ILikePie5
when I say not reading I’m talking about scumreads. Pretty you you understood that but just to clarify 


Wym? I townread Mago so early on lmao. And REF has done ZERO reads. So it’s ironic that you’re lynching me right now over this.


the thing is, I don’t think what you have on Rex is all that much of a read. Just the easy wagon.


It’s a read. Whether you think it’s legit or not, you have nothing else on me.0


last chance


No. If you’re town, you’re playing a double standard and I’m not going to let that behavior slide. Town can suffer for being full of morons. Lynching their best player over legit nothing while another person is refusing to claim even at L-1. The best I will do is claim at the same time REF does.

ILikePie5
Well... now they're both doing it. I can see both of them being obstinate regardless of alignment, but this is just absurd. Giving this some more thought.

Unvote


There’s a core difference. I responded to an L-1 inquiry for my soft. I followed the golden rule. REF was at L-1 and still refused to claim. So now I’m going to be put at L-1 again. I’m not going to claim if REF doesn’t claim. Period. It’s a double standard. If you want to lynch me, lynch me blind.

ILikePie5
In addendum: The pushes you’ve made are the easy push and your policy. Both of which are easy for you to fall back on, especially when you don’t want to read people.


Do you realize the irony in your statement? It’s an easy push, but he doesn’t want to read people? I’m making the push because I’m reading people lol. Get rid of your stupid paranoia dude. I’m not scum

ILikePie5
It is kind of funny that Pie's doing exactly the same thing I am. Not recognizing the validity of the case/wagon against him and refusing to claim.


There is no case lmao. And it’s pretty obviously a double standard.

ILikePie5
Eh. Vibes posts don’t amount to much. It isn’t hard to speak from the heart on Kohai as scum either. I think the townie things I pointed out aren’t that great.

@Pie still wondering why you wanted to wait to soft so long


Cause I don’t want to reveal any information about myself for free. I thought it was a soft in it self by claiming one of the three if you read my post. And if people didn’t like it, I pointed o it they could get the votes and I will go one step deeper.


As for whether fluffing is scummy or not? Just because you had one bad experience from another player doesn’t mean that he isn’t scum here. And not punishing someone for refusing to claim at L-1 and moving the wagon else where for a claim is just asinine. If you want to lynch me, lynch me blind. Townies who are falling for this are absolutely retarded

ILikePie5

If REF isn’t going to claim even though there is more than an adequate reason for him to, I’m not going to claim either. There’s not an adequate reason for me to claim. And if yall want to play this double standard then just lynch me and lose lol.

ILikePie5
you are. I’m not letting you go for the same thing Rex is doing


Then lynch me lmao. Play the double standard. What reason do you or anyone here to scumread me? I’ve pointed out the reason why I scumread REF. And he said “I should know that he’s town.” I don’t know that at all lmao.

ILikePie5
Not claiming. Just lynch me, it'll out Pie as scum because there's no way he doesn't know I'm town.


How?


I definitely don’t think you’re town. You’ve done nothing today to demonstrate that you’re town.

ILikePie5
...Alright I don't know much a out football so someone else can discuss that.


It means nothing lol. Character claims are basically useless this game because the justifications don’t mean anything. It doesn’t do much anyways. Bears always lost because of opposing teams scoring TDs against them. It’s nothing new

ILikePie5
Why are you acting like I'm asking you to full claim. Just soft. Decision, event, or someone/something still leaves you with a broad cloak of options. I see no reason why there is any disadvantage to doing so, nor any advantage in refusing to do so, aside from not setting precedent of softing -- which only really aids your scum game imo


Alright, I count 4 people. I’m an Event that happened during a game.

ILikePie5
By conditioning town to believe a soft can never be gotten from him, he creates an effective screen for refusing to soft when he is scum. It's a good policy.


I claim when there are 4 people willing to wagon me. Otherwise I’ll soft claim of my own volition and in my own way

ILikePie5
The whole point of softing is to increase credibility by nailing down at least a little detail of your role, something scum would be reluctant to do because they don't want to limit their fake claim choices at all too early. Even if they were given fake claims, they want more time to think of which roles should go with those characters and would be safe to claim, etc.


You haven’t played as scum with me lol. I have everything ready ASAP. Plan A, B, and C. And like you said + OP said. Justifications are pretty much meaningless. Saying I’m one of those 3 is adequate enough for me. If 4 people agree with you, I’ll narrow it down

ILikePie5
I fell the exact same way about people randomly seeking claims DP1. I think it's anti-town, lazy play. I punish it by forcing them to lynch me without claiming.


Just cause you think it’s random doesn’t mean you shouldn’t claim. People want you to claim for explained reasons and it’s guaranteed at L-1 that some townie think you’re scummy and want your claim.

ILikePie5
VTL Pie

Him FOSing others while cannily refusing to soft claim was an early point of suspicion for me last game when he was scum, and I failed to press him on it. Give me at least a definitive soft.


Im allergic to claiming anything. If people want more specifics. Get the support of 4 more people.

ILikePie5
He's probably targeting Rex due to inactivity, no attempt to scumhunt, apparent indifference to who is lynched. The thing is these are all normal behaviors for Rex and don't really indicate anything alignment-wise -- which is not to say that they shouldn't be held to account, I suppose.


Exactly. You can’t change people’s behaviors if there’s no consequences for their actions. Just look at Earth. He’s a lot better now than he was before