that we have 2 contradictory results. WF investigates Awesome innocent. Mikal’s Caroler results imply Awesome is scum.


3) I think the game is over. Awesome is 1000% scum. I am affiliation confirmable. Mikal can’t die. Max is confirmed. Awesome + REF/WF. I told yall that one new person + one native is mod psyche

ILikePie5
Also means if there is a tp and we hit them and not scum. We still lose 


If there’s a TP SK, then it makes sense for there to only be 1 mafia member due to the sheer number of kills and balancing issues (though David clearly doesn’t know how to balance). It’s still speculation.

ILikePie5
Shooting you when you claimed is one thing, since that was betting on whether you were telling the truth. Going into a DP with two flips that CC each of the roles I’m planning to claim and two existing claims on the table that do the same and going ahead with the dual fake claim anyway would be beyond anything I’ve ever tried before, particularly in a game like this where I, as scum, would only need one mislynch to end this and attention on me detracts from that.

It’s WIFOM, yes, but damn, this would be the worst informed fake claim choice I’ve ever decided to go ahead with.


Max to me is mod confirmed town for the simple fact that David basically stated in the OP that Max’s role exists.


Mikal is also someone who is nearly town confirmed to me. Just because of David’s comment about not discussing PM structure. Is there a world where he could be scum? It’s possible, but the risks that would entail make absolutely no sense to me. Why town confirm 2 players. Why claim off the bat. It doesn’t make sense.


From where I’m sitting, I genuinely doubt whether both yours and Mikal’s roles exist in the game. So either you’re scum or Mikal is scum from where I’m sitting at. However, if you’re both town, then from my POV it has to be exactly Awesome/REF.


Basically, my solve is Awesome + WF/REF

ILikePie5

Alright, before I read the DP, I reread DP1 to see if there was any indication of who Unsaid and Luna targeted.


Unsaid’s scumread in his last post was Luna, so logically, he shot Luna, and Luna as the flip shows is town. Not much to analyze there, but it’s the best logic out there


Lunatic’s last sorta scumread was on me. So logically, he roleblocked me last night. Didn’t matter cause there were a million kills. I’d like to take the town cred but it’s speculation, so I’ll leave it.


With that said, it seems both Luna’s and Unsaid’s roles were quote on quote affiliation checkers to a certain extent. Combined with a known Watcher, Tracker, Caroler, and Cop, it’s definitely wayyy too many town investigative roles

ILikePie5
Cus anti claim. I think I have a solve and don’t want to risk anything till we lock it in. I don’t need your character. What role are you ?


Any explanation for the kill? Cause if not, it had to come from anti-claim (and I think the only people who had full claimed were Supa and Max), so I don’t think your character matters. I would like your character and justification. I’ll full claim after that




ILikePie5
Yes, so obviously I'd make the very smart choice as scum to fake my claim in such a way that I would partially CC two flipped players and two other claims on the table. Certainly doesn't make me stand out as obvious. I understand not liking the CC, but come on man. Do you seriously think I'd give a fake claim as scum that CCs this many people and then decide to use it in full after that flip?


Youve done crazier things aka shoot a claimed PGO. You know this is WIFOM.


I need to reread DP1

ILikePie5
Seems to have been a crazy NP... I'll catch up on that in a bit...

For now just wanted to say that I recruited Mikal, got a "No results" reply... I asked if that means I was roleblocked and got essentially a "can't answer" reply... So it's probably fair to say I was RBd


Interesting.

ILikePie5
And since you seem to be saying you sent your Carol to Pie, why did you choose him? You had two players you showed were mod confirmed. Why Pie?


+1


Max was also solid town to him




ILikePie5
Also, why the fearless claim? We just had three deaths in one night after being warned about a strong anticlaim mechanic, with much of town claiming DP1 regardless of that. Personally, I'm incredibly leery about further claims. I have no role which could account for the extra deaths. That's the first question that should have been asked. I've tagged Pie as well to ask him that question. If he also answers no, the onlyexplanation for those extra deaths is anticlaim. In that case full claiming this DP could lose us the game.


I can confirm that my role would not cause an additional death. Agree with the analysis that anti claim has to be responsible.


I think it's possible to solve this game without more full claims on the table. Given the circumstances, I think that full claiming may lose us the game even if we hit scum this DP by doing so if the mechanic is so strong that it can create extra deaths in the NP.


It really depends on which of the 3 scenarios I mentioned is here. I’ll say that I was hoping this game would go to at least DP3 for the best use of my role. Lunatic dying really was bad though.