ILikePie5
They have rules that anything that happens outside of the game is off the table. Pm structure, mod messages, talking about someone not being there so they are scum blah blah. It still happens, people just lie about why they town read or scum read instead of being honest. Hand waiving off a mod mistake is impossible and always going to impact your read on someone


Ya that’s kind of a dumb rule. It’s the mod’s fault for being dumb

ILikePie5
I think it could be pie. David has went dead silent after the most of time. Prob cus pie is eating his ass in pms


I would’ve quit the game by now if I was scum lol. He’s just as trash of a mod as a player. Thankfully this time it’s working in my favor

ILikePie5

Can you clarify what this means:


”Flavor is NAI, however please be aware that there are some extremely nasty anti-claiming mechanics so claim at your own risk.”


Or at least rephrase it? Does it mean anti-claim applies to scum and town?

ILikePie5
In the op. Why would he warn mafia against anti claim lmao 


Where did he warn that?


All it says is that “Flavor is NAI,” meaning characters are NAI. Meaning bad guys can be town



ILikePie5
The fact David is saying we can’t discuss it implies they weren’t. Plus it’s David. He messaged me saying he should have specified that


Yes, I’m responding as I read the posts. Updated town block:



Pie

Mikal

Thoth

Luna

WF


Awesome

Unsaid

Vader

REF

Max

ILikePie5
I’m willing to shoot both pie and awesome. The idea they are pushing back out anti claim mechanics the op says it strikes me as beyond odd. Prob 1 scum there. 


It doesn’t matter anymore cause Thoth is mod confirmed town.


But where does it say that town have anti-claim mechanics? The whole point of anti-claim mechanics is to harm town.


Explain it like I’m 5 how town can have anti-claim mechanics.


ILikePie5
I’m a popular, Caroler, that can’t be night killed


Popular Bulletproof Caroler, nice lol


not claiming my character cus I think the anti claim mechanics apply. 


i am immune to all killing actions but if I am targeted it stops my from singing. I was debating this, I think the balance is
that I also can target scum with the song and they can lie. There are also other factors that stop the song from going off. Don’t what to say what they are. But essentially I give someone a dream (what I meant by confirmable )


also im popular. 

ask me why this role is here and can’t tell
you



ILikePie5
Moderator warning: Do not copy and paste directly from your PM. Also refrain from discussing the actual wording of the win condition. This type of discussion extremely close to what would typically be mod kill able. Do not discuss the is further and do not read into the alignment of any players with regard to this post. 


Well this mod confirms both Thoth and Mikal lol. Thanks lmao


ILikePie5
The instant agreement of the PM structure. If I was baiting and that was not in PM he risks getting caught. Scum would be risking a bait to say that 


Wouldn’t it depend on if scum were given town’s wincon?



ILikePie5
Kohai said flavor is NAI, which makes me think that, even if we knew one scum character, we would not be able to guess the other, but I could be wrong.


He said there’s no theme. What does that have to do with anti claim.


At the risk of providing fodder one of those nasty anti-claim mechanics, I'm going to say that my character is one of the more well-known ones from the 90s/early 00s. I'm willing to infer that most or all characters in here are also well-known, which makes the pool of likely inclusions shallow enough that fake-claiming characters could be risky, especially since Kohai said nothing about mod-provided fake-claims. Town might also have an investigative role that can check characters. This means that scum are likely to straight-claim their characters. Therefore, town could plausibly have anti-claim mechanics.


That is not a logical conclusion lol. If Town has a character cop, then the game is designed where scum have to fake claim. Even if scum are forced to claim their characters, that doesn’t mean town has anti claim mechanics.

ILikePie5
Potentially plenty, if scum straight-claim their characters. The chance of scum straight-claiming their roles is inherently close to zero, but Kohai said in the OP that flavor is Not Affiliation Indicative.


What does that have to do with anything?

ILikePie5
You know what else does not add up? Three votes to a majority. The only way that could have turned into an accidental firing squad is if three people voted within a window narrow enough that they either did not see each other's vote or could plausibly claimed not to have seen them, and people would probably treat those triplets as having one or two confirmed scum.


You were the one that suggested it, now you’re like it’s fine? That’s a major flip flop

ILikePie5

Post 97 from Thoth bothers me a lot. First he proposes the whole “Commit” thing for pressure, then he just goes and adds his vote onto Max anyways and says he’s not responsible if things go sideways.


This is coming off of last game where we had a quickhammer and he explicitly said: “Do not put your finger on the trigger until you are ready to fire,” later on after being hammered and in my PSA thread.


It doesn’t add up behaviorally

ILikePie5

iLikePie - ??? - ???

Thoth - ??? - ???

Lunatic - ??? - ???

awesome5000 - ??? - ???

Airmax1227 - ??? - ???

Rex - ??? - ???

Vader - ??? - ???

Mikal - ??? - ???

Whiteflame - ??? - ???

unsaid - ??? - ???


ILikePie5
Kinda mod pysch but I don’t think David randomized it 


I think one person originally from DC and one of the newer people to the site would be a solid selection if he didn’t randomize it. Unsaid and Awesome are both experienced players. Usually new players are noobs, and they end up town, but these guys seem like vets.


so have a feeling a scum would be between myself, pie, Luna, max and wf 


First 3 are town block. Add WF as well albeit a little less. That leaves Max.



Probably one scum in Max, REF, Vader

One scum in Thoth, Unsaid, Awesome with an emphasis on the latter 2

ILikePie5
Don’t know unsaid well enough to form a read but the throwing shit around everywhere thing is usually an old meta and typically a town tell. Mafia have no reason to “make something stick” this early. If anything it just draws unneeded attention to him.


It’s basically Mharman’s scum tell. Just does random shit all of DP1 to seem like he’s scum hunting

ILikePie5
Eh, screw it. If there's pressure, I might as well add some, and with three votes remaining, it ain't gonna be my fault if someone misfires.


Weren’t you the one who just said that we should do the whole “Commit” thing?

ILikePie5
Given how sternly kohai warned us all that claiming is at your own risk, I'm curious as to whether or not town could have any anti-claim mechanics, although, for obvious reasons, I am emphatically not asking any townies with anti-claim mechanics to say so.


What’s the utility of that for townies?


ILikePie5
hes saying factional a lot. Wonder if there is tp


Wouldnt be surprised in a 10p game. 7-2-1 is usually the balance, but never played in a game of his. Hopefully his modding skills aren’t as bad as his playing skills

ILikePie5
There's a mandatory lynch on the table. I haven't asked, but I'm pretty sure that means we can't abstain from a lynch even if we VTNL. We will eliminate someone every DP, regardless of ties or lack of majority votes.


Okay, adding WF to the townblock for this comment


Townblock: Pie, Mikal, Luna, WF