ILikePie5
Math wise, if hes scum and alive tomorrow the game is over. Check me, but I've checked it twice. Assuming there is no nk preventions. 


It’s 6-2 right now. If mislynch + NK, then 4-2. If we lynch Kohai and he’s scum, then 4-1 to 3-1, and then 2-1, so we still should be good. Best action is probably lynching Kohai tomorrow regardless of what we think his affiliation truly is.


yes you need to claim first because you should know I targeted you and that also makes me uneasy.


ILikePie5
Nope. I am actually quite shocked tbh. I confirmed that with the mod. We could technically go to F3, I get lynched, and town can still win if I kill correctly. 


How? 2-1, you getting lynched puts scum at parity and win

ILikePie5
fair point. TBH he is still my strongest scum read and it is not just because of flavor claiming


What else is it then?

ILikePie5
If I claim, we should really look at just full claiming at some point and I am not claiming before pie does. It will give him leverage to wiggle out of something and I am not doing that.


Everyone should full claim today tbh. Idm going first, but my role loses complete utility if I do. As for who scum would’ve recruited, Kohai, if town, is the logical option since he would take a townie down with him.

ILikePie5
You should know I'm town, you are saying you don't know that?

VTL Pie


I received no such message. I’ve pinged Luna in case he made a mistake

ILikePie5
VTL Pie 

He is literally the odd ball out with claims. He is the only other human in the game 


So far. There are people who haven’t claimed yet. Also, unless you think the theme is humans vs everything else, which is a simple theme, I’m not scum (Luna already said the theme isn’t simple)

ILikePie5
Well that undermines a lot of stuff lol. Anyone can be scum. Pie should know I'm town


and how would I know that?

ILikePie5

We really need to start doing verbal affirmations instead of actual votes to prevent this type of BS

ILikePie5

Your victim is dead basically the minute a Facehugger attaches to you. But you don’t die immediately because the xenomorph grows inside of you. Only after the chest buster comes out that, that you die. That explains the the apportioner

ILikePie5

He has no clue what a justification is. He’s reading too deep into his PM. Anyone on that wagon probably isnt going to die, especially me, so I suggest to any protective roles to not target me

ILikePie5
In the context of my role PM's flavor, yes it does.


Thats not a justification. If you’re telling the truth, your justification is that I’m an apportioner because I prevent the immediate death of a subject because I’m impregnating that subject

ILikePie5
Does this really need explaining? My role ability is delaying the night-kill. The flavor implies that an adult Xenomorph is performing the night kill. Therefore, an adult Xenomorph is likely scum.


A) That doesn’t have to be necessarily true

B) A justification is what links your character to your role

C) A Facehuggers doesn’t goes against Xenomorphs

ILikePie5

If they get on, which if they’re scum, I doubt they do. If Thoth flips town, there’s almost a 50% chance they’re scum

ILikePie5

Yep, kinda sucks, but it is what it is. Tomorrow everyone is probably going to have to full claim because Luna said the game was very very swingy

ILikePie5

Fine, we can do this the hard way. You’ll be at L-1 soon and you’re going to have to claim

ILikePie5

After you catch up, please put your vote on Thoth for a full claim. He wants to go at this the hard way

ILikePie5
I will full-claim if, and only if, you promise to pressure the SHIT out of Kohai if and when I die and flip town. I expect everyone to hold you accountable for this lest the scum team is you and Kohai.


Youre not in a position to negotiate. Your justification also makes zero sense. So claim

ILikePie5

Kohai is basically CCing Thoth because Kohai is claiming the entire Xenomorph species. Thoth is claiming Facehuggers which is a member of the species. Thoth needs to full claim

ILikePie5

So Kohai is claiming the entire Xenomorph species. That’s directly against Facehugger that Thoth claimed

ILikePie5
I don't want to full-claim because knowing my role could give scum opportunities they should not have. Yeah, I know how scummy that sounds, but in this case it's true. It's not that the Facehuggers are going against the interests of the Xenomorphs, exactly. I know that could have been worded better, but I wasn't sure how. Let me try again.

My justification is that the facehugger interacts with another stage of the xenomorph life cycle in a certain way that causes a certain effect, and, assuming that Xenomorphs in this stage are scum, this effect goes against their interests.


That still does not make sense. And at this point you’ve said enough where scum are going to target you anyways, so just full claim.

ILikePie5
I don't think I can say much without giving away at least what category of role it is.


I’m going to push back on this and say that you need to full claim. How do Facehuggers go against the interests of xenomorphs? That doesn’t make sense at all