Mag1cman
Whats all this talk of me being a fence sitter? My position was that both you and pie are town knuckleheads with big penis syndome. A fencesitter would be someone waiting to take the side of whoever is winning.

fair enough

Mag1cman
Pie-Whiteflame and Pie-Rex seem to be the strongest pairings imo. Lunatic-Whiteflame is a lesser pairing. Rex-Whiteflame is unknown territory, but possible. Pie-Lunatic is a weaker pairing idea, slightly stronger as an unpairing idea. Lunatic-Rex is a long shot.

I could almost put Pie-Lunatic in the same territory as Lunatic-Whiteflame off that DP2 start. Hm. but that’s still not one of the strongest pairings.


I’m kinda of at an impasse with Lunatic. I think there’s things independently scummy about him, but the pairings aren’t exactly the strongest. Am I wrong on what I think is scummy on Lunatic, or am I underestimating the pairings he could have with some other people?



Mag1cman

Make no mistake, scum was always going to be invested in me since the night phase began and they realized they could form a plan around my mistake from last DP.


On that note: Anyone else invested in me that I should know about?

Mag1cman

Not only is he opportunistic with his activity, and his pushes, not only is his logic completely horrendous and he is the #1 person who should know better, but he’s got some strong pairing arguments.

Mag1cman

Those are my jumbled up thoughts, putting it all together:


Pie-Whiteflame and Pie-Rex seem to be the strongest pairings imo. Lunatic-Whiteflame is a lesser pairing. Rex-Whiteflame is unknown territory, but possible. Pie-Lunatic is a weaker pairing idea, slightly stronger as an unpairing idea. Lunatic-Rex is a long shot.

Mag1cman
Lunatic-Whiteflame has a pairing argument but it’s small. Basically the idea is fencesitting + opportunism, with Lunatic being quicker to end his fencesitting. I played a scum game with Thoth where I was the aggressive one and Thoth sat back a little bit more.

a little more difficult but possible for Lunatic to be a fence sitter and then flip a switch and start pushes. I’ve done it as scum. Although it does help his defense.

Mag1cman
I don’t really see a pairing argument for Pie and Lunatic. I haven’t seen one press the other so lower odds of unpairing. , but it’s better than nothing, so it has some merit.

Lunatic going out of his way to argue against Pie’s narrative has some merit, but I’ve had games where I’d refute my scum partner and then push someone else.

Mag1cman

I don’t really see a pairing argument for Pie and Lunatic. I haven’t seen one press the other so lower odds of unpairing. , but it’s better than nothing, so it has some merit.


Rex-Whiteflame, idk


Lunatic-Whiteflame has a pairing argument but it’s small. Basically the idea is fencesitting + opportunism, with Lunatic being quicker to end his fencesitting. I played a scum game with Thoth where I was the aggressive one and Thoth sat back a little bit more.

Mag1cman

Both scum are in Pie/Rex/Lunatic/Whiteflame, 100%.


I can see pairing arguments for Pie-Whiteflame, Pie-Rex, and Whiteflame-Lunatic.


Rex-Lunatic could be unpaired. It could be a distancing, but given the situation I’d say 80-20 Lunatic and Rex are unpaired because Lunatic doesn’t need to for Rex if he’s scum, he can just go for me. So he doesn’t need to distance at this moment. And of he’s speculating some negative consequences for pushing me down the line, he would stop Rex from pushing me. So the lack of narrative collusion + Lunatoc sussing Whiteflame + possible opportunity to go for me = strong unpairing argument.

Mag1cman

You going to hand waive away past games anyway, just like you just did. And like you’re ignoring the meat of my defense.



When I showed up to the thread, Thoth was not in my town pile. He was absent from the thread, so he hadn’t claimed yet. He was at L-1. We were in low time.


These factors combined, I could’ve easily hammered, but I didn’t.

Mag1cman
This is a bit suspicious to me. It reads like a scum player planning out an outrageous action and having an example from a past game in the holster to justify it.

to be clear, this is the Kafka Trap


Can anyone recall a game where Magic was lynched as scum? Did he rage this hard?

and this a set up for another one



why in the world would Rex be asking for past games, if past examples could just be me justifying my play with past examples?

Mag1cman

I don’t like how Rex let things play out for the start of this DP, only to jump in now.


i picked this up from MU guide to scumhunting, but scum likes to have most of their activity in the mid phase. They don’t like being around at the SoD to draw attention and (depending on how the wagons are going) they will disappear near the end of the phase.

Mag1cman
Can anyone recall a game where Magic was lynched as scum? Did he rage this hard?

I could give you some but then “Mharman is justifying his rage using past games!”


this is a Kafka Trap, a well-known circular argument that presupposes my guilt. If there’s no precedent, I’m scum, if I cite a precedent, then my defense is what makes me guilty.



Mag1cman
This is a bit suspicious to me. It reads like a scum player planning out an outrageous action and having an example from a past game in the holster to justify it.

look at the incentives dumbass. Hella opportunistic

Mag1cman
Rex feels like his normal town meta is just solely on vibes, but I don't care for the wagon on Thoth. Harder to read because he is almost as inactive as Shining. Still null.

Elaborating: the town vibes and Thoth wagon just kinda cancel each other out in my book. one thing I sus, one thing I townread.

Mag1cman

Wylted obvious town for reasons from last DP, Magoroth I think is asking all the right questions, just has a crystal clear thought process which makes him vibes town, posting style reminds me of the game where I was hard sussing him and he was town. I don't remember what the game was called. Even his questioning me on why I townread him from last DP reinforces my townread of him.


Thoth I still think is town for reasons from last DP, but I'll admit some legit questions were asked that he should answer.