Mag1cman

Pie/Kohai being good info on each other, Thoth being good info on Alyssa, but Thoth has a falsifiable role claim. I prefer VTNL. Beyond that, preferred lynches are Thoth, Pie, Kohai, Helz, in that order.

Mag1cman

Thoth is still my strongest scumread. I get that Whiteflame says it's not likely to be a fake claim for being so obscure, but then we have to ask why he has something so obscure as town. I still hate the behavior there.


He would be my lynch here but 1. he has claimed a role that can be tested. 2. if he is scum, he only buys at most 1 DP.


May be 0 DPs bought in practice. I didn't like the math on Mestari's idea to vtnl multiple times, but with no NK, a single vtnl is pretty good. VTNLing here is basically just extending DP1, but with a halftime for night actions (and hence info from said night actions); we still have 17 heading into DP2.



Mag1cman

everyone else is still null, except for Casey but I haven't evaluated her yet. I still need to do that.


I dont wanna lynch Airmax. I would rather give him more time show up than lynch blind. We could stall out the DP to do that, only hammering/vtnling at the last hour.

Mag1cman

For Alyssa it comes down to 1. Thoth's affiliation. 2. Establishing high confidence in Alyssa being the no.1 teammate suspect if Thoth is scum. There's a chance Thoth made his Helz/Mestari confusion and is scum anyway which would negate the argument against Alyssa. However, if Thoth is scum and the story is a cover-up, I agree with Alyssa's defense about Thoth just having to ask Mikal who Mestari is. There are other names Lunatic listed but idt they're likely under the assumption he made in his exploration of other possibilities. There is a TMI argument, though: Alyssa's defense, while being a rebuttal to the common argument against her, assumes Thoth's defense is a lie. But it still just comes down to solving Thoth first.


Helz, I agree Mestari is town but his case for it was bad, felt forced. It's weird to me that he wouldn't consider Mestari joking, and instead echoes Kohai's misinterpretation. He's also claimed having a role which I think is mad if he actually has one. Wa also quick to give his character. The lack of concern in both cases is scummy to me. Had some 3p theory which has merit but combined with said lack of concern makes me wonder about projecting 3p. Could be 3p blending in on scumhunting or scum looking for 3p, I can see either.


Pie, I don't like the logic on the Mestari wagon. Pie is aggro but his logic for stuff is worse when he's scum. Really just that.


Kohai, did seem opportunistic in joining that Mestari wagon. I don't really hold Kohai missing Mestari's joke against him anymore. I thought about it but if anyone misses a joke it would be him, and he was tipsy.


Pie and Kohai are obviously pitted against each other here. It seems early for a distancing play, but with fake claims a distance play isn't so bad... but then Kohai just claimed himself. think it's more likely Kohai and Pie are unpaired off that.

Mag1cman
Yeah, there was no need for me to soft that when the soft is so transparent anyway. I'm unrecruitable. If I would have been recruited on night 0, the recruit would have been moved to a player of my choice. I also have two other abilities that I'd rather keep secret for now.

oh i didn't even see this. interesting


the presence of two extra abilities feels a little complex for a given fake claim. hm

Mag1cman

even though scum has fake claims? They could have character or role claims or both; how does that factor in? Like is the character someone you would/wouldn't expect to be a fake claim?

Mag1cman
Alright. I think I get what you're hinting at.

hey theme knowledge guy: You think we should push for his full claim or not? I kinda wanna push for it

Mag1cman
I'm Sung Jin-Ah


anyone here familiar enough with the theme to tell me if this is enough to drop the issue? I wanna go for the full if not

Mag1cman

alr yall I know how I'm reading people but I'm having trouble articulating/putting pen to paper- this feels like an assigned essay than anything fun. For the past few hours ive just been sitting at my desk fidgeting like the kid from the ADHD studies, checking my phone, or I've just been wandering around my apartment doing other things to try and clear my mind. I've gotten nothing accomplished and I feel burnt out. I'm sorry. I know you people wonder why I'm not always locked in while playing mafia (because you've seen me do great things when focused) and my answer is that I can only focus when I get lucky enough to be in the right headspace. Just the way I am


So you get the abridged version of my read list


Lunatic and Wylted are obviously town confirmed.


Townreading Mestari for various things I find towny, even if I ignore the thing he told me not to townread him for (feels a little egotistical tbh- "you don't know what I can pull as scum!" and yet every time I've seen someone give that line they're town- like town is just more likely to express that kind of ego). The frustration with Lunatic outing himself. Noting Thoth's likely slip. Asking people for input/activity. I think the first and last ones can be faked, but combined, they look better. I also hate the wagon on him at the start. You can't tell me mafia wasn't trying for an early opportunity/being opportunistic about one. Just too random of a wagon


Townreading Rex for his failure to see that he was invited by one of the faction leaders, so he's obviously not paying attention to his discord. Beyond that there's not much else.


Whiteflame was the one who pointed out that Rex could be town for not noticing his invite. It's a good point on Rex but it doesn't really clear Whiteflame. He can buddy with Rex, but atm there's no evidence of it. He does have a lot of good posts. The refutation of Thoth's strategy idea to not recruit was good, and his post against softing. Combine this with how he wants to stave off the VTNL discussion for later and he's someone who picks his battles based on what he thinks is the most efficient use of his time. And I do think not wanting to waste time is pretty townie. Whiteflame is really good at faking his town behavior when he's scum, but this is so far a good sign. Slight town.


Going to Thoth, proposing we discuss whether or not we should soft feels weak- you'd think he'd want to actually give a pro-soft or anti-soft stance and then ask others for input. Instead, he just looks for town approval. Feels like a fake contribution. And his idea on recruiting is just bad. With Mestari's VTNL idea I could at least see where's he's coming from- here I'm a little baffled. The elephant is of course his post about how Mestari is a fearkill, and that does look like a slip. Thing is, Thoth is weird. He is baffling. He gets frequently mislynched or almost mislynched off of saying the weirdest shit. I've seen similar situations, the question is if this is too weird even for him. I do lean yes and that he's scum but I want his claim before going for a lynch.


more coming. I slightly scumread Helz and Pie, feel conflicted on Alyssa and Kohai. null on everyone else- although Casey's posted more and I need to re-evaluate her

Mag1cman

Thoth 6/9 - Kohai, Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Mag1c

Kohai 2/9 - ILikePie5, wylted

Alyssa 1/9 - Helz


Idea: If you vote, you update the vote count


Mag1cman

You mean this?


also not gonna hop on your wagon just yet


already explained that


As for the wagon, 1. it's so random; I'm not convinced by tone arguments 2. I kinda townread your frustration with the guild leaders outing themselves
only reason I would join in the future is if town can't get around it, at which point I'd just do it to advance the game. That's what I mean by that
Mag1cman
I admit I may be a bit tipsy from my four cups of wine but bro your reaction isn't giving you any town points

He made a joke and you're overanalyzing it. Go sleep off the wine

Mag1cman
That’s an oddly specific guess.

it's in the start of day post


Objective
The primary goal is to eliminate the mafia.
There are 4 mafia
There may be third-party roles with their own win conditions