ILikePie5
Might as well. 

I’m Dexter’s Laboratory. Justification says there’s almost nothing I can’t create or solve.

I’m the Doc/Cop. I copped Awesome innocent.


So a Doctor as well? Definitely don’t like this claim at all. At this point it’s a direct CC to Vader, Thoth, Mikal, and Unsaid

ILikePie5
could be a third faction, but this game is dumb. 


I’ve maintained since the beginning there’s a good shot there’s a TP in a 10p game


I had a way to lock scum and the way david processes results made it impossible. On god im just willing to yolo lynch to get to the next game. 


I’m confused as to what this means? What processes do you need to ask about as a Popular/BP/Caroler?

ILikePie5

Preliminary thoughts:


1) It’s likely that Unsaid targeted a townie, which is why he’s dead. I’ll look back in a bit to see who who he was sussing. Don’t know how there were 2 additional kills. 1 seems like the NK, don’t know how there is another


2) Whoever Luna targeted didn’t execute the NK, so that could provide some evidence in someone’s favor. Again, going to have to look back to see who he was sussing


3) A Caroler/Dreamer? (Mikal), Tracker (Vader), possible Watcher (Unsaid), and Lie Detector (Thoth) seem like wayyy too many town investigative roles.


4) With 6 players it’s either 3-2-1 or 4-2. If the TP can joint win, we’ve already lost. If they can’t joint win it’s LYLO. If there is no TP, it’s MYLO. Regardless I’ll reiterate what I’ve been preaching. PLEASE DO NOT VOTE UNLESS YOU ABSOLUTELY SURE

ILikePie5
Just as with Max, the sudden claim from Supa makes me suspicious because only scum would not fear anticlaim, so claiming suddenly DP1 (especially after protesting it) is just overall sus to me. It's like he calculated that he could get more town cred for claiming, it doesn't feel genuine. I also feel like if you're going to throw a fit to stave off the night kill as town why not do it without claiming? I'm leaning more towards a desperate reaction like in that one game you linked. I don't know whether it's an act or not. My gut says not but that example you gave has been undermining that.


This is a great point I hadn’t thought of. Max just outright claimed albeit with a confirmable. Supa doing a complete 180 makes no sense. He was aware of the anti claim. Even talked about it. Going to iso him real quick

ILikePie5
Debating if this is a bluff. 


I honestly think it is. He’s done this before in a previous game. I don’t have time to dig it up right now. The only thing holding me up is the claim and the role.


My other scum read is Awesome. Like I said, his role doesn’t add up, and it can be a scum role too. From a balance perspective it makes sense to give it to scum too. I would’ve liked his character to determine justification, but his utility alive is pretty much non-existent from where I’m sitting at. I trust you as one of my top town reads, so I don’t know if I’m ready to pull the trigger yet.




ILikePie5
It’s also the fact I layer out pretty decent logic for Pie being scum later on after thinking about it but it just gets avoided all together


What logic? Last I saw, I was in your null pile

ILikePie5
Has Supa ever raged out before being lynched like that as scum? The two games I can recall him being scum in he just kind of sadly withered away and died once he thought it was hopeless.


Yes he has. I vividly remember a game from DART where he did that. .


ILikePie5
awsomes role is in the op and kinda validates that role being in the game. Which to be fair he did say off the rip 


It’s a direct counter to Max’s claimed role. Makes sense for scum to have something like what Awesome is claiming. Also note that he said he could enable/disable the ability, but if he died it would be perma disabled.

ILikePie5
Alright well I’m the tracker and I’m Steve from blues clues 

tough shit if I die atp. Town deserve it for forcing claims in an anti mass claim mechanic


So you went from saying you’re not going to be claiming no matter what to claiming. I can see the justification, but what’s the justification Kohai gave?

ILikePie5
Alright, now that's interesting. So there is effectively mod confirmation that your role is in this game. That does explain your earlier statement on Masons as well.


Doesnt confirm his affiliation though. And there’s still the question of the lack of win con in his PM. My theory is that as scum, he probably has an ability to disable chats, or it’s some sort of anti claim feature

ILikePie5
I can enable or disable day chats. If I die, all day chats are disabled


So how can you enable or disable chats but chats are disabled when you die?


If mafia chat was the only day chat, my role would be strictly -EV, which is why I talked about masons and neighbors
ILikePie5
I agree with unsaid, and am surprised people are over-looking supa. Lazy reads are one thing, but he is just typing to type. Also notice how he's been so against this "POE list" the whole game but then his town reads almost copy it verbatim, and he hops onto the awesome wagon. Makes me think awesome is a viable mislynch for scum. I am willing to lynch vader over whiteflame and awesome, with how busy vader keeps claiming to be he will likely hold up night phases anyway, and his reads haven't been heavy hitting this game. I know he's capable of more and I feel like when he is town its a lot more obvious. I am not seeing that from him.

I am voting vader.

VTL Vader


Could be Vader + Awesome or Vader + Unsaid.

ILikePie5
Right now my reads are as follows

Town
mikal 
luna

slight town
unsaid
thoth

null
pie
max
wf
awesome
rex


So you have zero scumreads at this stage of the game? Gun to your head, who would you lynch?

ILikePie5
We're running short on time and, unfortunately, I'm short on sleep. For people who want my claim, I'll point back to post #384 where I said my role is alignment-specific. If you still want it, I'll give it just so we can move on, but it's a town-only role.


Definitely missed this. Are you 100% sure this role cannot be given to town? And are you sure that it is confirmable?

ILikePie5
i kind of want to vote pie for possibly tmi'ing mikal and thoth town lmfao


It’s mod confirmation. Theres no reason for Kohai to say don’t talk about PM wincons