Mag1cman

Whiteflame, I already noted his post at the DP1 start, otherwise it’s just vibes. I don’t how to put it but it feels off.

Mag1cman

That being said, Pie’s posts are bad for Pie standards. I feel there was an attempt to buddy Banana DP1, and he’s kinda just letting town fall to its doom this DP. There was something else that bothered me but I forgot what it was.

Mag1cman

Worth noting that Lunatic and Rex had two different reasons for not wanting to VTNL. Rex’s is very towny (self sacrificial) while Lunatic’s is quite lazy. We had four hours and only three people on Rex. We can get 3 people in four to VTNL, I mean shoot, did it real quick and we got a fourth just now. To be clear: Being VTNL-averse isn’t inherently scummy, but saying “oh we dont have time for it” when we only need three/maybe four people in four hours (assuming one is coming off the Rex wagon) comes off as a quickly-drawn, fabricated reason to avoid a VTNL.

Mag1cman

Don’t be daft. If we mislynch you today that puts us in a 4v2 tomorrow, possibly 3v1 after but it’s still MYLO way sooner than needed

Mag1cman


Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 7/7/2026 at 2:25 PM (post #292)

Originally Posted by Mag1cman on 7/7/2026 at 2:11 PM (post #270)
With the vig dead we should be able to VTNL

let’s not make a decision just yet.

VTL: No Lynch

im dead tonight but with 6 townies here we improve our odds of getting helpful night results… as opposed to us doing this earlier.

The vig being dead is irrelevant because he could kill town or scum. It doesn't give us additional mislynches.

my point is that it is highly unlikely there are two deaths in the night, so we’re all but guaranteed to be on odds next DP

Mag1cman

I think Rex is town. The whole “I’m not claiming because my slot was inactive” is genuine and he’s done this plenty as town. I also felt Whiteflame worrying about role claiming after Kohai told us in the OP that he encourages it DP1 comes from the mind of scum who is trying to guess what role Kohai made what characters.

Mag1cman

There’s nothing in the rules that says VTNLs have to be unanimous. We can just make VTNLing the largest wagon and no one will die today.

Mag1cman

Let’s all vote to not have a lynch today


  1. the vig is dead, so this will get us back on odds
  2. gives us all more time to think
  3. gives us more time to post before we commit to a lynch, which helps against the inactivity
  4. doing this now, while there’s more townies alive, instead of later, increases our odds of getting useful night results
Mag1cman

Can’t we just get more people to VTNL than on any other wagon?


It would also give me more time to think if I somehow survive this NP, although that’s unlikely. Does at least buy more time for people to post before committing to a lynch. That helps against the inactivity.

Mag1cman


Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/7/2026 at 2:13 PM (post #272)

Originally Posted by Mag1cman on 7/7/2026 at 12:11 PM (post #270)
With the vig dead we should be able to VTNL

let’s not make a decision just yet.

VTL: No Lynch

im dead tonight but with 6 townies here we improve our odds of getting helpful night results… as opposed to us doing this earlier.
I dont think a no lynch is possible. I actually would support one here though. We would need every single player with a vote to unvote though, otherwise it will default to plurality. And Banana has been missing for a while now.


VTNLs have to be unanimous in this game?

Mag1cman

With the vig dead we should be able to VTNL


let’s not make a decision just yet.


VTL: No Lynch


im dead tonight but with 6 townies here we improve our odds of getting helpful night results… as opposed to us doing this earlier.

Mag1cman

If it’s between Rex and Whiteflame, I’m thinking Whiteflame.


was sus of Banana’s DP1 until the confirmation came in. Doesn’t change much about Pie, I wonder about efforts to buddy Banana. Lunatic is still around in my head.


I think both scum are in Pie, Whiteflame, Lunatic.


Admittedly I feel less confident in Wryly and Wylted being town after mulling it over a bit more, but I still kinda feel that way.

Mag1cman


Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/6/2026 at 6:01 PM (post #188)

Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/6/2026 at 1:57 PM (post #178)
Putting him at L-1 when he's just a blank slot? Really?
Didn't know he was at l-1, but l-1 isn't the end of the world either. Puts more pressure on him to respond faster. Anyways looks like someone unvoted, so hes l-2 now.


hmmmmm. Maybe. Maybe if see some towny things in you I’ll let it slide

Mag1cman


Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/6/2026 at 6:02 PM (post #189)

Originally Posted by Mag1cman on 7/6/2026 at 3:36 PM (post #183)

Originally Posted by Lunatic on 7/6/2026 at 3:52 PM (post #177)
Ill help with some pressure on magic

VTL: Mag1cman

hate this post
You... hate that I voted you for reads and activity? Okay I guess lol


moreso that you felt the need to help pressure when there was enough people on me already.


it’s a “hey look I’m doing something!” type of post. It put me at L-1 too, so no regard for the risk there.

Mag1cman

I am the doctor, justification is just Kohai glazing FDR about healing the nation and giving hope to it amidst the Great Depression.


Which isn’t even true. The New Deal was complete failure and WWII was actually what got us out of the Depression. But whatever.

Mag1cman

Chicago traffic is pure rage bait.


There’s no danger, but you are packed in like sardines going 15-25 mph on an eight lane highway. If you ever switch lanes to get into whichever lane seems to be crawling slightly faster, jokes on you because everyone else just had the same idea and now it’s the slowest lane.

Mag1cman

my only thought atm is that it is weird that Lunatic talked to me like he’s knows I’m town but apparently never had an opinion on Shining.


I have not even read DP1 yet. Or much of anything this DP. I’ll be around tomorrow after 5.