ILikePie5

Vote Count

Thoth 7/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted. Kohai, Pie (L-2)

Shining 3/9 - Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz (L-6)

Whiteflame 1/9 - Thoth (L-8)

#1316 has the consolidation of his role

But why did you vote him?

i would not bus this hard day 1. I’ll remind you I was the one who started the Thoth wagon 

I thought it was Mestari and Luna. Point me to where and why u started it

I am genuinely gonna laugh if Kohai and Thoth are scum partners

unvote

VTL Thoth

Vote Count

Thoth 7/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted. Kohai, Pie <-- L2

Shining 5/9 - Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz, Thoth, Magicman <-- L4

Almost seems like he’s trying to out both the Doctor and Jin Woo who is like the main main character in the show?

He's indicated he didn't know Jin-woo might be 3P and wanted to withhold potential town information from scum.

But he doesn’t know either way

If Jin-woo is a third party that doesn't joint win with town, they have every reason to deny being Jin-woo.

If that’s the case, why didn’t he reveal this at the very beginning?

Alyssa said it wasn’t her already, so Helz is the only one left

Lol I know, but you know me. Gotta be as thorough as possible

Explain your entire role in full detail with justification in one post

So ur ancient, good to know

I have information that narrows down who Jinwoo is. Justification is that I am really close to my brother. No, not that like, you doujin-reading freaks.

Why does it matter who Jim Woo is?

What’s the justification for not being recruitable and for being a backup?

What are your thoughts on Thoth claiming backup to a certain role

Any thoughts on how fast the shinning wagon grew? 

Also what are your thoughts on shinning putting you as scum lean but have no thoughts on Thoth, who was the center of discussion almost the entire day phase

I think it’s paranoia of me + he didn’t read the DP at all

Shining still null?

Yes but assuming he doesn’t answer my question, I’ll move him to scum pile. But with him, he’s just lazy in general

Vote count

Shining 6/9 - Kohai, Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz, Thoth, Magicman

Thoth 5/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted

Kohai 1/9 - ILikePie5

#742

But let me update

Solid Town:

Pie

Lunatic

Wylted

Lean Town:

Melz

Mestari

REF

Tilt Town:

Mharman

Wryly

Banana

Null:

Whiteflame

Max

Shining

Tilt Scum:

Vader

Alyssa

Thoth

Lean Scum:

Kohai

Casey

A lot of these are gut reads and based on what I remember. Happy to elaborate as needed

I did lemme link it

have you posted your thoughts on Casey yet?

Sounds like MK-Ultra

All I'm saying is that he's kind of a hypocrite, that's all.

What is hypocritical about leading a wagon for a claim? The person refusing to claim. If he did, I would’ve unvoted and move on. And the person being quick hammered by scum?

The town did win but only because of really poor scum play.

I roleblocked Wryly and Mago. Town played really well that game with REF as Caroler and Luna/Wylted. Kohai was quick hammered by scum and we correctly identified them. That’s a win.

Doesn't mean turboing DP1 was a good move. I've played many chess games where I hung my queen and still won, doesn't mean it wasn't a blunder on my part or that I should intentionally hang my queen in the future and hope it all works out anyway.

Again, we didn’t turbolynch anyone. Scum quickhammered. And Kohai didnt claim when there was sufficient pressure. A better chess analogy would be here that scum blundered their queen by taking my rook, but we still had to make a few moves to checkmate them

You're the one who led the turbolynch on Kohai in DC Players Mafia

It was quick hammered by scum lol, and I roleblocked Wryly for that exact reason. Plus, if he claimed, it would’t have happened

This Shining wagon is a gold mine. This is why we don’t end DPs super early folks

Seriously- what the fuck is the rush to end the day? Just chill. I also have the personal issue of being stuck in court for that murder trial bullshit soon and would rather that happen on a night phase so I have that personal driver.

Are you a defense witness or a prosecution witness lol

I just feel like half the time we lynch people for basically retarded reasons, and like 1/4 of the other time we lynch for reasons that boil down to "uh, DP is ending soon and I guess x is kinda scummy so YOLO???" if you want Thoth dead, fine. Whatever, but I can't really get a good read on anyone that isn't mech cleared or Mestari right now.

Thats not what I asked

L-1 on Thoth

If Mikal gave fake characters, he gave MCs. Here’s the issue with that, if as scum you’re really yourself. Any fake MC you use, it’s hard to prove if you’re not recruited, so you’re kinda forced to stick to being yourself.

If I were the mod, I would give a list of MCs, and a list of roles with no connection between the two. That’s where justification analysis comes into play.