Mag1cman

#8

Let me save you the trouble. You saw my Discord status as online at a time when people are normally awake in my time zone, so you figured I was waiting for the game to start since I have admitted to preferring scum.

Someone said this feels defensive from Thoth. Eh. It's not very in-your-face but maybe? Eh.


The bigger issue is that this post reveals he's conscious about when he appears online on Discord. I don't care about Discord activity, but being very conscious of your own Discord activity is scummy.


#10

I’ve been thinking about what Helz said in Solo Leveling about how DP1 should be played with the intent of getting information to read from later. I’ve complained more than once about how there’s usually nothing to do on DP1 except place my vote at random and wait. I have seen the light now. We must take stances and accept that some of them will be wrong.

I remember Thoth always being weird, but the self-meta commentary, I haven't seen (or haven't noticed). Are there examples of him doing this as town?


#25

Its just easy to bully you into slipping. 3 games running you have been a dp1 scum lynch for saying weird shit. Pressure on you is never bad because the more you talk the more you slip.

So you are either quiet and its prob a scum tell

Or you talk a lot and if you are scum, you inevitably will throw

On one hand, I like that Mikal saw the vision. On the other hand, telling Thoth what you're doing kinda defeats the point. Scummy aspect. Pointing out that Thoth quieting down is scummy could be a form of blackmail to get Thoth to keep posting, for obvious reasons. Towny aspect. I feel conflicted on this post.


#26

Also angle shooting isn't banned. He said minimal. So im sure ill pull from my arsenal at some point. Plus wf wont kill me. So not to worried about it

Gut says this feels honest, but the confidence that Whiteflame wouldn't kill him is a little scummy. Think about it like this: If Mikal's OGI is fake bc he's scum, no mod would punish that.


#27

VTL: Magoroth

I like Mikals logic

Same issue as the second previous post. There's something to be said about Wylted being impulsive at times. I think that gives him more of a pass, although it doesn't make the post towny.


#31

Im also okay with just hammering thoth for memes. Little over 20 percent chance to be right [likely]

The first sentence feels like it lands in "too scummy to be scum" territory. Like the type of thing so brazen scum wouldn't dare say it.


#33

Im always down to hammer thoth or mag (after last game)

Same as previous.


#42

Nah i wouldn't be talking as scum. Just up seeing if drunk you slips

I don't agree with this point. Moreover, the need to justify ("I'm just seeing if you slip bro!") once again feels off. Drunk scum Lunatic still might do it, but giving your intentions while conducting the experiment still hurts it (*might* hurt it in this case).

#46, #50

My gut is telling me that Mikal is the scummiest scum who ever did scum


I’m honestly starting to reconsider that scumread since this is Mikal we are talking about, but I’ll park my vote for now and watch as the day progresses.

I’ll soft that I am male.


So, jumps on Mikal, then starts to reconsider because it's Mikal. This honestly reeks of a situation where a mafioso makes a push, and then realizes it could get him scumread (in this case, responding to Mikal's pressure with "my gut tells me he's scum" could be called out as OMGUS), or a teammate tells him that it was a bad push. The result is the same: A sudden withdrawal/pause with little explanation.


#61

It was kind of RVS but he was not taking the bait. That said I think it’s unlikely Thoth is scum three times in a row. But pretty sure I’ve said the same thing about Whiteflame and been wrong in the past. That said there is a world where Mikal’s Thoth push is not just an opportunistic thing and something he genuinely thinks will go somewhere useful. It’s early game though so we will see. With 9 players and having so many strong players in this one I’d rather focus people like pie and Mikal and yourself early on though

Pressuring Mikal is fair, can't say I blame him for that. Was Lunatic pretending to be drunk to add to it? If so, an interesting idea that I will not be stealing lol.


The gamblers' fallacy on Thoth is just bad, the sentence after is worse. If you've been wrong on that before, why do it again? Gambler's fallacy is and always will be obvious. Says the push on Thoth is opportunistic. Possibly.


Last sentence probably pairs scum Lunatic with someone outside of Pie, Mikal, and I (Banana, Wylted, Magoroth, Rex, Thoth). Of those names, Thoth sticks out the most for obvious reasons.


#67-71 is very typical of Pie, and very much NAI.

Mag1cman

This is lame. Is there anyone in here who posts a lot less as scum, that any of y'all have observed?

Mag1cman

Alright. Got some okay-ish data points from that RVS. Will be back to analyze them in a few hours.


Only issue is that I don’t really have anyone to compare them to. Low activity is scummy at this stage.

Mag1cman

VTL Thoth


sorry whiteflame.


I have an OGI read but due to the game’s res I cannot give the reasoning

Mag1cman

Frieren Mafia

Mag1cman · 6 months ago


whiteflame wrote:
well id played but pie is gonna ista lynch me for complying with him and he always wins so id rather not go through that again, good luck guys hav fun

Your choice, though I'll point out that technically, he didn't win the vote. He won the coin flip.


🤓

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

We specifically chose Bullish for this because we noticed he frequently left sentences off without a period.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago


Lunatic wrote:

Mag1cman wrote:

Bullish wrote:
The reason I sussed Mikal is because I modded a live game where I gave him or somebody in the game a role where you're forced to say "lol" at the end of every sentence, or something like that.

Kohai came up the idea to make you do something tedious that you'd eventually forget to do, and I decided that two periods per sentence was the best idea within his idea.
Brother thats the easiest black mail to win ever. How did he fuck that up lmao

I mean, all you have to do is not pay attention for one sentence of one post and then you're dead. If I were more active, I would've pestered him throughout the DP to try and increase the odds.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago


Bullish wrote:
The reason I sussed Mikal is because I modded a live game where I gave him or somebody in the game a role where you're forced to say "lol" at the end of every sentence, or something like that.


Kohai came up the idea to make you do something tedious that you'd eventually forget to do, and I decided that two periods per sentence was the best idea within his idea.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

Also, I did not see Whiteflame dropping hints about his role. Stupid hail mary, should've claimed vanilla. Claiming jailer would've bought me another DP, but then I'd have to justify not being dead later.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

As for Kohai's crashout:


He didn't play well this game, but he did improve... the bar is pretty low. Some people have natural talent, and some people have to work really hard if they wanna git gud. He's in the latter group. It'll be a long road for him.


But as I told him, he should take a break. A couple games off was good for me and it'll be good for him. And then he should decide what his future in mafia and on the site is.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

Mikal wrote:
Mag1cman wrote:
Elo is gay. Just take your win.

Don't do that shit again. I won't either. I regret doing it.

Again same thing I said to kohai. I literally asked lol.


I'm talking about the whole "I'm gonna modkill myself" thing.


Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

Scum MVP for getting replaced out. Just stop saying weird shit bro, you can do it.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

The whole pretend to be wylted/bullish thing was just the wrong plan. By the time I had spare moment to look at thread (while preparing for said tounrament), I saw people thought I was Oberon, so I just rolled with it. It was a great excuse to lurk while continuing tournament prep and play, but trying to get away with some things and have people say "lol that's just wylted/bullish for ya" did not work out.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

At first I wanted a no-contest. I just didn't want to have a scum game losing streak. But, now I don't care enough. Some BS definitely happened in this game, and I wasn't locked in anyway. So it's a loss with an asterisk and he can declare a mafia loss if he wants to. Also, I could not care less about my elo.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago


Magoroth wrote:
I don't generally assign MVPs as host since I don't think that's my business, but I thought Mestari played quite well

Alr Mestari. You're pretty good when locked in. But I was not locked in this game. Was preparing/playing a pokemon tournament until mid DP2.


Locked-in Mag1c has not dueled locked-in Mestari yet. >:)

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago

Elo is gay. Just take your win.


Don't do that shit again. I won't either. I regret doing it.

Mag1cman

Amber Endgame

Mag1cman · 6 months ago


A-Brand wrote:
Originally, Kohai and I leaned toward killing Lunatic first, but Magic wanted Julian instead. I actually don't entirely remember why, but it ended up being a great choice, even if the game didn't go our way in the end.


  1. Lunatic was sussing Pie so I wanted him alive to keep duking it out with Pie
  2. Vader would've likely been against Pie, so it was a sneaky way for us to be able to say "scum Pie sneakily killed one of his detractors," while keeping his main detractor alive to thunderdome with him, while we argued "scum Pie wouldn't kill Lunatic bc it would be too obvious."
  3. Vader committing to the 50/50 immediately told me he had a way of dealing with whoever survived the rand between Banana/Pie.


DP2 I noticed Lunatic was telling people to "explain why you should be alive," which was similar to how the jailer talked in Pie's will. So then i thought I had been wrong on Vader and the jailer was Lunatic. But nope, the jailer was Vader and I was right the first time.


We did not realize the Janitor didn't give us the PM in this game, which was pretty weird. If I had known that, I would not have janitored any of the kills tbh.

Mag1cman

I wouldn’t have even done the poison gambit had Zaradi and Thoth not gone down early. I had more than enough ways of getting myself townread in that world.

Mag1cman

Anyway for most of the game I was townread. I do feel odds of victory were real good if it weren’t for the slip at the start of the game. Next time I roll scum yall are cooked.