ILikePie5
As I said, completely sus. The role is dodgy af, can't be verified, and the justification makes no sense. Him being the third player in scumchat is very believable in light of Thoth and Alyssa's plays. He's the lynch here. Unless you cannot satisfactorily prove your innocence, in which case I'll be in a more difficult spot. 


Which I shall dw

ILikePie5
As I suspected, Rex ain't online and I have to wait til tonight or later for my juicy, juicy data.

Y'all are really cock blocking my instant gratification here. Literally blocking my instant gratification with your cocks. Mm-hmm.


There’s a lot more to talk about like what your thoughts are on Shining’s claim

ILikePie5
Dude, getting a red check on you and still making demands like you're not the one with evidence against him.

If Kohai or Shining or someone were like "yeah I'll prove my innocence later let's just move on" no one would let them get away with that shit lol.


If they were saying they could 100% prove they were town, then yes, I would make REF answer one tiny question

ILikePie5
So we have team "just give Pie what he wants" and team "just give Rex what he wants". I'm now firmly on the second team out of pure counter-culture spite lol. Everyone always sides with Pie and lets him get away with shit they'd never let anyone else get a pass on, like remora latching onto a great white.

Love you though Pie. ❤️ May your eyes stay black and your teeth sharp.



What am I “getting away with” lol

ILikePie5
Lol come on this is just a power trip at this point. I don't want to wait around for Rex to come back online, and even once he does we're just gonna waste time with a pointless macho standoff. For once in your mafia career, just put your cards down first! It won't kill you lol.


It’s one sentence for the price of a confirmed townie

ILikePie5
By my count there's only one other person in the White Tigers, assuming Lunatic recruited again. Proving your innocence right now could narrow our suspects dramatically. My advice is to give Rex reason to doubt his guildmate, not to uncompromisingly demand info while ceding nothing in response to his evidence against you. I think from Rex's responses it's clear he did tell his guildmate, so stop looking for him to admit what we already know, and give us something.


I want it in explicit writing first

ILikePie5
Also, your argument is that you can prove your innocence later, so let's hunt other suspects now. All I'm saying is let's reverse that order. Get your innocence proven so we can eliminate you from POE and move on.


Im literally asking for one small piece of info. A simple yes or no question




ILikePie5
Distract and escalate pressure on another target in hopes of it leading to a quick lynch and escaping to the next DP. Also I don't know what the Ant King has in his arsenal and I'm wary of that; could be you're cooking something that could get you out of this. Your strategy as scum is always to stall, deflect, and use offense as defense.


I will commit to not lynching anyone but myself. Does that make u feel better?


unvote

ILikePie5
Yes, scum Pie claiming to be confirmable while he tries to shift his wagon to another target... unheard of.


Bruh I’m saying lynch me TODAY if what I say in inadequate

ILikePie5
VTL Pie

Sorry, I'm too used to Pie's ways. He's a slippery bastard as scum and always pleads for more time. Shining is definitely the lynch here based on the feebleness of his claim, so if Pie has a way to prove his innocence, I'd rather get that out of the way first.


what scum incentive do I have to say what I said lol

ILikePie5
Hang on, why are you guys asking for my justification and not Awesome's? Anyway, mu justification is dogshit and its obvious Mikal was lazy with AI. My justification is I am silent, but I have a strong desire to win and that makes me a Lightning Rod (Its not actually a LR, mine is just single target).


😂😂😂😂

ILikePie5
This is the one bit that I am struggling with.

You keep speaking like you are in some position of power with leverage as you play with smoke and mirrors and act like you are not the one on trial here. You very simply are. And if you had a reason to play games and hide information that damns Rex or someone else you could do that.


I do have the position of power cause I know I am 100% confirmable and will be by the end of the DP. I don’t have to fake it. I know.


I do not trust you and the situation has everything to do with you. Rex is not on trial imo. You are. And I very much doubt there is not a scum between You/Rex/Shining regardless but the way you are handling the situation looks very scummy to me. 


And I’m telling you that I need the full picture from REF. For the record though I do think Shining is scum


ILikePie5
None of these factors make sense to me questioning if Pie is town while they all make sense for a scum play. Im calling them out to push for pressure that Pie outs information before demanding information thats potentially damaging to the town (and serves no purpose to solve Pie) for Rex to out.


It actually does.

ILikePie5
My entire issue centers around the fact I can not place myself in Pies shoes and understand a town motive.


I know you can’t. It’s because you don’t have the full story. I do. But what’s my scum motivation here lol. He’s already a claimed Cop. And I’m telling you with 100% certainty that I’m innocent.


They feel they can prove themselves. Ok.. sure? But why refuse to reveal bits of information that nail down their potential of defense if they are this totally confirmable townie?


Because I’m 100% confirmable. REF isn’t.


Then there is demanding a full claim from Rex. Why a full claim? Why not specifically ask for the information about the peek? It would slightly make sense if they thought Rex was lying but they have openly said they do not. This is a very weird stance that also does not make sense for town.


I need the full facts. Prima facie I believe REF, but I need all the details


Now they are going after Rex's guild members. What would that possibly have to do with them if they are some confirmed townie that can prove themselves? The only thing that does is shade the potential that they were framed in some way.


Again, this is above you. Find a scum motivation for me to do this lol


To be blunt I am not able to put myself in their shoes and say "As town this makes sense to do" in multiple respects. While I can place myself in their shoes and say "As scum this absolutely makes sense"

Thats my take.


And it’s garbage lol

ILikePie5
Pie is claiming that someone in Rex's guild interfered with the results. If he claims Miller after asking if anyone in the guild knew about the investigation, we lynch him. We are trying too hard to be fancy here.


Exactly, it’s not hard

ILikePie5
What I am trying to avoid is the basic line of a player claiming a red check. Then Pie demanding specifics so they can go "Oh, well your alignment cop is wrong because I have a miller function" or "Your tracker result is wrong because I was swapped last night" etc.

Pie directly claiming if they visited and who at the very least is a step in the right direction. I am not even asking what they did or what their role is. 


I told you that I’m not a miller and idk if I was swapped.

ILikePie5
Im obviously trying to get you to clarify if you have any reason to believe that an alignment cop result would be altered because of whatever you are or if a tracker/detective/motion detector/ anything else looking at movement has a reason to be wrong.


It has nothing to do with me

ILikePie5
Rex essentially confirmed the the guild knew he was investigating you, so let's move on to the next step of this process.


Let him confirm. Put it in writing.

ILikePie5
Pie, how can you prove your innocence?


I literally will. Have a little faith. If I don’t prove myself by the end of the day, lynch me.