Mag1cman
Alyssa begins by accusing Mestari of claiming godfather on discord. Maestari never CCs this so I assume alyssa is being honest. I've seen town players do far worse than that and got lynched for it so normally I would not put too much stock into this. That said, maestari's reaction to this was absolutely bad and scummy af. He litterally pulled a mag1c (sorry mag1c) on the second page.


By "pulling a Mag1c," do you mean refusing to claim? I was town when I did that.

Mag1cman

Do you think mafia would be risky enough to suggest a VTNL tho? No matter what, it attracts attention to the person suggesting it.


I think it's just his idea that's not really a good idea

Mag1cman
The VTNL plan is to VTNL for multiple days quickly so we can enable power roles then use them, not just VTNL DP1.

And what do you mean by "just yet"?

premise is fine but when calculating idt it's good in practice


As for the wagon, 1. it's so random; I'm not convinced by tone arguments 2. I kinda townread your frustration with the guild leaders outing themselves


only reason I would join in the future is if town can't get around it, at which point I'd just do it to advance the game. That's what I mean by that


I remember there being someone named magic, but they didn't make enough of an impression for me to remember more.

I am not LikeMagic. I was Mharman. I think you only played Philosophers IV with me. That was my first game.

Mag1cman

4 mafia, possible third parties, 13 or less town


if we vtnl twice that's 2 maf kills and 2 more recruits


If I'm reading the rules correctly, that's 5 members in each guild by that point,


11 v 4 tho assuming no third parties. But with possible third parties plus possible faction sabotage, I don't think the extra night actions are worth sacrificing a few townies in that circumstance


The premise of the idea is fine but i dont think it works when we get down to the specifics.

Mag1cman

Airmax runs the site and uses his birthday as a competing holiday to Christmas, so he’s got some major Jewery going on. Thing is, as one of the more laissez faire mods, he doesn’t really censor the goys. So I’d rather give him my shekels than some other Jews in the site

Mag1cman

1.Lunatic

2.Vader

3.Whiteflame

4.Kohai

5.Banana

6.iLikePie5

7.CaseyRisk

8.Shining

9.Mestari

10.Wylted

11.Alyssa

12.Airmax1227

13.Wryly

14.Helz

15.Thoth

16.Mag1cman

17.RexFavilla

Mag1cman

"Lynching"

Mag1cman · 8 months ago

What it really means and why? Who gives a fuck? Point is if people are butthurt hearing it no harm in trying to be considerate.

I would rather gatekeep people if they’re gonna be that butthurt…


I would push a separate issue I see as far as community management in the way that is enforced. I will publicly say that I think some sites have utterly lost the plot with moderation weaponizing victimization. People are allowed to force their will on others voicing that they are offended in a toxic and harmful way to communities. I would simply voice that the way such a policy is implemented should be controlled.


…because of situations like this. Catering to butthurt people is exactly how you get a site full of easily offended people who will write rules against being a big meanie and whine to moddy when you make a microaggression.


There’s also the fact that we are primarily a debate website. Censorship and debate are like oil and water. We need to have a thick-skinned culture to even have productive discussion. Such a rule in the mafia community would harm the other side of the site as well.


Without saying what a place is there is a major mafia community that has a secret list of naughty words they police to the extreme while refusing to release what they consider not ok to say. They smite people for slipping up and saying commonly used words such as lynch. They attack users for having a different culture and punish them based upon unspoken standards. Should we move in that direction? I do not think so. And I do not think such policy even remotely creates cleaner Mafia games.

if you dont want to name names that’s fine and im not gonna encourage you to do so


But I wanna take guess and say that this is MafiaShit.


I think a middle ground exists strongly encouraging users to not use the term "Lynch" and punishing only if they are using it with intent to offend or chronically ignoring said policy without becoming one of the places that virtue signals and causes harm to the community in the name of standing on a soap box. Thats my two cents


hard “no” on the middle ground fallacy here. I’m not giving thin-skinned people an inch; they will take a mile. this middle ground is virtue signaling too much already.


if someone is so offended by a word, because of an entirely different context, then the problem is with them. They either change that mindset or they don’t belong here. People who cannot comprehend an alternative context, are weak-minded. Not just because they get offended easily, but because they run their possible viewpoints through a social acceptability filter before they allow themselves to believe in anything, like an AI. Such people would be harmful to the mafia culture we have, and DCraft’s aim at becoming and remaining the best debate website.

Mag1cman

I didn’t make this setup btw. I just told Banana the basics and told her to keep it simple. I think it’s a little townsided, but it’s ok.


She also consulted Mikal on some things.

Mag1cman
Mag1cman (wylted)
You win with the Town.
In Legend of Zelda Mafia, you copy-pasted your role PM and got mod-killed for it, which immediately revealed you as innocent. In this game, we will focus more on the innocent part than on the mod-kill part, so you are the Self-Activating Innocent Child. At any time during any day before MYLO / LYLO, you may confirm your role by copy-pasting it into, or posting a screenshot of it in, the day thread and not getting mod-killed for it. WARNINGS: To use this ability, you must post your entire role PM verbatim, including these warnings. You may not use this ability once MYLO / LYLO has been reached, even if MYLO / LYLO is reached during the day. Breaking either of these rules will make copy-pasting your role PM punishable by mod-kill as usual. If it will be possible to reach MYLO / LYLO during a day after start-of-day, there will be a public warning beforehand. Obviously accidental violations of these rules will be forgiven.

lol

Mag1cman

Mod-Kill Impact

Mag1cman · 8 months ago

I could not care less about my elo. I knew what I was getting into. I also didn’t care if I was converted to 3P survivor.


At any rate, I say it should depend on the host. If you don’t like a host’s ruling on that, don’t play their games then. No need for any more rulebooking. This community can regulate itself. Moderation is gay.

Mag1cman

"Lynching"

Mag1cman · 8 months ago

If you are offended by a word, because of a way that word was used in *an entirely different context* that is not everyone else’s problem. Just your skill issue.


You don’t see white people getting offended by the term “animal crackers,” do you?

Mag1cman
Pent up frustration or not i don’t regret it.
just listen to the defense more. Consider the points.


For clarification, I don’t regret pasting my PM.


I do regret the things (insults, profanity, all caps) I said in anger, and I do apologize for that. It will not happen again.